Fear is derived from the unknown, and like Newall and Sims pointed out, now that your players have heard the story, that mystery is dead. So if you want to keep the horror alive, you need to make a new mystery. Their solution for Protocol was to make an entirely new fear-based magic system inspired by alchemy. You can do that too.
I made a setting where nightmares are psychic diseases that start manifesting in the waking world as they become recurring dreams that slowly infect the host’s brain. Eventually, the host hits a point where they either get killed by a dangerous manifestation, or they reach symbiosis with the nightmare, becoming a “boogeyman” (avatar). Other people exposed to nightmare manifestations can then also become infected due to the frightening experiences causing nightmares about the things that happened to them, spreading the psychic disease further.
But maybe you don’t want to come up with a new fear system. Instead try creating new entities. Smirke didn’t get everything. Maybe another eccentric victorian heard of his list of fourteen and got so petty about disagreeing that they made a different list of fears that splits them up differently (causing academic infighting between cultists to this day). Maybe the fourteen are Major Fears, but there are also several Minor Fears with their own monsters and artefacts. Maybe the fourteen are umbrella categories, and contain multiple sub-entities that sometimes work at cross-purposes.
I created some example entities here:
The Famine: fear of starvation, poverty, and deprivation. Manifests as rat-monsters and emaciated figures.
The Whisper: fear of being misunderstood, lied about, bullied, or excluded. Manifests as lawyers, reporters, social media callout posts.
The Mirror: fear of being someone you don’t want to be. Manifests as doppelgängers, echoes, vengeful figures from your past.
The Coil: fear of snakes, poison, plots and conspiracies, and not noticing danger until it’s too late. Manifests as snake-monsters.
The Inevitable: fear of being pursued, slowly but inescapably, by something you can’t outfight (incl’ fears of mortality). Manifests as zombies, and tall bipedal inhuman things that always seem to find you again no matter how far you run.
The Gore: fear of violence, pain, and the insides ending up on the outside. Manifests as slasher villains, carnivores, and viscera/blood.
The System: fear of being dehumanised, a cog in the machine, or formulaically analysed/controlled. Manifests as killer robots, machinery, men in black.
The Boss: fear of authority being wielded against you, or being crushed by the weight of its responsibility. Manifests as police, CEOs, politicians, etc.
The Worthless: fear of failure, defeat, being wrong, incompetence. Manifests as people who are better at things than you are and usurp more and more of your life from you, or people who are bad at things and you find yourself falling to their level and getting lumped in with them.
The Glitch: fear of technological addiction, losing control over technology, or of the line between real and virtual breaking down. Manifests as computer game elements showing up in real life, getting trapped in virtual environments, having you account for real life suspended.
The Thief: fear of being robbed, losing things, or resource/energy-drains. Manifests as cat burglars, heist teams, master hackers, parasites, vampires.
The Intruder: fear of your spaces being invaded. Manifests as figures in your room at night, bug infestations, phroggers.
The Tumour: fear of bodies going wrong, disease and health issues, disfigurement, and pain. Manifests as fleshy abominations, surgeons, or disease.
The players already know what The Magnus Institute, London’s deal is. So give them new jobs. In my nightmare setting, the players work at a psychiatric hospital in the chronic nightmares ward. You could just as easily have them work in an antiques shop, for the CIA, or at a take-away restaurant with a menu system they can’t understand. Anywhere that they could plausibly encounter The Horrors on a regular basis, either by studying them, selling them, hunting them down and murdering them, or having them as customers.
Above all, change rituals. I cannot stress enough how little players will care about an apocalypse that they know isn’t going to happen. What I recommend instead is to make rituals not bring the entity fully into the world but rather do something smaller. Maybe a successful ritual gives an avatar more powers. Maybe it creates a major artefact like the coffin, or gives birth to a really strong monster. Maybe it causes a disaster (such as a corruption ritual causing an epidemic, a desolation ritual causing massive fires across a city, an eye ritual creating a new type of mass-surveillance, etc.). It should be something that the players would want to stop (if only so that a rival isn’t empowered), but that they actually believe will happen if they fail to do so. Or maybe the players are cultists, and want to pull off their own ritual.
pixelskylines
germansingergirl
2087
ellievsbear
dailybridgerton
discoholicmusic
