Andrew Lloyd Webber- Phantom of the Opera Soundtrack
This review is going to look a bit different, because this isn’t an album- it’s a soundtrack. A soundtrack functions quite differently than other bodies of work. In a traditional album, the music is all there is, but in a soundtrack, the music is to accompany a story. So, instead of judging the music, I’ll be evaluating how well the music accompanies the story.
Phantom of the Opera is my favorite musical. I first watched it at age 7 (I should have not been allowed to watch this at age 7...) and it’s just such a beautiful story and brings back such good memories. However, the soundtrack is not my favorite musical soundtrack. The other day I was asking myself how Phantom could be my favorite musical despite the fact that the soundtrack isn’t my favorite. I mean, I love the story. But isn’t the music the most important part of a musical? The songs aren’t bad at all, some of them I’d consider to be up there as the best broadway songs ever written. It’s just that I enjoy other soundtracks more. But then, an explanation hit me: even though the soundtrack isn’t my favorite, it accompanies the show perfectly and enhances it, making it even better.
If you don’t know the plot of the show, I’ll describe it incredibly briefly. (SPOILER WARNING! I’m literally going to spoil the whole plot from here on out so if you don’t want it spoiled just skip to the last paragraph!!) The story follows Christine, who’s a rising opera star. She performs at an opera house which has a ‘phantom’ that lives there, causing things to go wrong. She gets voice lessons from a mysterious voice in her walls which she calls the ‘angel of music’. One day, her invisible teacher reveals himself and he’s the phantom that haunts the opera house. She follows him into the canals below, and he sings to her and he falls in love with her. Problem: he’s a complete creep, and Christine has another man she loves. So, she leaves but the phantom keeps pursuing. He’s mad at the direction the opera house is going in so he threatens the directors and causes problems to get his way, all while pushing Christine to be in the spotlight. The phantom keeps causing problems, kills a few people, Christine kind of falls for him but tries to stay faithful to her other man. At the end he kidnaps her but once he realizes she won’t be happy with him, he lets her go so she can be happy.
The first song in the sound track is the overture which is absolutely EPIC. The organ is absolutely INSANE and the music is so energetic and terrifying at the same time and makes you excited to see what’s going to happen in the show. The opening number is Think of Me, which is a simple little aria by the star singer, Carlotta. She’s shrill and her falsetto is frankly irritating, but when she stops singing and Christine sings instead, the contrast is amazing. Her voice is smooth and beautiful, and it sets up the rivalry between the two characters brilliantly. The next song, Angel of Music (and the Mirror which is a sort of follow up to it) is about Christine’s teacher. It’s happy and whimsical and portrays the emotions Christine feels about her tutor perfectly. At the end though, it takes a darker turn as she shows her fear that the teacher (who’s the phantom) makes her feel. The Mirror is the follow up to the song, and it’s a duet between her and the phantom where he reveals himself to her. This song goes into the song which is the namesake of the show- Phantom of the Opera, which plays as the phantom takes Christine to his ‘lair’. I don’t even need to describe this song- it’s perfect. It’s romantic, haunting, energetic, and terrifying. The instrumental is simply perfect and the vocals are amazing. Christine’s high notes are actually mind blowing; it’s a perfect musical number.
This is followed up with Music of the Night, where the phantom sings to Christine. It’s a beautiful melody, but it’s also really creepy if you listen to the lyrics. The man is obsessive and loves Christine in a really almost perverted way. It also showcases the phantom’s musical abilities. The next song is Primadonna, which is about Carlotta. This number consists of the producers of the opera house hyping her up and calming her down because the phantom threatened her and wants to replace her with Christine. This song is more of a plot number rather than a musical number but it’s enjoyable nonetheless. The next featured number is All I Ask of You, a duet between Christine and Raoul (who’s the man she loves). He wants to protect her from the phantom. It’s a really sweet love song with great harmonies and a gorgeous melody. Following this is a reprise of the number, where the phantom gets pissed because he heard their song and is jealous and gets really angry. His anger and sadness shines through really well, and it’s a bizarre experience for the viewer/listener, as you begin to almost feel bad for him. He’s a stalker, kidnapper and murderer, but watching this you empathize with him.
Masquerade opens act two, and this one is an ensemble number. It’s a fun little song that’s used as a plot point to transition from one spot to the next, so there’s not much to analyze here. The next song is Wishing You Were Somehow Here Again, which is a solo by Christine who misses her dead father. This song is slow and haunting, but also really sad. At this point, she’s in extreme distress, so her singing to her father's grave is absolutely heartbreaking. What’s even worse though is what happens after: the phantom emerges from the gravesite and tries to lure Christine to him (which is absolutely sick). She begins to follow him in a trance, but luckily Raoul saves her. The song sets up this disturbing and terrifying scene brilliantly and makes it all the more unsettling. Setting up the climax of the show is Past the Point of No Return. This is a song that the Phantom wrote for an Opera that he threatened the opera house into performing and the sexual tension is INSANE. It’s a duet between the phantom (disguised as a character of the show who he killed backstage and replaced) and christine’s character and it’s just NUTS. At the end, she reveals the phantom, on stage, and he runs and takes christine with. The climax of the show (and the last number) is Down Once More/ Track Down This Murderer. It’s an epic number which has tons of different perspectives happening at once and contains themes and melodies of previous numbers from the show. It’s a plot song but it’s still thrilling to listen to, as you can see what’s happening in your head as you hear it. In this number, Raoul chases down the phantom, Christine tries to escape, the phantom captures Raoul and almost kills him but Christine begs for freedom and he lets them both leave. It’s intense, emotional, and heartbreaking. You find yourself feeling for everybody and empathizing with the phantom’s heartbreak despite his actions.
The soundtrack to the Phantom of the Opera creates an amazing gothic neoclassical aesthetic to a beautifully twisted story. The songs accompany and enhance the plot brilliantly and make the emotional appeal of the story significantly stronger. It’s one of the most successful musicals of all time, and for a good reason. It combines every element of what theater is supposed to be and perfects it, making it a perfect musical to me.