“Oh no! It’s My Undead Husband!”
(Horror from the Tomb & Mysterious Adventures horror comic covers)
A common trope in pop culture is the phrase “Oh no, it’s my husband!” uttered by a wife about to be caught cheating with another man (or a woman, a cartoon animal, etc.). [There are also examples of philandering husbands shouting “Oh no, it’s my wife,” but these seem to be less prevalent, possibly because the archetypal cuckold situation is a husband coming home early from work to catch his wife in bed with someone else, whereas pop culture suggests men cheat on their wives in motel rooms.]
This situation, tragic in real life, is used for both humourous and dramatic effect in popular culture. [Coincidentally, I was re-watching David Lynch’s Mulholland Drive last night and it contains such a scene.] It can be a joke (the lover hides under the bed, or in the closet, or jumps out the window, or the unfaithful wife makes a snarky comment to her husband, or the cuckolded husband makes a snarky comment to his wife), or result in violence or terrible emotional anguish. It’s interesting to discover that the set-up can also be used for...horror. And I don’t mean the horror of the betrayal of one’s marriage vows.
In today’s entry, we’ll examine several Fifties horror comic book covers which take the “Oh no, it’s my husband!” trope to an extreme. A quick perusal of horror comic covers turns up a not insignificant number of examples, including Beware 6, Dark Mysteries 4 & 15, and related covers (undead husband confronts wife, albeit not in the presence of her new lover) on Strange Mysteries 11 and The Vault of Horror 19. The two covers chosen for our post-mortem (see what I did there?) are Horror from the Tomb 1 (September 1954) and Mysterious Adventures 4 (October 1951).
Horror comics and crime comics were the primary offenders that caused the eventual creation of the Comics Code Authority in late 1954, which then led to the bowdlerising of comic book content for the next 3 decades (at least). Although comic books dedicated to “realistic” crime stories began in the early 1940s with Crime Does Not Pay, horror comic books came along later in the decade. EC became famous (and infamous) for its horror titles (Vault of Horror, Tales from the Crypt, Haunt of Fear, etc.) but many other companies jumped on the horror bandwagon in this era.
Horror from the Tomb, from small publisher Premier Magazines, lasted just one issue, becoming Mysterious Stories with #2. In his testimony at the Senate Subcommittee Hearings on Juvenile Delinquency on 4 June 1954, George B. Davis, president of distributor Kable News, said:
Mr. Davis: Let me give you a couple of illustrations. A man, one of our publishers, put out a comic last week. I found out about it and I insisted he kill it immediately. I have had people look through the editorial content and can't find anything too wrong with it, but the title itself.
[Chief Counsel Herbert W.] Beaser: What is the name of it ?
Mr. Davis: Tomb Horror. [sic] We killed it. I told the fellow not to print another one yesterday, when I heard about it.
Horror from the Tomb’s cover artist is unidentified, but—based on work appearing in the successor title Mysterious Stories--it appears to be George Woodbridge on pencils, inked by Angelo Torres. Before we get to the art and the wonderfully lurid text box, the extremely blatant ripoff nature of the cover design should be noted. Essentially, this is a “fake EC” comic. (1) the round, white company logo in the upper left corner (PM, “A Premiere Comic” and two stars) is virtually identical to the round, white logo in the upper left corner of EC publications (EC, “An Entertaining Comic,” and two stars). (2) The title logo lettering and placement “HORROR from the TOMB” resembles EC’s “The VAULT of HORROR” logo. (3) The inset thumb-nail artwork of the comic’s “mascot,” “The Keeper of the Graveyard” is extremely similar to EC’s “hosts,” “The Vault-Keeper,” “The Crypt-Keeper,” and “The Old Witch,” who were also depicted in thumb-nails on the EC covers.
[The interior stories in Horror from the Tomb were hosted by a very EC-like trio--The Gravedigger, the Graveyard Keeper and Grandma Gruesome—although only the second is featured on the cover (as “The Keeper of the Graveyard”: his name in the interior story is thus even closer to the EC nomenclature).]
Premier was hardly the only company to imitate EC’s cover style: Harvey (Chamber of Chills, Tomb of Terror), Ajax-Farrell (Haunted Thrills), Superior (Journey into Fear) and others were also shameless in their attempts to trick potential customers into purchasing their comics. It is interesting to note that when Horror from the Tomb was resurrected (heh, see what I did there...again?) as Mysterious Stories, the cover style was revamped, keeping the “PM” company symbol but changing the title logo typeface and dropping the thumb-nail of the Graveyard Keeper. Mysterious Stories began to carry the Comics Code Authority stamp with issue 3 (April 1955).
But, you may say, what about the undead husband?! Sorry, I got side-tracked there for a minute. First, the cover art is very good, certainly not a given for Fifties horror comics, with lots of style and detail on the skeleton-man and the gnarled tree & roots, etc. This is actually a quite “modern” looking comic book cover. It’s also nice how the revived corpse seems to be smiling as he lies in wait for his visitors. The dialogue balloons indicate Mr. Crewcut Cigarette-Smoking Hoodlum (possibly Mickey Spillane) and his Blonde-in-a-Slinky-Gown have returned after “five long years” to retrieve money they “buried with him.” Him? Who him? We’ll get to that. However, a couple of questions come up. Did they leave the shovel there for five years? Is her dress really appropriate for exhuming a corpse in the woods in the middle of the night? He’s wearing a purple jacket with a popped collar, but she’s got exposed shoulders and cleavage, isn’t she chilly?
Although the art and dialogue balloons explain the cover’s premise adequately, someone felt a text box loaded with the purple prose would be just the right touch of overkill: “This reeking, slimy corpse...was brutally murdered and his money buried with his crushed body! Now, his killer returned for his reward, bringing with him the faithless wife, who once loved this dead thing!” Ooh, now I get it...very slightly more than I got it before.
The text box concludes with “It can’t be, you say...but read...The Corpse Returns!” Sadly for any newsstand browser who was captivated by the exciting art and melodramatic writing style, no story entitled “The Corpse Returns” appears in this issue of Horror from the Tomb. But really, wouldn’t it have been anti-climactic anyway?
The second “oh no, it’s my husband” cover we’ll deconstruct today is Mysterious Adventures 4 (October 1951), a product of Story Comics.
Story Comics published only a handful of titles in its relatively short existence (1951-1955). The horror comic Mysterious Adventures was the company’s longest-lived publication, producing 25 issues over 5 years, the last two issues in the Comics Code era. William Friedman and Morton Myers were the publishers of Story Comics, which had fuzzy relationships with other ephemeral comic book companies like Master Comics, Ribage, Merit, Men’s Publications, etc. Like George B. Davis, publisher Friedman also testified in front of the Senate Sub-Committee on Juvenile Delinquency in 1954. The sub-committee questioned him primarily on the comic Dark Mysteries, about which Friedman said, vaguely “I am associated with the publisher and one of the people interested in the company as an officer of the company,” and was “assisting in the editing of that magazine.”
The cover of Mysterious Adventures 4 is also patterned after the EC horror comic cover style, albeit to a lesser degree than Horror from the Tomb. The vertical box reading “Amazing Tales” in the upper left-hand corner imitates similar boxes reading “Horror” (on Vault of Horror), “Terror” (on Tales from the Crypt), and “Fear” (on The Haunt of Fear), sort of a genre keyword. The title logo changed significantly five times during the magazine’s years of publication, but the version shown here was the most prevalent. The “motto” across the top of the cover—“Strangest Tales Ever Heard”—appeared on the first 10 issues, although it was moved down into the artwork with #6 and replaced on the masthead by “Thrilling Tales of Suspense” with #7 (and even this was later altered to “Thrilling Tales of Terror,” “Thrilling Tales of Mystery,” and, on the last issue, back to “Thrilling Tales of Suspense”). The text box reading “Tales of Horror” appeared on most issues through #13.
As an aside, “Strangest Tales Ever Heard” seems an odd choice for a comic book tag-line. Wouldn’t “Strangest Tales Ever Told” or “Strangest Tales Ever Read,” or “Strangest Tales Ever Written” have been more media-appropriate?
The last, minor bit of text on the cover is a box in the lower left-hand corner reading “Little Coffin That Grew.” This, contrary to what one might guess, is not at all related to the cover art, but neither is it a total red herring a la Horror from the Tomb’s ballyhoo of the nonexistent story “The Corpse Returns.” The first story inside Mysterious Adventures 4 is entitled “IF the Coffin Fits...Get In!” and this involves two brothers who buy miniature coffins that...grow. So it appears the cover blurb for “Little Coffin That Grew” references this story in an odd, oblique manner.
But on to the main attraction, the main cover art. We’ve got a green monster who looks like a cross between Shrek and the Hulk (he’s even got the purple pants!), standing in a cemetery holding a woman in his arms, as another man looks on, while being restrained by a skeleton. Makes perfect sense. The art is attributed to Bill Fraccio, a journeyman who worked in comics for more than 30 years (for 23 years he was a Charlton stalwart, often teamed with Tony Tallarico). Fraccio’s art here (and elsewhere) is a strange hybrid of cartoony (the moronic and catatonic looking monster) and realistic (the man and woman). This is not the worst drawing ever seen on a Fifties’ horror comic cover (not by a long shot), but it’s not very good, either. Fraccio is credited on one interior story in this issue of Mysterious Adventures, and his work is marginally acceptable there as well.
The “story” behind this cover is just about as well delineated as the one on Horror from the Tomb, but doesn’t have a text box to provide additional details. Unlike Horror from the Tomb, there’s no explanation as to why the blonde and her boyfriend are visiting a cemetery at night. Alright, maybe this is what happened: the blonde was getting ready to go on a date with her new boyfriend, when Shrek-Hulk burst into her room and abducted her. Boyfriend follows them to the graveyard, where the blonde shouts “It’s my husband!” [Question 1: did you recognise him? If so, Question 2: why did you marry a guy who looks like that?] “He says I must go with him! But look—that grave!”
Boyfriend, in the grasp of a skeleton (presumably one of the green monster’s supernatural friends), says “It can’t be! Jim was reported killed in Korea!” Once again, this raises some questions. If he was “reported killed in Korea,” that means his body would not have been sent back to the USA (because then his death would have been confirmed). And thus the grave where Jim aka Shrek-Hulk seems to be taking his wife can’t be his grave. Maybe it’s an empty one? Except...a headstone is visible. So Jim dug up someone else’s grave and is going to climb in there with his wife? Maybe it’s all a misunderstanding, and Jim doesn’t intend to chuck his wife into the open grave at all. Perhaps he’s taking her to Olive Garden for dinner!
[The reference to being “killed in Korea” is an interesting topical reference to the Korean War. A surprising number of non-war comic book stories in the first half of the 1950s allude to the war in some way, with boyfriends/husbands going off to fight, wives becoming widows, injured veterans returning, and so on.]
An alternative explanation would be that Jim was not killed in Korea. Instead, he became a dopey-looking green monster as the result of some sinister Communist mad scientist’s experiment, and he’s been sent back to the USA to destroy the rotten capitalist system from within. He’s the original Manchurian Monster Candidate! But he got sidetracked when he bumped into his wife, foiling the Reds’ plan. So she’s actually sacrificing herself to save her country. She’s the Greatest American Hero!
[As another aside, is anyone else suspicious of the boyfriend? “Oh, I can’t get away!” Yes, I’d love to fight that ugly monster to save you, my darling, but I’m being restrained by this skeleton. How tragic! I’d gladly risk my life, honestly, but I’m helpless, as you can plainly see!]
Marriage, so I’ve been told, is a wonderful institution. Unfortunately, marriages occasionally (alright, frequently) have problems, and infidelity is one of these. So as long as we have cheating spouses, we’ll always have situations where we’ll hear “Oh no! It’s my husband!” Bad? Sure. But “Oh no! It’s my undead husband!”? Worse.