Alright y’all I have a theory!
So with the latest episodes we find out who the holder of Alastor’s deal is (if you don’t know, stop reading, unless you want to be spoiled)
That seemed really odd to me as I thought it would be a big hubbub with it only being hinted at in season 1.
***
Is it possible she is holding the contract so Lilith can do her thing in heaven (whatever the hell that is) sure. Could be everything, could be nothing. I’m not really focusing on Lilith for now till we get some personality from her to help gauge direction. (She cold though, watching her daughters phone ring and now answering)
ANYWAY! We saw the deal and how it went down. I call bullshit. Why is everyone agreeing to such loosely worded deals? Alastor doing magic and beings cannibal when he’s alive? Sure.
Him blindly agreeing to a deal with no specific requirements but just vague “something” - dude was a serial killer. Like sure he’s not some mastermind but he’s not an idiot either.
So I got thinking. We’ve never seen hells residence make deals with the living before, that’s weird. Rosie is an overlord. But is she a hellborn or a sinner? Because that deal had some juice requirements! “the most powerful Sinner in hell…but, you must do something for me. And until you complete this task, your soul will be mine.” That’s weird and suspicious.
So I went on a deep dive. If Rosie was ever human it’s suggested she was in the 1910’s while Al was in the 1930’s (there’s some debate if sinners are demons or if that’s purely a hellborn thing, I don’t think they are demons for the record). 20 years doesn’t seem like enough time to be an overloaded and have that kind of juice for that deal and make earth contact f we assume people are dressed in the style of their time.
Ok so what do we know about Rosie? (…huh) She doesn’t like seeing someone sad or in low spirit. *suspicious looks at Alastor’s constantly smiling face* Which is why she helps Charlie season 1, she had a partner named Franklin who does in the last extermination according to the pilot and she has a love of interfering in other peoples drama/love life (crazy aunt/mum vibes)
***
***
***
Guys is Rosie Alastor’s mother?
***
***
Wait! I swear it’s not just because they’re both cannibals!
They both constantly wear a smile. Rosie is all about other peoples love lives, Alastor wants nothing to do with that shit but he loves other peoples drama
Alastor’s mum was supposed to be a big deal to him when he was alive right? But we didn’t see a hint of her in the flashback.
And she called him away roughly 7 years ago when Lilith allegedly went missing and the exterminations supposedly started. Why? No one saw him in all that time?
Alastor doesn’t seem to be quite as vindictive with Rosie as he would with everyone else. He’s in a Sassing war with the king of hell. I don’t think, if Rosie was just his contract holder, he’d deal with it so calmly.
And look what he does when she tells him “tough luck pumpkin” takes his toys and goes to hide at his…friends(?) house. That’s some mama boy behaviour
It’s just a theory. If I’m wrong, I’ll laugh about it.
