Wait what!!?? I didnât even know you were attempting to continue/finish the 1930s AU!!! BEYOND EXCITED. The extra time will allow me to re-read from the beginning!! Do you have a link to a master post of them at all? Thank you!!!!! For answering this and for continuing this and any other stories! Youâre one of my favs for sure :D
Okay, so I saw someone had liked an old post talking about me writing Chapter 14, which was like, FOUR years ago. I am SHAMED that itâs been that long. I am sad to say that Iâm not actively working on this story; HOWEVER. This unexpected ask, along with me looking over at @mmfd1930au-blogâ (yes, I once left it along so long it got renamed ⊠) makes me feel like I need to at least preserve what Iâve written, and perhaps that will spark me to finish the story (with as much justice as I can muster.)
However (again), I also realized thereâs no masterpost that works anymore because the blog name changed. So, Iâm going to use this lovely ask to create one, in case anyone wants to revisit the story and didnât know how to find it.Â
Thank you, lovely anon, for reminding me of this story, and of all the love I (and @nicrememiralleggro) have received for it. This fandom is a true gift. <3
Okay, I think Iâll address these message by message. First of all, thanks for taking the time to read the story and provide feedback. I have no idea how long ago these messages were sent or if youâll see them, bc I am the worst and basically abandoned this blog for too long. But, these were some thought-provoking criticisms and I thought Iâd take some time to try and explain my thought processes for some of the things you found objectionable.
i wanted to give some critical criticism bc i found some pretty iffy messages written into the fic? and i guess i kinda want to address them. when i started reading the fic i thought it was a refreshing and very creative take for an au, i mean i love historical fiction, and this fic did a really good job in that aspect. but? i feel like finn is uncharacteristically annoying? like he is too nice and doesn't really have and antagonism towards rae which makes it feel like the romance is too easy?
It is historical, so the characters are not going to be direct analogues of those in the series. I try to think of their positions in the household relative to their motivations. Finn canât âbanterâ with Rae the way he can in the pub in 1996, or really antagonize her. Heâs her motherâs employee. So, it was a more delicate balance. I also feel like the conflict in this story isnât so much a âwill they or wonât they?â but a âcan they or canât they?â Subtle, but distinct difference from the original.
and like? there is a quote from the fic that where finn is telling how lovely he thinks rae is? but like obviously she doesnât know it. and somehow that makes her lovelier???? like thats kinda horrible. like why would finn think rae is more attractive or more âlovelyâ bc she didnât know it? and since when does a girl need to be told by a man that sheâs lovelier bc she doesnât know sheâs lovely. i hope your following my train of thought. also?? i seriously thought finn was too wordy?
People and characters have âiffyâ thoughts and problematic ideas. Itâs Finnâs opinion that her not being aware of how lovely she is endears her to him further. Heâs 18; heâs observed enough women at parties and dinners to draw some conclusions about vanity. Itâs not meant to be a statement that vanity is bad, or girls shouldnât wear makeup, or anything like that. Itâs a boy, in 1930, trying to tell a girl he thinks sheâs pretty. Boys today donât do much better. Iâll cop to Finn probably being too wordy. I enjoy writing dialogue and itâs likely true that I made him too eloquent.
and basically every other character in the fic not involving the help are utter assholes? like callie (who i guess is supposed to be chole) and archie???? like i get it archie is gay????? but standing rae up and asking her to marry him??? and just writing rae as a character who can just be pushed around??? like that is not canon rae at all. and it felt like you just made rae into this indecisive pushover, while watering down her mental illness so you didnât have to deal with it?
I donât agree that the Rae in this story is someone who can be pushed around. Sheâs been sent away and given no treatment for her mental illness, so sheâs developed some ways to cope. (Iâm sure youâre right that I havenât gotten all the mental illness stuff right. Iâm not always 100% sure how her issues would have manifested themselves in another time and place, where she probably wouldnât have had the same level of verbal abuse from classmates, but she might have had more harsh words from her mother and teachers.)
Sheâs dropped into this environment, still figuring out her place in the house, and worried about being sent away again . . . so she might not be quite as forceful as a modern day Rae. However, she plays poker, sneaks out to the jazz club, takes up an unladylike hobby, and refuses Archie in a pretty forthright manner, if you ask me. She chooses who she wants to spend her time with, even if itâs servants who her mother doesnât approve of. Iâll agree to her being a little indecisive, but though she wobbles, she hasnât been toppled over.
Callie is Chloe, and she has some pretty heavy shit going on. She canât go to the clinic to take care of her problem, and yet she still gives Rae some friendly advice. Archie is petrified, and it makes him act like a jerk. Hassan has had some early traumas, as well, and had channeled his emotions into anger. It was not my intentions to make anyone inexplicably cruel. There is a bit of an Upstairs, Downstairs divide in personalities, I agree, but that was somewhat intentional. (Also, Karim is kind, Henry is kind, Archieâs mother is lovely . . . there is some balance in the universe.)
(wait is anna, chole? i dont even know) and lastly i want to make a point at her mom? like please make me understand what is her deal? like i feel like you made her into the awfully dull version of the step mother from cinderella, and even then the readers had even a little sympathy when it came to the jealousy she had for cinderella. like why does lilian hate her so much? and why does rae not care? Iâm just really confused and while i spent the last 3 days trying to finish this fic.
Iâve said from the beginning that thereâs a reason Lillian is so cold, and I hope to finish the story so youâll find out why. Rae does care, but sheâs been pushed aside so often, sheâs trying not to get her hopes up. Iâm sorry to hear that things were confusing. Obviously, there are things that were meant to be ambiguous or a mystery to be resolved later, but perhaps they werenât as effective as I hoped.
i really wanted to write some critical criticism bc while i suck at writing i like to think Iâm a bit decent when it comes to analysis. and im on anon bc i truly dont want anyone to take this personally it truly is critical feedback. i really like your fic, i think the creativity and the strive is definitely there i just think there are some things you can work on! peace out man!
Once again, thanks for taking the time to let me know your thoughts. Iâm sorry you didnât enjoy it more, but I will also say . . . I wrote this for free. (Also, the more common phrase is CONSTRUCTIVE criticism. Iâm fine with critical criticism, but when sending feedback to other writers, you might want to temper your objections with a few more positives. And maybe fewer question marks. *shrug*)
He pressed the dull point of the pencil to the paper and wrote âSorry it took so long to return this to you.â He sat back and looked at his careful lettering. It didnât seem like enough. He tugged thoughtfully on his eyebrow and then wrote, âI hope you didnât miss it too much.â He smiled. That was good.
inspired by mmfd1930au endemictoearth
I miss these two in mmfd1930Â T T. Hoping for the next chapter to come out.
HAVE to reblog this here!!! I am once again overwhelmed by the support and love for this story. I never would have imagined it would be this popular or inspire such awesome things! Thank you, nipasir!
Reblogging because I got a query about what song Rae sings to Finn in Chapter 7. This is it, nipasir! I'll answer your other questions in a message. :)
Developing negatives scene - MMFD 1930AU. I really really like the scene where they were developing negatives for the first time. Actually I was aiming to make them drying the photograph and stuff. But itâs hard, and I canât draw :p. Hope you enjoy this picture as much as I enjoy making them! endemictoearth @mmfd1930au justagirlnamedkayla
So.. I love AU 1930 sooo much. The part where Finn & Rae dancing in the night club gave me so much squishy fluffy feelings.. XD. I actually wished an artist to draw the scene (with the pub ambiance, and maybe Chop and Izzy dancing too in the background?) But well, Iâm not good at drawing, so this is what I can do. Hope the other AU 1930 fans like it. =D
Before she realized what she was doing and could talk herself out of it, she drew a hand, then another, a pair of hands cupped next to each other. (mmfd1930au)
Her heart had been full to bursting and she let everything spill out in front of him. Now she felt . . . not exactly empty . . . more hungry. She wanted to stuff herself back up; she felt deflated, incomplete.
Heâd taken a piece of her with him, along with all the light in the sky. The sun was setting as she watched Arnie drive him away in the car, and by the time she turned and walked up the stairs to her room, the darkness had overtaken. Whatever else she dreaded about life, Rae had never feared the dark before, and she was determined that she wouldnât let herself start now.Â
Everything had happened so fast, she hadnât had time to think about what his going would feel like. What it would mean to not have him down the hall and up the stairs. Or in the garden. Or waiting at table. He was truly out of reach and her palms itched, knowing they couldnât touch him.Â
Rae felt proprietary over Finn in a way that she never had about anyone else. She didn't understand it, nor did she like it. In her core, she didnât believe that people belonged to other people, but she was beginning to believe that sometimes people belonged together. She was afraid to believe in anything like fate, because maybe that meant she deserved to be sent away. Could being sent away have been a cosmic preparation to meet Finn? Or was life utterly chaotic, and if you found someone you loved, you should hang onto them with all your might, because they might float away if you didn't?
Now that he was gone home, she had nothing to hang onto. She was aimless and empty, like she didnât know he was her direction and what filled her heart.Â
She couldnât believe they had actually said the words out loud. This was where so many books end, protagonists joined in an embrace, looking forward to their long and happy future. But she and Finn didnât have a happy future guaranteed for them. True, no one had a guarantee, but many people didnât have this gulf between them. And on top of everything, Finn was gone. He had embraced her, told her again that he loved her, taken his small case, and left. It was so strange, sheâd been thrilled by those three words, I and you, joined by love, but now she was deep in despair. In the book that Finn had taken with him for his journey, an old man says that it is impossible to love and to part. She didnât know when sheâd see him again, and she couldnât just spend all of that time pining away. Sheâd go mad again, or become madder still.
Sitting at her desk, she tugged on a strand of hair, agitated. She needed something to occupy her mind. She started opening desk drawers, and saw the letters sheâd received only that morning. It seemed like a month ago. She took the card Henry had included, and turned it over in her hand. Sheâd go to the Galleries tomorrow, take her sketchbook, and hope she could lose herself in drawing.Â
Then she glanced over and saw Archieâs letter. She had to respond now. Her answer had always been no, from the moment he had suggested their union, but it had been soft and small at first. But that no had grown larger and more solid, and now it would never be anything but no. She pulled a sheet of paper out of her center desk drawer. Â
Taking up her pen, she tapped the end on her bottom lip, searching for a way to begin. Dear Archie, was a good place. They were friends, after all. She liked him, in spite of him putting her in this predicament. But he wasnât now, nor would he ever be, her dearest.
Allow me to apologize for not replying to you sooner. I have spent a lot of time considering your offer, vague as it is, but after giving it every consideration, I find still cannot accept it.Â
I very much hope we can remain as friends.
Best wishes,
Rachel Earl
It was short. Too short? It wasnât sweet, but she didnât feel sweet about Archie or this situation. Heâd likely want to argue further, try to wear her down, but she felt steadfast in a decision for the first time in her life. Even if she could never be with Finn, she wouldnât use Archie as a fallback position. As she pondered these thoughts, something nagged at the back of her brain, but she couldnât put her finger on it. It wasnât regret; more like something was askew, a picture frame crooked on the wall of her mind, but she couldnât see which one needed straightening.Â
Then, she wrote a short letter to Henry thanking him for the course information and letter of introduction to his professor. She informed him that he would likely be receiving correspondence addressed to her, and that sheâd be happy to meet him at the museum to discuss the matter.Â
Intent on not wasting anymore time, she folded the notes and popped them into envelopes, addressed and stamped them, and then opened her door to take it down to Mr. Gill to add to the letters for the morning post. Joan stood in the hallway and jumped at the sound, shoved a book into her apron pocket, and lamely flicked the feather duster over a sconce.
Rae was surprised to see her there, and raised an eyebrow. âLittle late for dusting, isnât it?â
âMy work is never done, Miss.â Joan sighed gratuitously.
âItâs a wonder you havenât fainted dead away,â Rae smirked. Joan was a good egg; Rae had felt an unspoken kinship to her ever since that day sheâd disappeared, and it was discovered sheâd been reading the whole time.
Joan paused, seemingly unsure whether to be offended or to laugh. Just as she was about to speak, Rae asked, âRead anything good lately?â
Now Joan froze. When she didnât reply, Rae continued, flustered. âItâs just, I know how much you like to read. Sorry, you can carry on; didnât mean to interrupt your work.â Rae swept past her, down the hall, and glanced back at Joan, wondering if that was fear behind the young maidâs eyes.
When Rae reached the top of the stairs, Joan replied. âIâm sure heâll be back soon, miss.â
It was Raeâs turn to freeze. Why did Joan say that? She felt she had to conceal, cover, hide. âWho? Oh, Finn? Yes, his grandmother is rather ill, I believe? I do hope sheâll pull through.â The words floated out of her like they were spoken by a stranger. She glanced back at Joan, who was wearing a forlorn expression. Turning away, Rae marched down the stairs.
* * *
After a long and restless night, the morning finally dawned. Rae awoke and groaned as the light assaulted her eyes. She had just propped herself up on her elbows when Izzy rapped on the door before coming in.Â
âMorning, miss,â she said, keeping her head down as she put the tray on Raeâs desk.Â
âMorning, Izzy.âÂ
The young maid didnât respond, which was strange. Rae had grown used to the flighty chatter Izzy would spout while Rae nibbled her breakfast and Izzy darted around the room, choosing an outfit and planning a style for her long dark hair. The silence between them felt awkward and Rae could not account for it.
âAre you feeling well, Izzy?â
âYes, miss. Miss Rae, I mean. Sorry.â Izzy opened Raeâs wardrobe and stared blankly in at the dresses hung up inside. âIs this dress alrighâ for today, Miss Rae?â Izzy held up a dark green cotton frock with pleats at the neck. Rae nodded. âIâll come back anâ fix your hair up in a bit,â Izzy sighed. Usually she waited around until Rae was through with breakfast, but today Izzy floated away in a cloud of sadness.Â
When she was alone, Rae was reminded that sheâd promised to write Finn every day, so she took bite of her croissant and then picked up her pen and opened her drawer to get a page of writing paper. On the right side of the drawer, Rae saw the stack of photographs they had printed the other day. One of the pictures of Finn was on top, she traced her finger along the curve of his jaw, and then opened her lower drawer, taking her journal out from underneath the scarf sheâd used to hide it, unclasped it, and slipped the photo in between the pages. Looking back at the photos, she now saw her face was on the top of the pile. He had printed it, after all. She smiled, feeling sheepish.
Turning back to the page, she was stymied. What could she say? What if his mum opened it and read it? How could she tell him in words how much she missed him already, how she couldnât fathom how much more she would miss him if he were gone a week or more, and how very, very much she hoped that everything would be alright?
Dearest Finn,
Before she realized what she was doing and could talk herself out of it, she drew a hand, then another, a pair of hands cupped next to each other. They were his hands; sheâd memorized them. She wondered if heâd recognize them. Then, she drew a heart nestled in his palms. It was not an anatomically correct organ, but she hoped heâd understand. He had her heart. She closed the letter with Yours, Rae. Because she was.Â
She carefully folded the paper around the photo of her in profile, and gently slid them into an envelope, addressing it with a feather touch. She clasped it to her heart, wrinkling the edge slightly before slipping it into her portfolio. This message she would need to mail on her own, away from prying eyes.
* * *Â
After breakfast, Rae made her way downstairs. She paused at the bottom of the stairs and looked at the light that filtered through the leaded glass panels of the front door, shapes dancing on the pattern of the hall carpet. Her eyes flitted to the marble-topped telephone stand, to the heavy wooden doors of the library which were slightly ajar, and then followed along the brocade wallpaper covered with framed prints to the door of her motherâs study. The door to the kitchen, bare wood denoting it as the entrance to a simpler world, was across the hall, and that was the world to which Rae was drawn. There was no pull to see her mother, to ask her what her day was like and if she could spare an hour to lunch with her. She knew the answer was and always would be that Lillian was too busy. She could easily spare fifteen minutes to dash up to the nursery to see Violet after sheâd worked through lunch with her second tray of the day. Much harder to tear herself away from correspondence and account books to sit awkwardly across from her eldest daughter and struggle for conversation. Rae didnât imagine the disdain she felt from her mother; she was sure of it.Â
As she made her way down the hall, she paused for the briefest of seconds outside the study door, but continued down the stairs to the kitchen.
She ducked her head as she rounded the turn in the stairs and heard the low tutting of Mrs. Dewhurst. âMiss Rachel, whatâre you doinâ down âere? Thought Iâd finally dissuaded you!â
A smile crept into Raeâs features. âCanât keep me away, Mrs. D. I was hoping to make some hand pies, like the ones I made when I was little?â
Mrs. Dewhurst smiled, but swatted her hands through the air, âOh, go away wiâ you! You probâly couldnât even handle a rolling pin anymore; itâs been that many years.â
Rae feigned shock. âOh, really? Well, any time youâd like to challenge me, just let me know.âÂ
Mrs. Dewhurst chuckled and started to turn back to her preparations for lunch. A shadow seemed to fall on the cookâs sunny mood, as she asked, âDid you âear about poor Finnâs gran? The lad was so broken up abouâ it!â
Rae felt a pang in her chest. Finn. She hadnât forgotten him, but for a moment he wasnât at the very front of her mind. Now he strode forward from the back of her brain at the mention of his name. âYes, I heard. Itâs terrible news. I hope he makes it to her in time. I hope they get to spend some time together before . . .â Her voice faltered. She didnât want to say before what.Â
Mrs. Dewhurst came to Raeâs side and placed a tentative hand on her shoulder. ââEy now, donât get too upset. Anyone would think it were your gran . . .â Mrs. Dewhurst didnât finish her thought, apparently not keen to state the inevitable out loud either. ââEre, letâs âave a seat.â She gestured to the little sitting area by the fire. When they were both settled in, the cook glanced around the kitchen and said, in a low voice, âWeâwell, Iâveânoticed how close the two of ya are gettin', Rachel.â She took a breath and seemed to gather her thoughts. âHeâs . . . heâs a good lad, and you're a lovely lass, but ya know . . . nothin' can come of it."
Rae nodded solemnly, her heart heavy. She wished she were the type able to conceal her feelings. She felt embarrassed at being caught out. But she could also hear the tenderness in Mrs. Dewhurstâs voice. Rae knew she was only showing her she cared about her and didnât want her to get hurt.Â
Rae took a deep breath and said, âI know. I know. It's just . . ." she walked over to the window that looked out into the garden. ". . . I've never felt what I feel when I'm with him. Itâs like . . . I was meant to know him. It seems strange that a little thing like who our parents happen to be should make it impossible for us to be friends or . . . anything at all.â
She looked over her shoulder at the old woman, and saw Mrs. Dewhurstâs eyes shining. She stood up and rushed to the counter, stumbling a little on her way. Rae rushed to support her.Â
âIâm alrighâ, donât fret about me, dear. I just need to be gettinâ on wiâ me work.â She placed both hands on the edge of the wooden counter, steadying herself. Rae nodded, even thought Mrs. Dewhurst couldnât see her with her back turned. Rae started to walk over to the door to the garden; sheâd really come down to ask Arnie for a ride to the museum. As her hand touched the doorknob, Rae heard Mrs. Dewhurstâs voice, low and throaty, as though she were fighting back tears, say her name. It wasnât her name so much as a plea, so she stayed. She waited, finally whispering, âYes?â
âDonât listen to a daft olâ cow like me. You should do what makes you âappy. You deserve to be âappy, after all youâve been through.â
Rae felt like one of the statues she was hoping to sketch, frozen in time. Her mind raced as her body ran from hot to cold in a matter of seconds. âIâI havenât been through anything so very terrible . . . â The unspoken question . . . have I? seemed to hang in the air after her words.Â
Rae heard Mrs. Dewhurstâs footsteps as she crossed over to her. She thought that if she turned around to face her, the tears gathering in the corners of her eyes would surely spill.Â
âPlease, have another seat. I shouldâwell, truth be told, I probâly shouldnât, but . . .â
Rae slowly sank into the upholstered settee opposite Mrs. Dewhurst, filled with curiosity.
âI know you donât know this, but Iâm not actually Mrs. Dewhurst.â
Rae looked up, bewildered, feeling thrown off balance herself.
âI mean, Iâm meself, no mistakinâ that, but I never actually married. The âmissusâ is a term oâ respect down here. Means youâve been workinâ a good long time, anâ know your trade.â Her voice had begun to waver, so she paused to steady it.
Rae tipped her head up to glance at Mrs. Dewhurst. âNo, I didnât know that.â
âWell, thereâs not much time for romance when youâve got breakfast lunch tea dinner anâ a tray of puddings to be doinâ every day, wiâ extra refreshments on Sunday. No time for rest, let alone flirtations anâ the like.â She managed a wry smile, like she was remembering something that contradicted what she just said. âThough there might âave been a moment or two. When things seemed . . . possible. Or, maybe, jusâ not IM-possible.â
Rae smiled, thinking of Mrs. Dewhurst as a young woman meeting a young man at the end of a dark hallway or in a corner of the garden.Â
âThere was a young man once . . . but, then, there always is. I âad so much âope, but it just couldnât be. Now, I tried to tell ya, well, warn ya, really . . . but now Iâll tell you somethinâ else.â The old woman took a deep breath and drew herself up straight in her chair. âIâve watched you grow from a wee lass, Rachel Earl. Iâve known you from a babe in arms, anâ Iâve seen what goes on. I know more than you do abouâ what . . .â She shook her head. âIfââ She faltered, but only for a moment. âIf your mother had treated you better, shown you more compassion, more love, I'd be inclined to tell you to do your duty. To forget about the feelinâ that you get when you see âim in the hall. But she hasn't done her duty, not properly. So, you do what you think is best . . . for YOU, Rachel Earl. I reckon youâre the only person you owe anythinâ to.â
With that extraordinary statement, Mrs. Dewhurst put her hand on her knee, sighed, and pushed herself up to stand. As she crossed back to the stove, a journey she must have made a hundred thousand times, she dropped her hand onto Raeâs shoulder, squeezing it for a second, before returning to work.
Rae drew a deep breath in through her nose and held it for a count of ten before she sighed and said, âThank you, Miss Dewhurst.â She didnât see, couldnât, as she was walking through the door, but the cookâs hand sprang to her heart hearing the name of her youth.
* * *Â
In the garden, Rae felt a little lost. Moments ago, Mrs. Dewhurst had confirmed her fears by saying nothing could ever happen. Her heart felt clenched, like a hundred little fissures were cracking its surface, but hadnât broken. But then, moments later, she was blindsided with hope. With this strange permission that she hadnât known she craved until she had it.Â
Rae was clouded by her thoughts and stumbled against a wrought iron bench, tottering for a second until she gained her balance.Â
âYâalrighâ there, Miss Rae?â Arnie called to her from the garage, coming out to see if she needed assistance.Â
âYes, yes. Perfectly sound, Arnie!â She turned and walked over to him, forcing a smile onto her face. âActually, itâs you Iâve come to see. Would it be possible for you to drive me to the British Museum today?â
Arnie was polishing a brass fitting in his hand with a soft cloth. He looked down at his coveralls. âWell, Iâd hoped to put in a couple hours gettinâ things in tip-top condition, buâ I could change and take ya in. Itâs a distraction Iâm after, and a driveâs as good as anythinâ for distractinâ me.â
âA distraction?âÂ
âJusâ donât wanna be thinkinâ too hard abouâ Finn anâ his gran, like. When he first got âere (I were undergardener then, but weâve always shared a room) . . . sheâs all heâd talk abouâ. Then, one day, after a month or so, he jusâ clams up abouâ her, says he canât talk abouâ her no more, or itâll drive âim spare. Anâ he didnât. Iâd forgotten all abouâ it, all about âer, until last night when Mr. Gill says I need to drive Finn to the station soâs he can go home anâ see âer. One lasâ time.â Arnie sighed.
Rae nodded gravely in response. With every mention of Finn, it was like an ocean of tears lapping at the back of her eyes, and high tide was bound to come.
Arnie popped the brass gasket onto at tray of polished hardware and furrowed his brow. âYâknow, itâs funny. All he talks abouâ these days is you.â
Rae felt her eyes pop out of their sockets. Luckily, Arnieâs head was still down.Â
âMainly in âis sleep, mind you,â he lifted his head, raising one eyebrow.Â
Her face felt hot and she knew that everyone must know. âIâI shouldnât have . . .â
Arnieâs face softened. âWhat? Yaâve done nothinâ.â He waited for her to look at him properly and said, âI were only jokinâ. He talks abouâ the pictures, too.âÂ
Rae exhaled a long breath to another ten count in her head.
âWhat time did ya wanna be at the museum?â Arnie asked, his voice softer, like he was worried his words earlier had been too harsh.
âUm, perhaps noon? If thatâs okay.â
âIâm at your service, Miss Rae, but even if I werenât, thatâd be fine. See ya then, then.â He doffed his cap at her and she wandered back to her room to gather her thoughts, as well as her things for the museum.
* * *
The ride to the museum was quiet. This time, Rae had allowed Arnie to open the back door for her and she sat in the back, silently filled with an apprehension that Arnie would ask her about Finn and why he talked about her. Not only did she not know what to say, she didnât know what Finn would want her to say. They had seemed to tacitly agree that secrecy and discretion was necessary, but he wasnât here with all of these people as much as telling her they knew everything. It made her want to laugh, because they acted like they knew something she didnât even know herself. Yes, they had spoken the word out loud to one another, but that didnât mean Finn didnât regret it, or that something at home hadnât changed his mind. She couldnât be sure how he would feel when they saw each other again. Whenever that might be.
When Arnie pulled up outside the museum, she didnât make any pleasantries, just sprang out of back of the car and tossed, âThanks for the ride, Iâll find my own way backâ over her shoulder, not giving Arnie a chance to respond before she shut the door and walked quickly through the gates.Â
Inside, she was directed to the Galleries of Sculpture and presented the card Henryâs professor had provided in his letter. The guard nodded at her to enter. Entering the enormous room was like stepping into a cathedral; it seemed almost religious. The skylight above flooded the center of the room with the clean white light of the midday summer sun, and the marble and granite statues gleamed at her in rows. Some artists had brought easels with them, and were standing, but there were also a few benches provided, and Rae gravitated to one of these.Â
She glanced around at the artists, most of whom were wearing canvas smocks to keep their clothes neat and clean and berets to keep the hair out of their eyes. Rae only had her sketchbook and a few pencils and drawing tools; she felt underprepared and inadequate. She decided to take a quiet turn about the gallery, partially to inspect the statues and find one she wished to sketch, but also to quietly take a peek at the work of the others, to see if she was hopelessly out of her depth.Â
To her surprise, there was a wide range of talent, not to mention different styles. Rae had always tended to draw things realistically, possibly even with too much honesty, wanting to present each subject as it really was. But some of these drawings she inspected bore little resemblance to the finely chiseled statues in the room, though she got the sense that the lines they had chosen did convey the feeling of the statues. Rae realized, not for the first time, that she had a lot to learn.Â
She returned to her bench and decided that the Greek statue in front of her, of a young man holding a discus, was as good as any, and she began to sketch. Almost immediately, she slipped into that state she could never describe to anyone else, because it was like she was operating on another frequency to the rest of the world. Time seemed to both stand still and slip away, because when she finally came to, she was disoriented and shocked that two hours had flown by. It had seemed like only a few moments. She blinked her eyes to clear them and looked at her drawing. Sheâd only focused on tiny sections while she was drawing, so now she could take in the whole picture. She wasnât sure how it had happened, but . . .Â
âLooks alright, but that face is a bit off,â spoke a jovial voice from over her shoulder. âWell, itâs a fine face, but it isnât the one on the statue.â
Rae turned around to find Henry smiling at her through his beard.Â
âHenry! What a nice surprise!â She started to stand up, but he motioned for her to keep her seat.
âI got your letter in the morning post, and as I was coming in anyway to meet with my professor, I thought Iâd see if you were here. How have you been?â
His smile widened at her joking. âSheâs very well, too. Weâre thinking of getting married at Michaelmas.â
âLovely!â Rae looked back at her sketch, at the face. Of course. It was Finn. She shook her head, flipped the sketchbook cover over the drawing, and started to pack up.Â
âLeaving?â Henry asked.
âWell, Iâm done for now,â Rae said, uncertain.
âThirsty? We could share a pot of tea downstairs.â
She found she was, and nodded. âYes, that sounds . . . yes.â
Downstairs in the tea room, Henry pulled out a chair for Rae and they sat facing each other at a small table.Â
âSo, whatâs going on, Rae-Rachel?â
Rae looked at her hands, and picked at a cuticle for a moment. âWhat do you mean?â she asked, knowing very well what he meant.
âWell, your letter was mostly expected, that youâd be coming to the gallery to sketch today, that you were thinking about the program at Camberwell . . . but whatâs this about you might be getting letters sent to my address?â
Rae sighed. âIf itâs a problem, let me know. Itâs . . . just . . . you were the only person I could think of that might understand, might be fine if I couldnât tell you why.â She picked up a spoon and twirled it nervously between her fingers.
âCan you tell me why?â Henry asked, his voice low and gentle; he seemed to understand this was difficult for Rae.
She raised her head and met his gaze, which she had been avoiding. âI think I can. I canât account for it, but I think I can trust you.â After a deep breath, she told him, if not everything, everything he needed to know. That she and Finn were good friends (her significant glance probably revealed they might be more), that his grandmother was ill and that she wanted to write to him to make him feel better, but he couldnât write back without fearing discovery and possibly much worse.
Henry nodded, humming thoughtfully as he twisted the side of his mustache. âYes. You knowâwell, of course you donâtâmy father was a day laborer. My mum took in washing. I was a weedy lad growing up, too slight to do much good on a farm or a building site, so I was sent to school. I was good at learning, and got a scholarship to Oxford. Thatâs how I met Sarah. She was in St. Hildaâs; I was in St. Johnâs. We met at the Ashmolean one rainy Saturday afternoon.â He smiled at the memory. âAnyway, she and her family are rather posh. Sheâs taking a step down in the world to be with me. And though I feel the weight of that, the fear that sheâll regret it . . . well. Sometimes you just know, you know?âÂ
Just as he finished his speech, the waitress arrived at their table with a tray of tea things. By the time theyâd gotten everything set out and the tea poured and fixed, Henry was caught by surprise when Rae replied, âI do.â
* * *Â
Her walk home from the museum had been invigorating at the start. Between Mrs. Dewhurst and Henry and even Arnie . . . maybe she was getting a nod from the universe. But, the question remained, to what? What options did she and Finn have?Â
The hope she felt at the start of her walk slowly swung closer to despair by the time she got home, and when she came in the front door and her mother was standing in the hall, the last glow of hope faded at once. Here was the only person whose approval mattered, and she would never get it.Â
âAh, Rachel, there you are! I wanted to speak with you.â Lillian held her hand out to have Rae join her in her study.
Rae ducked down to lean her portfolio against the telephone stand, then followed her mother.Â
âPlease have a seat.â Her mother seemed . . . pleased? Not angry, at any rate.
Rae wore an expectant smile. âWhatâs this about?â she asked, hoping she sounded casual.
âWeâve been invited to Scotland for a house party,â Lillian said, allowing herself a smile, as well.
âOh! Well, thatâs . . . nice. I hope youâll have a nice time.â Rae guessed that her mother wanted her to stay behind and keep the house open.
âNo, Rachel, youâre coming, too. In fact, itâs because of you weâve been included in the party. Mrs. Harris has invited our entire household!â
Raeâs eyes felt like they might drop out of her head and roll across the carpet. Sheâd just sent Archie her rejection; she couldnât spend two weeks in the Highlands with him!Â
True to form, Lillian didnât notice Raeâs discomfort and carried on. âNormally, I donât like to be away from the business for such a stretch, but Mrs. Harris says there is room for Violet and her nursemaid, and we can even bring a few of the servants. Karim could use a break, and Hassan always likes a bit of sport. Itâs really rather perfect, donât you think?â
Rae nodded without thinking, then said, âBut, mother, I just . . . started . . . a course of study at the British Museum! Iâd hate to miss out on something.â It was a lie, but a plausible one.
âRachel, this is a wonderful opportunity, and an honor for our family to be asked. The Harrises are a family of influence, and anyway, you are such good friends with Archie and Callie . . . I thought youâd jump at the chance?â
âNo, I mean, yes. It sounds lovely, Mother.â Her mind raced for a moment, trying to fashion a solution. âIf I might be allowed to go once more to the museum, to explain to the . . . instructor? When are we expected to arrive?â
âWell, we could leave anytime; their summer house is open for the season. I had planned for you to go up tomorrow on the noon train, and Karim and I would finish up some work and bring Violet in a few days. I suppose Hassan will work to his own timetable, as usual.â Lillian was distracted by thoughts of her stepson for a moment, then looked at Rae with a skeptical eye. âI donât like the idea of classes; what is the subject?â
âItâs just a drawing class, new techniques and that sort of thing.â Rae continued to lie, feeling panic rise within her. She had to write Finn again. She had to let him know where they would be, and why she wouldnât be able to answer anything from his letters for a bit. And Archie . . . had he already received her letter to him? A thought occurred. âWhat if I go up the day after tomorrow? Iâll go to the class tomorrow, and explain I have to postpone my studies.â
Lillian furrowed her brow. âWell, I suppose. I suppose that could work, and wouldnât look too odd. Though I did promise Mrs. Harris . . .â
âThank you, Mother.â Rae was already scheming how to stay behind for longer, when Lillian decreed, âNothing else must detain you, though. This is an important invitation, and Mrs. Harris will be expecting you.â
Rae nodded, and left her motherâs study to pick up her portfolio. It had never occurred to her that she wouldnât be here to get Finnâs letters. That she would be asked to a summer house . . . in Scotland . . . to spend two weeks with Archie and his family? This was going to be torture.
* * *
The next day, she went back to the museum, and explained to Henry that she was going away. âCould you keep any letters for me, till I get back? Iâm sorry; this came up so suddenly.âÂ
Henry nodded sympathetically, and said, âItâs not a problem, Rae. Only . . . did you want the one I got this morning?â He pulled an envelope out of his pocket, a sly grin on his face.Â
Rae looked between him and it, disbelievingly. âIs that . . . from him?â
âWell, the postmark is from Stamford. You know anyone else in that part of the world?â He held it out to her. She took it and turned it over in her hands, but didnât open it. She wanted to wait until she was home. Or maybe until the walk home. Definitely until she left the museum.Â
âRae-Rachel,â Henry ventured.Â
âYou can call me Rachel, you know,â she said with a smile. âOr just Rae.â
âI know, but Iâm fond of my nickname for you.â He smiled back, but then his face assumed a serious expression. âIâm happy that youâre happy, but . . . think about the Camberwell application. No man, nor woman neither, can live by love alone. Itâs a wonderful thing; just think about what else will fill your life.â He took a breath. âIf you let romantic love consume you, it will.â
Rae nodded. She couldnât trust love absolutely, in any case. And she wanted something to distract her. The art program application was actually the perfect thing. Even if she wasnât accepted, which she didnât expect she would be, it would be something to fill her time, occupy her mind. Though . . . she could still read his letter, and write a response. And think of him in gaps, when she caught her breath, when she could no longer stand it and just had to think about him.
Dear My dearest Rae,
Iâm writing this by candlelight with a bad pen, and the only people I write to are my mum and my brother, so please forgive me if this is terrible.Â
I arrived safe and Nan is still with us. Sheâs always been strong, and I think itâs strength thatâs kept her here until she could see me. You remind me of her in some ways, though that might sound odd. I see you having a pillar of strength inside, too. You must have, to trust in anything at all, after all thatâs happened to you. I hope you can trust in me.
I hate that I had to leave just as we wereâstarting things, I suppose? I hate that life can give you something wonderful and then make you leave it behind. I hate that I donât know when weâll see each other again.
I know itâs not the same, but I think I understand a little of how you felt returning home after a long time away. I donât quite fit here anymore. Everything looks the same, but Iâm not the same, you know? Now I wonder if the only place I fit is when Iâm with you. (Sappy clap-trap, I know. Probably heard that at some picture or other.)
Words canât express what I feel, so I wonât waste anymore.
Love,
Finn
Rae blushed furiously, both at his perfect letter, and her inability to write a single meaningful syllable to him in her initial correspondence. She slipped his letter into her portfolio, and wished she hadnât already mailed the drawing to him.Â
* * * * *
Two days later, Rae was on a train bound for Inverness, filled with apprehension.
Sheâd prolonged this journey for as long as she could, but her mother was adamant that she join Archie and Chloe in Scotland. âYouâve never been to a house-party, Rachel. It will be good for you to socialize with young people, make more friends and acquaintances, broaden your horizons.â Lillian seemed to say this last sentiment with an odd emphasis, like she felt Rae had been narrowing her horizons somehow.Â
Rae had managed to delay her going an extra day, but now she found herself on a sleeper car on her way to Archieâs family home near Beauly Firth. She never received a reply from Archie, and was tying herself up in knots, wondering if heâd gotten the letter.
This anxiety compounded with her missing Finn, and she once again failed to get any decent sleep, alone and awake at three in the morning, hurtling through the night toward an unknown fate. Her mother and Karim were planning to come up in a few days, but couldnât accompany Rae. Hassan was already in residence, and Callie had written, apparently the day he arrived, imploring Rae to come and join them, the subtext being that she didnât like to be alone with him.Â
Izzy was traveling with her, though she had her own seat in Third Class. Rae had asked Izzy to sit in her sleeping compartment, but Izzy seemed to want to sit by herself, which Rae thought odd. She was probably upset at being separated from Arnie. He was not a member of the party, as they werenât driving up, nor would they be in possession of a motor on their trip. Rae had given them a moment alone when Arnie dropped them at the station, going to a newsstand, pretending to take her time choosing something to read on the journey. When sheâd returned, the two of them sprang apart out of an embrace and Rae hoped her face hadnât betrayed that sheâd seen them.Â
As she stared up at the polished wood ceiling, Rae tried to think positively about this trip, not dwell on the fact that Archie would likely be angry with her, which would make his mother upset with her. Callie might even join in. And Hassan was never nice to her. She could use Izzyâs friendship just now, but she wondered if she still had it.
She decided to cheer herself up and read Finnâs letter again. She switched on the dim light bolted to the compartment wall, and reached for her portfolio.
Rae gingerly took slid it out of the envelope and unfolded it with the utmost care. She read over his words, closing her eyes and shaking her head at the perfection of them. She couldnât keep responding with drawings, so she picked her pen and took a deep breath.
My dearest Finn,
You keep telling me that youâre not very good with speaking or writing, as though words somehow elude you. Yet, you still manage find the precise ones I need to hear again and again. Whoever told you that words were your enemy was wrong. I loved your letter, and I wish I were still in London to receive every word. Unfortunately, my mother insisted I come to Scotland, to Archieâs summer house, to . . . well, Iâm not sure why. I think it is simply because we were invited, and it would be rude to decline such an invitation.
So, here I am, in cold, bleak Scotland, glad of my long sleeves, but wishing I could have stayed behind to wait for you and your words.Â
I should have actually written something in that first letter and told you, but Mrs. Dewhurst knows. About us. And Arnie suspects something, too. Of course, I had to tell Henry. So, I donât know. Part of me wants everyone to know, because it feels so good to love and be loved. However, I know how difficult that would make life for you. And for me, too, I suppose. I donât think anyone will betray us, but if theyâve sussed us out . . . I donât know how much longer before everyone knows.Â
If that scares you, well, Iâm scared, too. Though I think Iâm more scared Iâll never see you again.
I hope I have even a little of the strength you see in me. I think weâll need it before long.
Yours, with love,
Rae
Sleep eventually overtook her, and when she awoke, it was early morning, a bright sliver of clouded gray-sky light making her squint as she opened her eyes. She sat up and pulled the tiny curtain over the window all the way open. The landscape was shrouded in mist, foreboding. Rae shivered and pulled the thin blanket provided by the railway around her shoulder. It was summer, but didnât feel like it this far north. She heard the muffled voice of the conductor walking the aisle. âInverness! Next stop Inverness!â She stood, steadying herself against the wall until she grew accustomed to the sway of the train, then pulled the dress sheâd hung up last night on over her head, smoothing the front, then ran a brush through her hair. There was a knock on her door and she reached over to pull it open. It was Izzy.
âGood morninâ, Miss Rae.â
âMorning, Izzy. Did you sleep well?â
âA little. Third class was so crowded, though, and a man tried to use my lap as a footrest in his sleep.â
âOh, Iâm sorry! You should have come and bunked with me. Itâs not a lot of space, but I wouldnât have trampled you in the night.â Rae tried a joke.Â
Izzy rewarded her with a sly half smile. âMaybe on the trip back. I jusâ needed to think a bit.â
âWell, I can certainly respect that.â
After they disembarked and claimed their luggage, a porter took them to a lane filled with taxis and motors. The Harrises had sent a car, and the chauffeur leaned against the car holding a sign with MISS R. EARL on it. She approached with Izzy and the tall lad stood up to attention, helping the porter load the bags. Rae noticed him giving Izzy an appraising glance and shook her head. If only he knew.Â
Rae spotted a red pillar box near the station, and snuck over to slip her letter to Finn inside before they headed to Archieâs house.
The drive wasnât terribly long, but it was terribly bumpy. Rae tried not to gasp every time they hit a rut in the road or climbed over a hill of dirt, but her nerves were already frayed from lack of sleep. She found that she and Izzy had clasped their hands together at some point, and the two of them smiled at each other through gritted teeth.
They were suitably impressed by the facade of the âsummer homeâ which turned out, unsurprisingly, to be more of a castle. It was built high, and somewhat narrow, and rose four stories tall, seeming to grow out of the bare stone at the base. The grey carved stone walls gleamed in the early morning sun. There was a long, low wooden addition that stretched out to one side.
As they climbed to the front doors and entered, looking up at the imposing foyer, the butler informed her that breakfast was still being served in the dining room, if she cared for a bite after they deposited their luggage in their rooms. Rae suddenly realized she wouldnât get away with having a tray sent to her room here. She would be expected to spend every meal as a member of the party. Just then, her stomach rumbled in mutiny and she sighed, knowing there was no escape. She smiled and nodded.
One of the maids showed Rae to her room. It was impressively large, more than twice the size of her room in London, with dark wood paneled walls, high ceilings, and a small window that overlooked a tangle of woods and distant mountains.Â
The maid took Izzy to her quarters, and Izzy said sheâd be back to unpack Raeâs things once she got settled in. Rae found herself alone, hungry, chilly, and groggy, wishing she hadnât had to come at all.Â
She looked longingly at the bed, sorely tempted to crawl in and sleep until noon, but she knew that would be rude. Instead, she hung up her dresses in the large wooden wardrobe, and poured water from the jug into the shallow basin to splash her face with water. Then she patted her skin dry on the rough linen towel and stared at herself in the mirror, which was spotted with age. She realized sheâd been pushing a lot of her fears and anxieties down inside, to be dealt with another time. If the day of reckoning ever came . . . she found herself worrying about her worries which, on not enough sleep, was enough to make her head swim.Â
She knew she was better than she had been as a child. Whether she had outgrown her fears and insidious patterns, or just learned how to cope with them because there was no one who would indulge them even before she was sent away, she could not say. But what if her more serious compulsions returned, even worse than theyâd been before? She couldnât expect Finn to put up with her in that state. Her eyes welled with tears, which she wiped away roughly. She took a deep breath and counted. Counting was the thing she kept, and she didnât know if needing numbers was helpful or harmful, but she knew they slowed her heart and cleared her head. Her stomach rumbled again, and this time she laughed at it. âAlright, I get the hint,â she murmured, and headed downstairs.
She thought she might be able to slip a scone or two into her pocket, to eat in the privacy of her room, but back in the foyer, the butler bowed deeply at her and led her to the dining room, rolling back the heavy door. She blinked against the bright light from the high windows, one of which shone directly on her face and shoulders. She tried to slide out of the sun and into the shadows, but Mrs. Harris rose and floated toward her. âRachel! So good to see you; Iâm pleased you could join us. I know Archie will be thrilled to see you.â Rae blinked at her hostessâs smile and nodded dumbly.Â
Mrs. Harris swept her hand out to indicate the impressive spread on the sideboard. âFeel free to fix yourself a plate; mornings are a little informal around here. Half the house hasnât even woken up yet, I believe.â She smiled ruefully and floated over to speak to one of the maids.
Rae noticed Callie sitting with a small bowl of oats and fruit, grimly chewing. She nodded at her friend and Callie managed a weak smile in answer. âMorning, Callie,â she said softly, and stepped over to peruse the food offerings. There were eggs, bacon, sausages, kippers, toast, scones, fruit, and the oats Callie was eating. Some sort of cereal for health, Rae supposed. She salivated over the sausages, but took toast and fruit, instead.Â
As she went to sit with Callie, the door rolled open again, Archie and another young man burst in on the serene scene, laughing loudly. Archie stopped short when he saw Rae, and the smile fell from his face. He looked like heâd been caught stealing.Â
He recovered quick enough, and smiled, walking over to kiss her on the cheek. âRachel, so glad you could join us!â Rae tried to parse his tone for anger, but he sounded pleased.Â
He then gestured to the young man heâd come in with, and said, âRae, I donât believe youâve met my friend, George Barnstaple.â It was the young man Rae had seen at the ball, and who had argued with him him the street.Â
Rae was confused, but nodded her head in greeting. âMorning, Archie. Pleased to meet you, George.â
George bared his teeth in the approximation of a smile. In his eyes, Rae could detect a coolness, as if heâd appraised her and found her wanting. Rae was used to this look, and shrugged it off.Â
She wanted to ask Archie if heâd gotten her letter, but she surmised he must not have. Sheâd sent it . . . four days ago? âWhen did you arrive?â Rae asked, trying to keep her tone light.
âOh, weâthat isâI came straight from Cambridge after my last exam . . . three days ago?â He looked to George for confirmation who nodded tersely.
So he couldnât have gotten her letter. They had just missed each other. Rae felt the need to sit down. She perched on a chair opposite Callie, who whispered, âYou look as wonderful as I feel. Long journey?â
Rae nodded. âSuppose so. Didnât sleep well on the train. Never can seem to sleep on a journey.â She took a tiny bite of toast, and then whispered, âHow are you, Callie?âÂ
Callie shrugged helplessly. âSame. Doomed.â She looked over her shoulder at the boys, who were piling their plates high with food and having resumed their laughter. Mrs. Harris was still in conversation with a member of staff about a dish on the sideboard. Callieâs voice dropped to a whisper again. âBut Iâm not even allowed to suffer my shame in solitude. Hassanâs been here for two days and keeps trying to get me alone. Only, it isnât like it was before. Before, he used to kiss me and tell me I was irresistible. Now, he accuses me of wanting to ruin his life. Saying I planned this whole thing to trap him. Why canât he see that Iâm just as trapped? That I have no options? Iâm at his mercy, and he has none.â
Rae swallowed her bite.âI donât know, Callie. Iâve found people go to great lengths to avoid facing uncomfortable situations, especially when theyâve created them.âÂ
Callie wrapped her arms around herself and looked over at the window, the culmination of weeksâ worth of sleepless nights evident in the shadows under her eyes. âAnd I donât know whatâs worse, the idea that heâll refuse to marry me and Iâm cast out of society, or that he will, and make my life a misery, anyway.â
Rae knew her friend was right. Hassan could ruin her life either way, and was probably resentful enough to try.
âIâm so sorry, Callie.â Rae reached across the table and squeezed her friendâs hand in sympathy.Â
Archie and George plonked themselves down next to the girls, and Callie withdrew her hand to pick up her spoon.Â
âNot feeling well, Callie?â Archie asked, taking a big bite of sausage.Â
Callie shook her head slightly. âMy stomachâs been bothering me,â she said, taking a small bite of cereal. âMust have caught a bug or something.âÂ
Archie just nodded, but Rae noticed George staring at Callie, and she would have sworn he looked skeptical.Â
âI think thereâs something going around London,â Rae said, more confident than she felt, wanting to protect Callie and her secret.
Callie smiled up at her, then looked down at her lap. Rae took another bite of toast.
A comfortable silence had just settled over the room when the door slid open again and Hassan blundered in, looking rumpled and still half-asleep.
Callie looked up at Rae, eyes wide. Her hand flew to her mouth and she murmured her excuses and swept out of the room, past Hassan, who whipped around to watch her leave. Rae bit the inside of her lip. When Hassan turned back to the sideboard, she came into his view and he sneered. âOh. Itâs you. I suppose we had to expect you sometime.â
Archie and George both gave Hassan looks of derision. No one commented on his rudeness, but Mrs. Harris came to sit next to Rae, smiling broadly. âRachel, we have a lot to discuss, I expect.â
Rae cleared her throat. âDo we?â
Mrs. Harris gave her son a look, saying, âI believe so . . . Archie?âÂ
Archie cleared his throat and swallowed his bite. âWell, I mean . . . I thought we had an understanding.â
George stood up abruptly. Rae wanted to do the same, and run out of the room.
âIâI hadnât . . .â Rae felt faint. If Archie had told his mother, her mother could already know and . . . the room spun.Â
âAre you quite alright, my dear?â Mrs. Harris asked, genuinely concerned.Â
âIâIâm not sure . . .â Rae steadied herself on the table. âI didnât think anything was understood. Not absolutely.â
Mrs. Harris looked at Archie, eyes wide with disbelief. âArchibald Harris! Did you . . . without even waiting for a proper answer?â She tutted and put a reassuring hand on Raeâs back. âDonât worry, my dear. I understand. Youâre very young and this is a momentous decision. You are welcome here as my guest. Donât give my assumptions another thought. Though, Iâd love to talk to you about your drawing. If youâd be so kind as to indulge me. It used to be quite a hobby of mine, and Iâm keen to see some of your sketches.â
Rae nodded, unable to speak once again.Â
Mrs. Harris stood up. âI think you should get some rest, Rachel. I know how difficult it can be to rest on the night train. If you need to take luncheon in your room, just let one of the maids know. Weâll see you at dinner tonight.â She swept out of the room, and Rae was left with three young men, all of whom were giving her dirty looks of varying shades.Â
âIâI think Iâll just . . .â Rae pushed her plate away and stood up, swaying for a moment, though she was no longer on the train. Archie started to stand up to help her, but George put a hand out to stop him.Â
âLet her go, Archie. She looks done in,â he said.
Back in her room, Rae closed the door behind her and leaned her forehead on the wooden wall next to the door. She exhaled a shaky sigh and jumped when she heard a voice.Â
âMiss Rae, are you alright?â
âOh! Izzy. Itâs you.â She sighed a second time, this time in relief, and gave her a weak nod. âYes, everythingâs . . .â Her voice trailed off. Things were not alright, not in the strictest sense of the word. Rae could feel her world slowly tilting off its axis. She needed to talk to Archie, but also dreaded the meeting. And Mrs. Harris was being almost unbearably kind.
Izzy interrupted the chatter of her brain to chide her. âYâshouldnât âave put your things away yourself, miss! Thatâs why Iâm âere, right?â
Rae nodded again. âYes, Iâm sorry. I just . . . donât know if Iâll ever get used to having someone else do things like that for me.â A part of her was afraid of getting used to it, and then being sent away again. Deep-down, Rae didnât want to lose the self-sufficiency her exile had instilled in her.Â
âOh, well, I know itâs my job anâ that, but I actually like helping you, Miss Rae. As daft as that might sound.âÂ
Rae smiled. âThank you, Izzy. That doesnât sound daft at all. I didnât mean to make you think I donât appreciate all you do for me.â
âThatâs okay, Rae. I know we . . . we got a strange relationship. I mean, Iâd like to count ya as one of me friends, buâ I know I couldnât.â
âNo, Izzy! I do think of you as my friend! But it feels so lop-sided, with all you do for me, and I just sit around while you braid my hair.â Rae shrugged.
Izzy looked at her in wonder. âMiss Rae . . . donât you . . . donât you realize? You listen when I talk! You give me advice and laugh at my daft sayings! No one . . . youâre the only one who ever did thaâ. Here, anâ at my last place . . . I was jusâ someone to be in the corner, stayinâ out of the way, as invisible as possible. But you . . . I dunno how, but you see everythinâ. Everyone.â
Rae scoffed lightly. âI donât feel like I see anything very clearly. I feel so muddled right now. I think I know what I want, but . . . I know what I want isnât really possible. And everyone else is telling me what I should do, and itâs enough to make me want to scream!â
Izzy guided Rae to sit at the vanity by the window, and started to brush her hair. âOkay, why donât you start by tellinâ me whatâs goinâ on?â Izzy asked in a soft voice.
Rae glanced up at Izzy in the mirror, who looked back at her with eyes softened by a small smile. âWell . . . thereâs a lot to tell. And I donât want you mix you up in anything.â
âThen tell me one thing, and if you feel like it, tell me another, until youâve told me what ya can.â
Rae started with Archieâs strange proposal. Izzy looked excited at first, but Rae shook her head and told her she couldnât accept. He didnât love her and she didnât love him; and Callie had given her strange warnings that she still didnât quite understand. Then, Rae let slip that even if she didnât have someone else she cared about, she wouldnât want to marry Archie before seeing more of life, taking time to determine what she wanted out of it. It would feel like she was released from one prison right into another.
Izzy listened sympathetically. âAnâ this other fella you care for . . . thatâd be Finn, would it?â
Raeâs eyes flew up to meet Izzyâs in the mirror once again. âIâyes. Of course! Apparently, we should have taken out an advertisement in The Times, as itâs the only way more people would know about it.â
Izzy rushed to calm Rae down. âI donât think everyone knows, Miss Rae! I only figured it out as you were speakinâ jusâ now. You didnât mention him once, anâ thatâs how I was with Arnie, when I didnât know . . . when we werenât . . . It was, like, I noticed it more that you never said his name. âCause I never trusted myself with Arnieâs name in my mouth . . . I felt like everyone would know as soon as I . . . yâknow?â
Rae closed her eyes and breathed heavily, gripping the sides of the vanity. âYou, Arnie, Mrs. Dewhurst . . . everyone probably knows. Iâm . . . this is . . .â
âRae, Miss Rae . . . I donât think anyone who hasnât seen the two oâ ya together will figure it out. Itâs jusâ . . . you twoâve been together downstairs . . . the photographs anâ all thaâ. Donât fret, Miss Rae. Please.â Izzy put her hands on Raeâs shoulders, and then impulsively wrapped her arms around her, pressing her cheek to Raeâs in a hug. âRae, youâre . . . please donât worry. I wonât say anythinâ to anyone.â
Rae closed her eyes and leaned against Izzy, returning the unexpected affection. She took a deep breath, counting. âAlright. Alright.â She tried to calm herself as her mind raced through scenarios of Mrs. Harris forcing her to leave and her mother telling her to take her luggage and keep going all the way back to France. Of never seeing Finn or Izzy or any of them ever again after it was revealed. Of a long, lonely existence far away from those she had grown to care so much about. She shook her head and counted under her breath. Izzy kept ahold of her; she didnât let go.
* * *
Rae took a fitful nap, sleeping through luncheon, having dreams of an angry Finn, upset because she hadnât denied everything absolutely. When she awoke in the early afternoon, Izzy was still there, apparently having kept watch over her in an armchair. Rae had Izzy choose her an outfit to wear for the evening meal, and then said she could go. She needed to think.Â
Rae was angry, too. A little at the circumstances that took Finn away, but mostly at herself. She hated this feeling of desperation, of needing another person. She had been the one to initiate their friendship, but sheâd never imagined that he would mean so much to her, so soon. That sheâd feel these pangs of longing if she didnât see him everyday. Sheâd always felt kind of disconnected from her body, but when she thought of Finn, of his lips on her, of his hands on her, she became all too aware of her physical form. She got these strange pangs and . . . she could only describe them as yearnings, and she didnât know what to do about them.Â
And the fact that she might never a chance to ever do anything about them . . . that certain vision of her future sheâd had before she came back to London flashed in her brain, taunting her. She honestly didnât know what was worse, a certain bleak future or the cruel uncertainty of hope.Â
A knock came at the door, and Rae started. She glanced in the mirror, and saw that she looked as flushed as she felt. She waved a hand in front of her face to try and calm down, calling out, âUm, just a moment, please!â She took a few breaths and crossed the room to open the door, only to find Archie waiting there. She sighed. âWhat do you want, Archie?â
âWell, you . . .â Archie looked down at the hall carpet. âIâm sure you must have deduced that I told Mother about our engagement.â He adjusted his spectacles and looked up at her.
âArchie, what engagement? I told you no, and you insisted I think it over. I gave you that courtesy, and you disregarded my feelings. You really shouldnât have done that.âÂ
Archie nodded gravely. âMay I come in?âÂ
Rae gave him a skeptical look.Â
âJust for a moment. IâI just wanted to explain . . .â He trailed off, not completing his thought.
Rae bit her lip, but nodded, opening the door a bit wider. She did not shut it behind them. Archie looked at the door standing ajar and seemed unnerved by it.Â
After a moment of silence, Rae spoke. âI sent you a letter. To Cambridge. I . . . I canât accept your offer, Archie. Iâm sorry. I think of you as a good friend, but I cannot say further than that.â
Archie looked down at his hands, his thumbs running along the outsides of his fists. âIâRachelâI donât know what to do!â He bolted for the door, running away.
Rae stared after him and looked down the hall, but Archie was long gone. She felt frustrated. She just wanted this one thing to be dealt with. For him to accept that she didnât want to marry him or be complicit in whatever deception he was planning. She felt it should be the simplest thing in the world. She would say, âNoâ he would say, âFineâ and they would shake hands and move on with their lives. But he wasnât listening to her. He didnât want to take no for an answer, and Rae was getting restless and even angrier. She didnât want to be here.
* * *
Dinner was about as comfortable as she had expected it to be. Tonight, Rae decided to eat her fill. She was hungry and didnât feel the need to hide that fact from this crowd. She even complimented the main course, a local salmon poached in butter and herbs, aloud.Â
Archie was practically mute all through the meal. There wasnât much conversation, apart from Rae and Mrs. Harris. Rae said she would probably take her sketchbook on a walk the next day, and Mrs. Harris told her of a few spots with lovely views, if she was interested in sketching landscapes. They chatted easily, and Rae almost wished she fancied Archie, because Mrs. Harris certainly would be a pleasant mother-in-law. Hassan cut in now and again with requests for his wine glass to be refilled, and George tried to engage Archie on a couple of topics, but Archie just shook his head and kept silent. Callieâs mouth stayed in a permanent smile, but not even she added to the dinner conversation. Rae almost wished for her mother and Karim to arrive early, just to liven up the dining room.Â
After dessert, Rae made her way out to the garden. It was a small garden, enough for one gardener to take care of, since the family were only in residence a few weeks out of the year. But it overlooked a small loch and you could see the distant mountains, covered in moss and heather, wreathed by fog. It was summer, and the sun lingered late in the sky this far north, and Rae watched as it slipped below the ridge line, and dusk gathered in.Â
Rae wished for the thousandth time that she could draw the dark. This dark was a purplish gray and had the muted landscape lit by both the last rays of the sun and the rising moon, lending the scene an eerie calm.Â
She breathed deeply and closed her eyes to make another wish: that Finn could be there to enjoy it with her. Just as she was imagining him coming up behind her and gently catching her in an embrace, kissing her neck like he had that day on the boat, she swore she could feel a hand on her shoulder. For a long moment, she believed she must have been dreaming it, until the hand grazed over the curve of her shoulder and down her arm. Raeâs eyes flew open and she turned to see who was there. There wasnât anyone to her left, the side sheâd felt the touch. She sighed in relief and then turned to her right, where she was face to face with . . . Hassan. He leaned towards her, as if he were going to kiss her.
She recoiled and stumbled backwards. âWhat-what the hell do you think youâre doing?â she stammered.
âRelax, please. There is no need for that sort of language. I did not mean to startle you. You just looked . . . I had not noticed . . .â He didnât seem able to articulate what it was about her, and Rae did not wish him to. How could he think he had the right to do this? After how he had treated her? Not to mention how he had treated Callie.
Raeâs brain struggled to form words, but eventually she hissed âHassan, are you mad?â
His brow furrowed instantly. âNo, I am not mad! I think we both know it is you whoââ
Rae cut him off, not interested in him turning the tables on her. He was going to answer for himself. âThen, what are you doing? Callie is just inside!â Rae gestured to the yellow glow of the well-lit windows behind them, keeping her voice to a whisper, in case anyone should come out and find them.
âIâI just wanted . . . and she does not . . .â Here he faltered. Rae knew he didnât want her; she was just the only other girl near his age and he was currently fed up with Callie. Her old friend wasnât a good time anymore; she and the secret she carried inside her had become a burden he didnât want to carry. He wanted to be in control again, to feel he had power over someone.Â
âI know,â Rae said evenly. The helplessness on Hassanâs face made her feel the smallest atom of compassion for him. He hadnât considered this would happen to him. She sighed. âBut you canât do this anymore, Hassan. You canât treat people like this, taking what you want and leaving other people to clean up your messes. You canât ruin Callieâs life because you donât like how things turned out. You have to face the consequences of your actions.â
Without a thought, Hassan shouted, âYou cannot tell me what to do!â He sounded like a petulant child, and her atom of compassion popped like a bubble and disappeared.
Rae shook her head, weary of this conversation, knowing she couldnât change his mind, glad he hadnât had any real intentions toward her. âNo, youâre right. I canât. I can only hope youâll do the right thing.â Hassan set his jaw and stared out at the loch, white lines of moonlight outlining the gentle waves. His anger was evident in his features, even in the dim moonlight. For the first time since sheâd known him, Rae sensed that anger was directed at himself. Perhaps his anger had been at himself the entire time, feeling incomplete and lost, not knowing how to channel the sorrow and disappointment he felt over his motherâs death. Rae could understand his loss, but not how he chose to cope with it. His thoughts were no longer with Rae, if they ever had been. She turned away from him to return to the house, and didn't look back.
* * *Â
That night, Rae slept soundly; they next day, she awoke refreshed. She still had a tangle of problems, but she was starting to understand herself and what she wanted, and that made all the difference. And when she looked around at the problems of her friends and family, her life didnât seem so bleak. The indignities of her past seemed farther away than ever, and though she missed Finn, ached for him, really, she reveled in the honesty of her feelings.Â
She bounded down the stairs, bound for the dining room and a plate of breakfast. At the bottom of the staircase, out of the corner of her eye, she spied two people in an embrace. She turned instinctively to see who it was and they scrambled out of sight, hearing her intake of breath. But before they were gone, she recognized Archie . . . and George.Â
Suddenly, Callieâs words came back to her. âPractically everyone knows his bread is buttered the other side . . . people donât care as much about that as they used to as long as heâs discreet . . . he thinks heâll please his mother by marrying . . .â Rae realized there was much she didnât know, but things finally clicked into place. There had been some girls at the academy, sent away because they preferred the company of girls in a âperverseâ way, and one of them had lent her a book called The Well of Loneliness.Â
And, just like that, all the goodwill sheâd woken up with was gone. Archie didnât care about her at all. Why did he make her think he did, with those flowers and letters? What was that about her being âpart of his happinessâ and him âhoping to make her happy, tooâ?Â
She marched down the hall, away from the dining room, in the direction sheâd seen Archie and George escape.Â
She opened the first door and looked around the billiard room. Nothing.
Then she crossed the hall and stuck her head into the library. No one.
At the end of the hall, there was a door that led to the addition that included the kitchen and the servants quartersâ. She didnât think they would have gone in there, but she opened the door to check, and heard someone around the alcove, breathing heavy. She poked her head around the corner to see who it was and found Archie staring back at her, wide-eyed. She could tell he wanted to run, but she wasnât having it. She stepped in front of him, using the size that she so often despised to her advantage. They were going to settle this for once and for all. She grabbed him by the lapel of his jacket and dragged him back through the door into the main hall.Â
âWhoa, where are you taking me?â he yelped.
âSomewhere where we can actually TALK about our . . . situation. Iâm tired of you running away and not listening to me.â She glanced around and chose the library. Theyâd had a heart-to-heart among books before, and she had just ascertained it was unoccupied.
âSit down,â she ordered, unballing her fist and releasing him from her grasp. He stumbled back into a chair and did as he was told. âNow talk.â
He looked down at his hands. âWhat do you want me to say, Rachel?â
âYou could start with the truth.â
âNo, I couldnât!â
âWell, Iâm not letting you mess me around anymore. You want me to be your wife? But you wonât even let me know why you want to marry me? Other than it seems to satisfy your familial expectations or . . . something.â
He remained silent.
Raeâs bravado and bravery started to melt away. âYou must really think Iâm simple.â
At this, Archie looked up, surprised. âWhat? No!â
âWell, you wonât even try to explain to me whatâs going on.â
âI CANâT!â Archie buried his head in his hands for a moment. âI really like you, Rachel. Youâre smart, and you seem to know yourself. I admire that in you, really. And, I thought you liked me. Canât that be enough? There are marriages built on much less. Things were . . . I had to say something or . . . I thought you were just stalling, playing coy! Itâs not like youâve got any better offers, have you?â
Rae, who had been softening ever so slightly, starting to feel sympathy for this boy who had messed with her mind, now sat up straighter, realization dawning. âOh! Lovely! Now I know what you really think of me. Poor, sad, fat Rae! Sheâll never get married if I donât ask her, and she can help me keep my secrets!â
Archie held his hand up to his mouth, trying to quiet her. âNo, no, thatâs notââ
âAnd whatâs more, youâre fine, absolutely fine, with consigning me to the same unhappiness you feel!â
Archie shot her a look of surprise. âWhat?â
Rae nodded to herself, everything had become very clear. âYouâve decided that Iâm a decent companion. I wonât bore you, but I wonât demand anything, either. I wonât . . . question your late nights and weekends away. Youâll have someone to introduce, someone people will wonder about, but they will figure that youâre such an intellectual, youâd never choose a wife just for how she looked on your arm. And Iâll, what? Be alone while you live the life that my presence in it makes possible?â
He shook his head in protest, âNo, no! I donât quite see how youââ
Rae interrupted him, feeling no need to hear him deny what she knew must be true. âI didnât, either, at first. And I know youâve not done it deliberately. Your mind worked out the puzzle, but you convinced yourself we could both benefit from this arrangement.â
Archie stopped shaking his head in protest to muse aloud, âWell . . . couldnât we?â
A small smile curled on Raeâs lips. âThat depends. You made assumptions about what I want out of life. What you think my life is like, and how few options you believe I have.â
Archie was thoroughly confused now and didnât even attempt to respond.
âWhen I got back from the academy, I wasnât sure what to expect, but I kept my hopes small. Romance, love, marriage, I never imagined those were on the table for me. I thought I had to earn my motherâs love, that if I werenât the best I could be, sheâd send me away again. So, I made myself scarce, thinking, if she didnât have to see me, she wouldnât be offended by what she saw. But in hiding, I was found.â
Archie looked utterly flummoxed now.
âI didnât realize it till just now, but those lovely people who make our lives livable found me. Mrs. Dewhurst, Mr. Gill, Izzy, Arnie.â She took a deep breath. âFinn.â
âAh, so thatâs how it is, eh? I can call your mother right now! I can tell her what youâve been up to and sheâll fire him and send you away soââ Archie cut himself off, like he couldnât believe heâd said those words.
Raeâs eyes grew wide as she backed away from him. âYouâd do that? To save yourself from whatever you think will happen if you are simply yourself, youâd destroy that many lives?â
âI-I donât want to, Rachel, but . . .â Archieâs voice wavered.
âYouâd be destroying Finnâs whole family, and mine, and possibly yours.â
âIâm trying to save my family, Rachel. Youâyou have no idea what awaits me if Iâm âmyselfâ as you so naively put it.â He spun on his heel and covered his face with his hands.Â
Just then, George came in the room. Seeing Archie upset, his eyes flashed angrily at Rae. âWhat have you done to him?â
âNothing,â Rae said.Â
George went and put his arm around Archie, who shrugged him off. âGet away from me! Youâre making everything impossible! IâIâI have to get out of here.â Archie ran once again.
George narrowed his eyes at Rae and she could feel the curses his brain was inventing against her. She could agree with Archie on one point of this matter. She wanted to get out there, too.
* * *
Somehow, Rae managed to make pleasantries at the table the rest of the day. It was gray and gloomy and spitting rain, so she kept to her room the rest of the time, sketching pictures of Violet from her photos, or writing in her journal. She really just wanted to leave, but her mother and Karim would be arriving soon, and she didnât feel she could. Izzy came to commiserate with her, though she didnât know about Archieâs proclivities.Â
The next day, the sun struggled out from behind the clouds now and again. At breakfast, Rae chatted with Charlotte (Mrs. Harris had insisted Rae use her first name) about drawing. Charlotte did not let on that Archie had told her anything of their discussion of the day before. And she also didnât seem to mind that Rae didnât want to marry Archie. Rae was glad that at least she wasnât being made to feel awkward by her hostess, on top of everything else.Â
Rae had tried to talk to Callie about what had happened with Archie, but Hassan kept interrupting them, like he didnât want the two of them to speak to each other. Archie and George were silently sulking at the other end of the table. Eventually, Rae just wanted to escape the dramas playing out around her.Â
After luncheon, she took her sketchbook and a tartan blanket from the chair in her room, and crept to the front door, avoiding everyone but a footman on her way out. She wandered out past the garden and found a tree in a mossy clearing. She spread out the blanket over the moss and settled back against the wide weathered trunk. After producing a few half-hearted sketches of the mountains, she lay her book to one side and closed her eyes to catch a few momentsâ sleep in the peace of this secluded spot.Â
As she always did when she found herself enjoying a moment, she wished Finn were with her to enjoy the moment. She wanted to share more and more of her moments with him. She smiled as her head drifted down until her chin was almost resting on her collarbone, breath coming deep and even. Soon, she was happily dreaming of him.
She had no idea how much time had passed, but she stirred when a boot crunched against the mossy stones near her feet. She inhaled sharply and sat up, looking around, startled, and she saw someone standing before her, the sun behind him. She squinted and held her hand up to shade her eyes. When her vision cleared, she gasped âFinn!â
So, I'm going to post Chapter 14 in a little bit. This post is in lieu of an "author's note." For the first time ever, I asked someone to take a look at it beforehand, because I'm really nervous. (It's been awhile, you know?) I got positive feedback, so I hope you guys will like it, too! I've started Chapter 15, but I'm going to probably write a chapter or two of Mad Spaced and maybe a couple of one-shots before I come back to this. It takes a lot out of me, this one! But I solemnly vow not to wait another six months. I hope not even six weeks, but we'll see.
Just need to do a few last checks and it will be up soon!Â
I think itâs a popular opinion that MMFD 1930 AU is a fanfic go-to for many of us in the fan-dem. I decided to re-read it ahead of the upcoming post of Ch14 endemictoearth (Shawna) has been diligently composing.Â
It occurred to me that it might be âfunâ to live-blog my re-reading of it. I posed this to Shawna and with her blessing, thatâs exactly what is going to happen. Now, just to clarify, this will not be a lampooning live-blogging event. Basically, I plan on linking sections of the text to chapters and posting my editorial (feels) responses with gifs for emphasis.Â
This is either a âkeep an eye outâ post or âadd me to your blacklistâ post, depending on your interest level.
Iâll tag all the posts with #darlingdiver re-reads MMFD 1930AU
Yâall, this is going to be fun. Buckle-up, itâs happening. This is your warning shot, live-blogging will commence in a few hours and then continue on/off over the next few days. Gotta make a quick stop into a party, drink some sangria and then Iâll be primed and ready to roll.
You poor thing... You're putting all this effort into the next chapter of the 1930sAU, and we are all going to gobble it down within minutes and then reflexively start obsessing over the next part. We are like addicts, and you have the only source to appease our addiction. I would like to apologize ahead of time for obsessing over part 15 before part 14 is even finished. :)
Awwww, thanks Anon! I wouldnât keep writing it if the drive wasnât there, and Iâm just glad I got my creative juices flowing again over this story. I can only hope and pray that this next chapter lives up to the hype and makes up for the hiatus! Thatâs my biggest worry right now.
Iâve devoured other peopleâs fanfiction, and totally understand that itâs something that takes a lot of effort to produce, but little effort to enjoy ⊠though I think your concern is so thoughtful and lovely.
I got knocked out by a bit of a cold these last few days, and though my plan is still to put the story up by Thursday, please forgive me if thereâs a tiny delay.
And, of course, I canât say when chapter 15 will be out, but I promise you wonât have to wait another six months. :)
Thanks for hanging in there, Anon and everyone else!
I deactivated my previous tumblr account, so all of my "likes" on your chapters disappeared. :( I will show them some love as soon as I'm on a computer and find the chapters!
Oh, you really don't have to do that!! I mean, if you happen to reread them at some point and feel so inclined, go ahead, but don't feel you have to because I'm a nerd who noticed a discrepancy! YOU ARE TOO KIND, LOVELY ANON. Thank you for thinking of it, though!
if ya really want to know...i have you followed so that i remmber to start reading this fic sooon
Thank you for the follow and for your interest! I hope when you do, you enjoy it! :)
(I was worried that my post would come off as "why aren't you people liking my story?" when I absolutely didn't mean it to. I genuinely find it interesting how people interact with this site and the internet, why some people like things and others, y'know like them but don't click anything to make it "official". It's just intriguing to me.)
So, when I logged in the other day, I noticed that there were a few more followers than last time, even through this long silence. And when I broke the silence, I gained a few more. And then, something occurred to me that hadn't really before. That this blog, which is essentially JUST for this story (yes, there are a few other posts, but all related/reminiscent of the AU) has over 500 followers, and yet each chapter only has between 80-120 notes. (I guess that follows the 80-20 rule pretty closely.)Â
And I guess that's why publishing on AO3 or ff.net makes sense, because you get a more accurate idea of how many people are seeing your stories. You get a view count. Now, I could set up analytics on each chapter and find out how many people (ostensibly) read them, but it's really more of a curiosity for me.
I mean, I guess people are interested in the story that don't click the heart for whatever reason. And I'm SURE that some of the people following this story maybe don't use Tumblr that much anymore and just haven't deactivated their accounts or whatever. It's a kind of mystery or puzzle that I could work on but probably won't. Because it doesn't really matter.
I really don't know what I'm trying to get at with all this, just that, it didn't really dawn on me that more than the folks who like/comment/reblog were reading the story. (I knew it somewhere in the back of my brain, I'm sure.) And their silence is intriguing to me.