Spilled Sodas
Pairings: Cassie McKay x Fem!Reader
Summary: When Cassie drags you to a Dodgers game with the promise of making it a date, she fucks it up. Now, she has no choice but to make it up to you.
Word Count: 7.3k
Warnings: Mild angst | Cassie being a jerk and then showing how downbad she really is | Smut - Fingering (Reader!Receiving), Oral (Reader!Receiving)
Traffic moved toward the stadium in slow waves, the city highlighted gold by the evening sun. The windows were cracked just enough to let cool air move through the car, carrying distant noise from outside
Cassie looked completely relaxed behind the wheel.
One hand rested at the top of the steering wheel while the other stayed spread across your thigh, fingers warm against your skin. Every so often her thumb moved without her realizing it, small, absentminded strokes while she talked.
âAnd if they keep playing like they did last week,â she explained, eyes still on the road ahead. âTheyâll probably keep this lineup through postseason.â
You looked over at her from where your head rested against the seat. âI know you think I understand what youâre saying.â
She frowned slightly. âBut you do understand. I explained this earlier.â
âNo,â you said honestly. âIâm just listening because your voice is nice.â
That pulled a soft chuckle out of her. âWell thank you, baby. For putting up with me.â
âMhm.â
She shook her head in amusement.
The closer you got, the thicker traffic became. Cars packed around you with Dodgers flags hanging from windows, groups of people crossing streets in jerseys and caps.
Cassie kept talking anyway. She just got like this when she was excited about something. She couldnât exactly help it, but you didnât mind.
âAnd Garcia swears theyâre gonna fall apart by August, but she says that every season so nobody listens to her anymore.â
You hummed quietly, tracing your fingers along the frays of your shorts. âWhoâs the one you said takes baseball weirdly seriously?â
âLangdon.â
âThe one with the hair?â
That pulled a snort from her. âYeah, babe. The one with the hair.â
You nodded like that meant something to you. Truthfully, most of Cassieâs coworkers blurred together after a while. You knew stories more than faces at this point.
âYou shouldâve heard them arguing,â Cassie said, smiling to herself now. âIt went on for like half the shift.â
That argument is precisely how you got here in the first place.
Earlier that week, the emergency department had been unusually calm for once. Someone had the Dodgers game playing near the nurses station while everybody worked, and at some point Garcia made a comment about the team blowing the series.
That shouldâve been the end of it.
Instead, Langdon argued back. Then Santos joined in. Then Whitaker started looking up stats on his phone while pretending he didnât care enough to participate.
Ahmad simply made the entire thing worseâalways one to add fuel to the fire.
Heâd turned around in his chair and started collecting predictions from everybody like he was hosting some kind of game show instead of working another security guard shift in the Pitt.
Garcia said the Dodgers would lose.
Langdon insisted theyâd win in six.
Santos mostly participated to annoy Garcia.
Whitaker claimed everybody was overreacting while continuing to contribute statistics nobody asked for or paid any attention to. And somewhere in the middle of all of it, he mentioned he had two Dodgers tickets he wasnât going to use because his brother canceled on him at the last minute.
That was when the bet stopped being casual.
Ahmad immediately decided whoever guessed the series outcome closest got the tickets.
Cassie had only joined because everybody else was already involved and in the end, the Dodgers won exactly the way she predicted they would. Which meant she walked out of her shift with two tickets and an ego big enough to be genuinely irritating about it.
You still remembered the way she came through your apartment door that night.
Still in scrubs, bangs messy from a twelve hour shift, exhausted, but smiling so hard the second she saw you that you knew immediately she was about to ask for something.
âWhat?â you asked from the couch before she could even speak.
Cassie dropped her bag by the door. âI have a surprise.â
âShould I be scared?â
âNo, you should be proud of me.â
You laughed skeptically at your girlfriend. âOkay, let me rephrase that. What did you do?â
âI won.â
âYou saying that with no context is terrifying.â
Cassie walked over to the couch, already digging into the pocket of her scrub pants before pulling out the tickets.
Your eyebrows lifted immediately. âThose are real?â
âAs real as they get.â
You took them from her carefully, looking down at the Dodgers logo printed across the front. âYou won baseball tickets?â
âI won the bet.â Cassie explained, sitting down beside you close enough that her knee pressed against yours.
âCassâŠâ
âI know, I know.â she said quickly, gently pulling the tickets from your hand and setting them down on the coffee table. She took your free hands into hers like she was trying to coax a shy puppy out of its cage.
âI donât even like baseball.â
âBut you like me though, right?â
You looked at her unimpressed.
Cassie was sitting up straight, watching you carefully now. She looked excited, but quieter about it suddenly, like she truly cared what your answer would be.
âWe donât have to stay the whole game,â she assured. âI just thought itâd be nice.â
âYou want to spend your Friday night explaining baseball to me?â
âI want to spend my Friday night with you.â
That was the problem with her sometimes. She said things like that so simply that it made it hard to argue back.
âAnd,â she added after a second. âIâll make it feel just like a date. Promise.â
You narrowed your eyes at her slightly. âA baseball game.â you said bluntly.
âA date at a baseball game.â
âI bet that sounded different in your head than it did out loud.â
Cassie laughed then, leaning closer until her shoulder bumped yours. âCome on,â she said softly. âPlease?â
And honestly, it wasnât really the tickets that convinced you.
It was her.
The way she looked genuinely excited at the idea of bringing you somewhere she loved. So eventually, after enough convincing, a kiss to your cheek, and Cassie promising multiple times that she wouldnât spend the whole game neglecting you for baseballâyou agreed.
Now, sitting in the passenger seat while stadium lights glowed ahead of you, you were starting to think maybe it had been worth saying yes after all.
Cassie pulled into the parking lot slowly, rows of cars stretching around you. âYou look beautiful by the way.â she said suddenly.
Her eyes flicked briefly toward your outfit before she parked expertly between two cars.
Youâd spent longer getting ready than you originally planned to. Jean shorts, white top, the oversized Dodgers jersey Cassie insisted you borrow hanging open over it all.
A little more makeup than you usually wore on a daily basis, mostly because she kept calling this a date all week and somewhere along the way, you began treating it like one too.
âYou already said that before we left,â you reminded her.
âI know.â Cassie shut the car off, looking over at you fully now. âJust felt like telling you again.â
Warmth crept up your face before you looked away toward the windshield. She reached over, brushing her fingers briefly against your thigh again before opening her door. She fell into step beside you, immediately reaching for your hand as the two of you started toward the entrance.
The stadium felt different once you were actually inside it. The music, the announcers, the buzz of thousands of voices blending togetherâeverything echoed. People moved with trays of food and drinks through the crowded walkways while the smell of popcorn and hot dogs hung in the air.
Cassie walked slightly ahead of you, turning back every few seconds to make sure you were still there despite her firm grip on your hand.
You let her pull you toward concessions first, mostly because she looked so confident weaving through the stadium like sheâd done this a hundred times before.
Popcorn. Nachos. Two drinks.
You watched her while she waited for everything, the way she shifted her weight impatiently from foot to foot, already glancing around toward the field every few seconds like she was trying not to miss anything before the game had even officially started.
It was kind of adorable.
She balanced the food carefully while leading you toward your section, occasionally stopping to look at signs overhead before continuing down another set of stairs.
âYou really know where youâre going,â you said.
Cassie glanced back over her shoulder. âI studied the map.â
âYou studied the map?â
âSo I knew where to go. I didnât want to have you just walking around.â
The way she said it made your heart skip a beat in your chest againâbecause of how hard she was trying to make this enjoyable for you.
Cassie let you slide into your seat first before sitting beside you, setting the popcorn between your legs and drinks in the cupholders.
You looked around, and it was actually kind of nice. The sky had gone fully dark now, the lights shining against it while people settled into their seats all around you.
Cassie watched your face carefully for a second. âWell?â she asked.
You looked over at her. âOkay. I kind of get why people like this.â
A grin spread across her face immediately. âYeah?â
âDonât get too excited.â
âToo late.â
Cassie relaxed back into her seat beside you and when you shifted closer, she adjusted. Her arm stretched around the back of your seat so you could tuck yourself against her side comfortably.
âThere you are,â Cassie murmured quietly.
You peered up slightly. âWhat?â
âYou finally stopped acting like I kidnapped you.â
âIâm still deciding, thank you.â
Cassie chuckled, looking down at you for a second before smiling to herself. A few minutes later, she reached into the popcorn bucket and held a piece near your mouth without saying anything.
You stared at her and she just lifted her eyebrows slightly.
You laughed under your breath before leaning forward enough to take it from her fingers.
âSee?â she said. âYouâre already getting into the baseball experience.â
âItâs just popcorn.â
âItâs stadium popcorn. Different thing entirely.â
You rolled your eyes a little, but you were smiling.
At one point, while you were simply watching the field more than actually paying attention to it, she turned your head slightly and kissed you quick enough that it almost caught you off guard. Just one soft press of her lips against yours before she leaned back again like nothing happened.
You looked at her.
Cassie fought back her grin as if she was trying to seem oblivious, eyes already drifting back toward the field again. âWhat?â
âNothing.â
But warmth lingered in your chest afterward anywayâand for a while, you really did think the night was going to be fun.
Then the game started.
The crowd got louder, thousands of people focused in the same direction all at once, and beside you, Cassie changed with it.
The second the players ran onto the field, she was on her feet with everybody else around you, clapping loudly, yelling toward the field with a grin wider than youâd seen all night.
The sudden noise and movement from her startled you enough that you jerked slightly where you satâpreviously cuddled up to her side.
At first, you tried following along.
Every few minutes the crowd exploded over something happening on the field you didnât understand quickly enough to follow. And every time it happened, Cassie got pulled into it instantly.
Even though you didnât understand most of what was going on, you had to admit the concentrated look on her face was cute. Sheâd lean closer to you between plays so you could hear, explaining things quickly while still watching the game.
âThat guyâs been struggling all season, so if he gets on base right nowââ
The entire crowd roared before she could finish explaining and Cassie stood right back up with them, eyes fixed on the field while people around you shouted and clapped.
You looked out at the game, trying to figure out what everyone was reacting to, but by the time you understood where to even look, the moment was already over.
For a while, you didnât really mind.
You mostly watched her.
The way she hunched forward during close plays. The way she reacted half a second before the crowd sometimes, like she already knew what was about to happen.
She looked happy, and honestly, that was enough.
But eventually, you started feeling the distance between you grow anyway.
âCass, look at that guy on the screenââ
âWait, hold on, baby.â Cassie said, her hand falling to our arm briefly as if to stop you while her eyes stayed fixed ahead. âI think theyâre reviewing the play.â
You nodded along, but it quickly started happening more. Every time you tried getting her attention, the game interrupted first.
âCassââ
âHold on.â
âWait, lookââ
âOne second, baby.â
And after a while, you mostly stopped trying.
You just huffed, slouching back into your seat while the game pulled more and more of her attention away from you a little at a time.
It almost seemed like she acknowledged strangers more than she did you, as she talked with the people sitting beside you over bad calls made by the umpires.
The worst part was she didnât even realize she was doing it.
Then the home run happened.
One second everybody was tense and focusedâthe next, the entire stadium exploded into screaming.
âHoly shit!â
Cassie sprung up suddenly and her knee slammed into the seat hard enough to jolt the drink from the cupholder. You barely even had time to react before freezing cold soda spilled down the front of your shirt and straight into your lap.
The shock of the icy drink made you suck in a breath immediately, and Cassie froze immediately. Her face fell and her eyes dropped to your soaked clothes before widening.
âOh shitâbaby.â she dropped back into her seat, grabbing the few napkins from beside the popcorn bucket so fast they nearly tore in her hands.
âIâm sorry,â she rambled. âIâm so sorry.â
She started trying to blot the soda from your shirt frantically, despite clearly realizing that there was way too much for a few napkins to fix.
âI didnât evenâfuck.â Cassie looked up at you again, guilt written all over her face.
âItâs okay,â you said, even though your voice came out tighter than you meant it to.
She kept trying anyway, dabbing uselessly at your clothes while apologizing under her breath. You looked down at yourself for a second before exhaling quietly through your nose.
And suddenly the whole night hit you all at once.
The noise.
The crowdedness.
The constant feeling that youâd come here to spend time with Cassie, while she came here to watch baseball.
You caught her wrist gently, stopping her movements. âCass,â you said, and her eyes found yours immediately. âIâm just gonna go to the bathroom.â
Her expression fell even further, like she knew there wasnât really anything she could say right now that would help. âOkay,â she said softly.
You nodded once before stepping past her and disappearing up the row of stairs.
â â
By the time you came back, your shirt was still damp. Not soaked anymore, but enough that you could still feel it clinging uncomfortably against your skin underneath the jersey.
You walked back down your row expecting to find Cassie completely focused on the game again. Instead, her head lifted from the field almost instantly the second she saw you.
Relief crossed her face so fast it made your chest ache a little despite yourself.
âThere you are,â she stood to let you pass before holding out a folded blue Dodgers hoodie from the merch stand in one hand, your favorite candy awkwardly tucked into it.
You blinked once.
Cassie rubbed the back of her neck lightly and swallowed. âI didnât know what else to do,â she admitted quietly.
Some of the irritation in your chest loosened at the embarrassment she obviously felt, and you took the hoodie carefully from her hands. âThank you.â
âIs your shirt stained?â
âA little.â
âYeah,â Cassie muttered. âIâm really sorry about that.â
Then, before you could answer, the crowd erupted into angered remarks at something happening on the field again.
Cassieâs gaze flicked to the field on instinct. âOhâwait wait.â
She sat back down quickly, eyes already returning to the game while you pulled the hoodie over your damp shirt.
A second later she leaned toward you again, pointing towards the players. âOkay, this is what I was trying to explain earlier.â
And the rest of the game passed exactly like that. Cassie zeroed in on the game just as she was before, and you now wanting nothing more than to just go home.
â â
When the game finally ended, the entire stadium was on its feet. The Dodgers won, and Cassie looked thrilled. She laughed, already speaking before the two of you had even fully stepped out of your row.
âI told you theyâd pull it off,â she said, looking over at you with flushed cheeks and that same bright excitement sheâd had all night. âDid you see that last play?â
You smiled faintly. âMhm.â
Cassie continued on while the two of you slowly moved with the crowd toward the exits, her hand finally finding yours. Most of it faded together after a whileâsomething about pitching, something about defense, players names you still didnât know.
You just listened quietly beside her.
The parking lot was chaos afterward, headlights stretching endlessly between rows of cars while people yelled across the lot still riding the energy of the game.
Cassie was still riding the high of the win too. She kept talking as she drove, replaying moments from the game out loud, occasionally shaking her head and laughing to herself when she got to a part she still couldn't believe happened.
You listened with your head resting against the window.
Every now and then you'd hum or nod just enough to acknowledge you were listening, but the conversation never really became a conversation.
When the car came to a stop at a red light, Cassieâs hand settled back onto your thigh, warm and familiar just like it had been earlier.
Only this time, you turned slightly toward the window without really thinking about it.
Cassie noticed anyway, her words trailing off for a second before she glanced over at you briefly. âYou okay?â
You kept your eyes on the passing lights outside. âYep.â
Then the light turned green. She looked at you for another second like she was trying to decide whether she believed that, but decided to drop it, her gaze falling back on the road ahead.
By the time Cassie pulled into your apartment complex, you felt drained.
The second the car stopped, you reached for the door, and the sound of it shutting behind you made Cassie pause.
Not just because it was loudâ but also because you moved fast too. You were already halfway up the walkway before she'd even grabbed her keys.
And the moment she'd ignored at the red light returned to her mind immediately. When she finally caught up to you, you had gotten the apartment door unlocked.
"Hey,â she said.
You didn't stop.
The door swung open as you stepped over the threshold, and Cassie barely caught it before it closed on her. Inside, the apartment was quiet. After spending three hours in a packed stadium, the silence felt eerily strange.
Just the faint hum of the refrigerator and the soft click of the door shutting completely. Behind you, Cassie dropped her keys onto the counter, the sound echoing through the room.
For a second she just watched you.
You kicked your shoes off by the door and headed toward the living room. The Dodgers hoodie followed next, pulling it over your head and tossing it onto the couch.
The shirt underneath clung to your skin.
Hours later, the soda had mostly dried, but it left behind a tacky material that stretched across your stomach every time the fabric shifted.
God, you wanted a shower.
âOkay,â Cassie finally spoke up, her voice breaking through the quiet. âWhatâs going on?â
You shrugged off the button up jersey she insisted on you wearing, discarding that onto the back of the couch as well, leaving you in a white tank top. Cool air finally hit your skin, and it felt refreshing after the long game youâd sat through.
"Nothing's going on."
"Come on, I know thatâs not true."
âEverythingâs fine, Cassie.â
"Baby,â
You rolled your eyes, huffing in annoyance before finally deciding to look at her. She was still standing by the front door, her hands on her hips as she studied you carefully.
You broke eye contact first. "Next time just take Langdon."
The words slipped out before you could stop them, and Cassie's eyebrows shot up. "What?"
You shrugged. "You would've had more fun."
"With Langdon?"
"Or Santos. Or Garcia. Whoever else."
Cassie looked genuinely baffled. "Where is this coming from?"
"You spent the whole night talking baseball with the people around us anyway."
A small crease appeared between her browsâshe still wasn't following. "Okay..."
You laughed quietly to yourself, shaking your head, because somehow she still didn't get it. "You know what? Forget it."
You turned toward the hallway that led to the bedroom, however, Cassie caught your wrist before you could get very far. Not roughly, just enough to stop you.
"Hey."
You glanced down at her hand wrapped around your arm, then back up at her. "What?"
"What are you actually upset about?"
The question irritated you immediately and you pulled your wrist free.
"What am I upset about?" you stared at her for a second in disbelief that she even had to ask. "Cassie, I just sat through two and a half hours of baseball."
At that, a smile immediately threatened to appear on her face.
You pointed a finger at her. "Stop it."
Cassie bit the inside of her cheek, trying and failing to hide it. You shook your head and started pacing toward the couch.
"I don't even like baseball. I spent the entire night pretending to understand what was happening."
"I know, baby. And I appreciate you for that."
"Yet somehow you're still looking at me like Iâm a joke."
The amusement faded from her face instantly at your words. Maybe she should be taking this more seriously than she was. "Then tell me what I'm missing."
You stopped pacing now to actually look at her. "I went because you wanted me there." your voice came out quieter this time.
Cassie's expression visibly softened from the change. Like the irritation had faded and a tinge of vulnerability began to emerge even if you didnât mean for it to.
"I thought I was finally gonna spend a night with my girlfriend after a busy couple weeks." you said, continuing before she could respond. "I got ready, I stood in front of my closet for twenty minutes trying to figure out what you wear to a baseball game."
Her eyes moved over your outfit automaticallyâor what was left of it, but she remembered exactly how you looked before youâd left the house.
A small smile tugged at the corner of her mouth. Not teasing, but fond. Which somehow made you more annoyed.
"I was trying to look nice."
"You did look nice."
"That's not the point."
"Then what's the point?"
"The point is that I felt like I was sitting next to the commentator instead of my girlfriend the entire time."
Something shifted in Cassie's face, you saw the way it fell immediately. The realization or at least something close to it.
Good, maybe she was finally listening.
"And then you dumped your soda on me."
Cassie groaned, throwing her head back. "Oh my God, that was an accidentâ"
"I was marinating in Coke for hours. I still am."
âOkay,â despite herself, she let out a short, humorless laugh, rubbing a hand over her face. "Okay, yeah. That was pretty bad. You still looked cute in the hoodie, though."
"Cassie."
"Iâm sorry."
You stared at her blankly, like you were trying to confirm if she was actually being serious before sighing and shaking your head.
"I should've just stayed home."
"Baby, noâ"
"I would've had a better time if I did."
âCome on, donât say that.â
She watched as you began collecting your clothes from the cushions, and reached for you. Her arms went to wrap around your waist, but you stepped back before she could fully touch you.
Cassie's hands dropped, and so did her expression.
"I'm gonna go take a shower."
"Babyâ"
"Not right now." you inhaled through your nose as you turned and headed down the hallway. "I still feel gross."
This time, she didnât try to stop you. Her mouth opened only to close when she couldnât find the right thing to say, if there even was such a thing in that moment.
A few seconds later, she heard the bathroom door shut, the sound ringing through the apartment. Cassie stood in the living room for a second longer before slowly sinking onto the couch.
Her eyes landed in the direction of the bedroom you left.
Then on your abandoned shoes by the door.
And finally on the empty spot beside her.
At first she just stared, then squeezed her eyes shut and leaned back into the cushions, mentally cursing herself for how stupid sheâd been. The more she replayed the night, the worse she felt.
Because she recounted the amount of instances you'd tried to spend time with her while her focus was somewhere else.
A knot formed in her stomach.
Then the spilled drink.
At the time she'd been focused on cleaning up the mess and getting you something to cover up with. Now all she could picture was you sitting there uncomfortable for hours while she kept talking about the game.
The realization made heat creep up the back of her neck.
Fuck.
Cassie pressed her lips together. You hadn't been asking for much.
Just her attention. Just a date. Just her.
She thought about the drive home and how quiet you'd been. How she'd filled every silence with baseball again. How she'd only asked if you were okay when you physically pulled away from her.
She let out a heavy sigh, because you were right.
â â
The apartment was still buzzing with silence when you stepped out of the bedroom.
The shower had helpedâmaybe not with your mood, but at least you no longer felt like dried soda was glued to your skin. Youâd changed into an oversized t-shirt and a pair of sleep shorts, the clean set of clothes making you feel refreshed.
Cassie looked up the millisecond she heard you coming down the hallway.
Sheâd remained in her spot on the couch the whole time you were gone. Not watching television, or scrolling on her phone. Just sitting there. And the second she saw you, she straightened slightly.
She watched as you made your way over to the kitchen, mentally debating if now was the time, before deciding to follow. The couch cushions shifted under her weight as she stood up.
âHey,â she said quietly, her feet brushing against the floor, slow.
As if she were approaching cautiously because she wasnât sure how youâd react. Her shoulders dropped a little when you ignored her, only opening a cabinet to grab a glass.
âBaby,â
This time a faint hum left you.
Not exactly an answer, and also not completely disregarding her. You filled the glass from the refrigerator water dispenser, and Cassie appeared behind you a few seconds later. She didnât touch you, but she was close enough that you could feel her presence.
âIâm sorry.â
You took a sip from your cup. âHm.â
Cassie sighed, the sound carrying a little frustration with it. Because for someone who spent all day talking baseball, she suddenly couldnât figure out what to say.
You downed the rest of your drink and set the glass beside the sink, turning to leave again. But before you could get more than a step away, Cassieâs hand closed gently around your wrist.
The movement happened so quickly you barely processed it.
One second you were planning to leave, the next you were being spun back around and your feet had left the floor. She lifted you like you weighed absolutely nothing and set you on the countertop.
Immediately, she stepped between your knees and her hands braced themselves on either side of you, effectively trapping within her arms.
Your eyes widened as you blinked at her. âWhat are you doing?â
âIâm trying to get you to listen to me.â
âI was listening to you.â
Cassie raised an eyebrow, the action alone telling you she didnât believe that for a second.
âNo,â she denied slowly. âYou mightâve been listening to my voice but you werenât hearing what I was saying.â
You scoffed. âYeah, doesnât feel too great does it?â
That response shocked her into silence, and her mouth pressed into a thin line. Your arms folded across your chest as you looked past her shoulder toward the living room, toward anything except her stare.
Clearly you were still very upset.
For a moment neither of you said a word.
Cassie eventually inhaled a deep breath before speaking up. âYou were right. About everything.â she started softly.
Your jaw tightened immediately.
You hated hearing that because it made it harder to stay angry.
For the last hour youâd been mentally preparing for this exact conversation. Planning what you were going to say and how you were going to say it. Now, she was agreeing with you.
It was annoying.
âI didnât realize how dismissive I was being, and I hurt you.â
A quiet sigh escaped through your nose that Cassie noticed instantly.
âYou werenât there because you wanted to watch baseball.â she said. âYou were there because I asked you to be.â
Your fingers tightened around your folded arms. The words landed harder than you wanted them to because that was exactly it. You hadnât gone for the Dodgers, you had gone for her.
âI keep thinking about you trying to talk to me.â Cassieâs voice stayed quiet. âI remember now, and I hate that I brushed you off the way I did.â
Your eyes dropped briefly to the counter between you at the memory of how upset you gradually became, how embarrassed you were.
âI was so excited about the game, but thatâs not an excuse.â she watched your face carefully when you continued avoiding her gaze.
âI meant it when I said I wanted it to be a date.â
Your gaze flicked back to her at that.
For the first time since youâd come out of the shower, and Cassieâs eyes softened immediately when she realized sheâd finally gotten your attention.
âI wasnât lying.â
You looked at herâreally looked at her, and the sincerity in her gaze made all of your built up walls nearly crumble on the spot.
âI just got carried away.â a tiny smile pulled at one corner of her mouth. âAnd apparently I turned into some crazed Dodgers fan.â
Your lips twitched before you could stop them, and immediately your mouth flattened again.
But it was too late.
âThere she is.â a faint warmth appeared in her eyes.
You rolled your eyes and looked away again. âDonât ruin it.â
The smile that spread across Cassieâs face was soft, relieved. Like sheâd been waiting all night to see even the slightest crack in your stubbornness.
Cassie slid her hands to your waist, pulling you closer to the edge of the counter and against her front. This time you let her, and a warm kiss landed against your cheek.
Then another.
âCassie.â you warned.
And another.
âYes, baby?â
âYou think you can fix everything with kisses?â
âI can try.â she pressed another to your jawline. âIs it working?â
Her hands settled on the top of your thighs, and you became suddenly hyperaware of how close she was standing. The argument had distracted you from it before, but now there was nothing else to focus on other than her.
She pulled back to look at you, and your gaze dropped to her hand placement for a second before meeting hers again.
âYou know,â she said softly. âYouâre really cute when youâre pretending youâre still mad at me.â
You scoffed immediately. âYouâre not completely off the hook yet. Youâre still in trouble.â
âYeah?â
âVery serious trouble.â
She breathed out a sigh. âI guess that just means Iâm gonna have to make it up to you.â her hands glided higher as her mouth returned to your neck.
You fought to keep your eyes open at the feeling of her soft lips on you. Your head tilted to give her more room against your better judgement. As much as this is how you wanted your night to goâyou were still pissed at her.
âHm?â she murmured, her mouth trailing further down. âAre you gonna let me make it up to you, babygirl?â
A gasp caught in your throat when her teeth grazed your skin. She paused at your pulse point, focusing on that spot for a moment as she nipped gently before soothing the bite with an opened mouthed kiss.
Her lips then captured yours.
The way she kissed you so deeply honestly caught you off guard. It was different from the quick, brief pecks sheâd given you earlier before the game. Like she wanted you to feel how sorry she really was instead of just saying it.
You soon pulled back just enough to get some air, your lips barely brushing hers. âBetter get on with it before I change my mind.â
Cassie chuckled and she didnât give you time to respond before she hauled you off the counter. A startled gasp escaped you and you clung to her instinctively, legs tightening around her middle and arms wrapping around her shoulders as she carried you towards the bedroom.
The door clicked shut with a nudge of her foot, and the mattress dipped under your weight as Cassie laid you down, crawling to hover over you. Your hands tugged at her jersey and she instantly pulled it over her head, tossing it somewhere on the floor. You always loved the feeling of her skin on yours.
Her mouth found yours once more. Cassieâs hands wasted no time in gliding up your sides, the usual coldness of her hands a sharp contrast to the warmth of your freshly washed skin. Your shirt was soon bunched up above your chest, and a shiver ran down your spine when her thumb brushed over your sensitive nipple.
You gasped lightly into the kiss, and Cassie smiled victoriously. She parted from your lips, trailing kisses down your throat until she reached your breasts. She focused on the left one first, her mouth closing around the areola as her tongue swirled around your nipple.
Heat shot straight to your core, soft whimpers falling from your lips at the stimulation. Her hand cupped the right one, giving it a firm squeeze before her fingers began toying with the hardened bud.
She pulled, twisted, rubbedâyou could feel your panties getting embarrassingly soaked by the second from the way they were sticking to you.
Cassie switched to the other breast, giving it the same attention. Her tongue circled around your nipple before latching back on. Only when your hips began bucking up into her did she chuckle, taking the hint.
Her hand traveled lower until they reached the waistband of your shorts, slipping beneath the fabric. She was instantly met with dampness, your slick generously coating her fingers. Your breath hitched at the feeling of her touch exactly where you needed it.
She pulled off your breast with a grin. âJesus, baby.â she teased, her fingers sliding under your panties to run along your slit. âThis wet for me already?â
You wanted to roll your eyes at the comment, but a moan was forced out of you at the sudden intrusion of her two fingers. She chuckled at the look of pleasure that settled on your face. Your eyes had fallen shut and your head rested back into the pillows.
âFuckâCassie,â
âYeah, baby? That feel good?â she drew back before pushing in again, curling her fingers once she was knuckle deep. âGod, youâre so beautiful.â
The spot she was hitting so accurately made your walls clench around her fingers, eager to keep them inside. A soft moan fell from your lips as she fucked you slowly, and you thought she was finally going to give you what youâd been waiting for, but all of a suddenâshe pulled out.
Your eyelids flew open. âCassie,â you groaned, staring at her in annoyance.
She was walking a fine line from earlier and you still werenât particularly happy with her, so this was in no way helping her case, but she paid no mind to your scolding.
âRelax, baby.â she said, sitting up to pull your underwear and shorts down your legs. âIâll take care of you, donât worry.â
Cassie ran her hands soothingly along your calves as she returned to her position between your thighs. She laid flat on her stomach and let your legs drape over her shoulders, now staring directly at your dripping cunt.
You had expected to be met with more teasingâCassie loved to make you wait and get you all riled up before giving you what you wanted. Youâd anticipated maybe another finger that she would refuse to sink in deep enough to satisfy you, or maybe a stroke of her tongue that she wouldnât let you feel long enough to actually be pleasurable.
Thatâs why your breath caught so roughly in your throat when she dove in like a woman starved. You werenât prepared for the way her tongue glided through your folds with a delicious pressure that made your eyes roll back into your head. When she reached your clit she sucked hard, moaning into you at the taste she never got tired of.
The vibrations made you cry out and your legs tried to involuntarily shut around her head, but her hands wrapped around your thighs to keep them open.
âOh, fuckâCassââ
Cassie ate you out desperately, her mouth working wonders on your cuntâlike all she wanted was to make you feel good after a night of making you feel like shit.
She traced her tongue around the sensitive bud before closing her lips on it and sucking firmly in a way that had you keening and your hips bucked on their own accord.
Her tongue ran along your slit, probing at your aching hole for a moment before pushing all the way in. Your hands grabbed at her, looking for anything to hold as her tongue fucked deep into you.
You made the mistake of looking down at her at that moment, because her gaze was already locked on you.
The sight of your girlfriendâwho you were thoroughly pissed off at not even a half hour agoâlying between your legs with your arousal glistening on her face as she fucked you with her tongue could have made you cum on the spot if you werenât deliberately holding yourself back.
Her eye contact remained unwavering, and the attention would have been overwhelming if it wasnât exactly what you had been wishing for all night. You were the first to break it, your eyes closing as keeping them open proved to be impossible with the pure ecstasy running through your body from her ministrations.
Your hand tangled in her hair and she groaned when you tugged, but she didnât stop you. You were getting close, and she knew it from the way your walls were tightening around her tongue. Her thumb began to rub circles into your clit. Your other hand finally released its grip on the sheets to find her.
âFuck, pleaseâCass, pleaseââ
It was too much and not enough all at once, you couldnât decide whenever to push her away or pull her closer. She used her free hand to lace her fingers with yours, offering a grounding touch as she doubled down on her efforts.
Her tongue curled, finding that angle that made you cry out for her. A few more perfectly timed thrusts and a particularly hard rub at your clit, and you were falling over the edge.
Your back arched as you went silent, and Cassie had to pry your clamped thighs open so she could fuck you through it properly. It washed over you in waves, and when you eventually came down you had to push her away to get her to stop.
She gave in to your protests and sat up, gently guiding your legs back down to the bed. Your chest heaved as you tried to regain your air, and the fucked out expression on your face made her smile.
Cassie probably didnât look any better.
Her hair was disheveled, and she wiped her face that was most definitely covered in your slick with the back of her hand. She moved to hover over you, her forearms resting on either side of your head. She brushed your hair back from your forehead as she peppered kisses across your cheek.
âMy sweet girl,â she murmured. âYou have no idea what you do to me.â
You hummed lightly, your eyes still shut as you allowed your body to come down from your high. She connected her lips with yours, and you moaned quietly at the taste of yourself still evident in her mouth.
Cassie pulled away, pecking your lips once before sitting up. She unzipped her pants that were somehow still on and kicked them to the floor before sliding back into bed beside you. She tugged the blanket over your naked body and gathered you into her arms.
The apartment had gone quiet again, but this one was comfortable. Not the tense silence that had followed your earlier argument.
âYou okay?â she asked gently.
âMhm,â you responded. âCan we just stay like this for a bit?â
Cassie pressed her lips to your hairline. âYeah, of course, baby.â
You laid against Cassie for a while, basking in that post-sex bliss. You traced absentminded circles against the back of her hand where she intertwined your fingers, and neither of you seemed particularly ready to move.
Cassie was the first to break the silence.
âI really am sorry.â
You smiled faintly. âI know, Cass. Itâs okay.â
âNo.â she gave your hand a gentle squeeze. âNo itâs not okay.â
That made you turn your head, and she was already looking at you.
âI donât ever want to be the reason you have a bad day.â she let out a quiet breath. âYouâre supposed to enjoy being with me and I just hate knowing I made you feel alone while you were sitting right next to me.â
You watched her for a moment before reaching up to smooth down her bangs on her forehead.
âYou did.â you said, and her eyes visibly saddened. âButâŠâ you smiled a little. âYou made up for it and I forgive you.â
Cassie chuckled lightly. âI was hoping youâd say that.â
You laughed before focusing in on her hand again. After a moment, you spoke up. âYou knowâŠI never told you this.â
âWhat?â
âI still have no idea what an inning is.â
Cassie stared at you in disbelief for exactly one second before she broke out into a grin. âYou sat through that whole game,â
âMhm.â
âAnd you still donât know?â
âNope.â
She shook her head, laughing. âI must be a pretty shit teacher then.â
You smiled to yourself and pressed a kiss to her cheek. âIâd do it again, though.â
Cassie looked up in shock. âYou would?â
âYeah.â you said. âIt was nice at first. You know, before the game started.â
Her expression softened as she looked at you, and she leaned in to kiss you softly. âYou have no clue how much I love you.â she murmured against your lips. âNext time Iâll make sure itâs actually worth it.â
âI know you will, and I love you too.â
She would definitely be calling out of work next weekend to take you on a proper date.
~ end ~


















