How ATLA bends its bending rules
In just these four wordsย Avatar: The Last Airbenderย layed out the basics of its entire magic-but-not-really-magic system. Despite the name, bending is actually pretty straightforward. All you gotta know is that there are people called benders and they can control a specific element in all its forms, getting better at it with practice and a right mindset. No mana, no incantations, no last-minute friendship-fueled power-ups.
What makesย ATLA'sย approach to worldbuilding so refreshing to me is that instead of piling on more and more increasingly convoluted rules as the series goes on, it takes what's already there and gradually builds on it. The very first thing we learn is that waterbenders can bend water โ doesn't get simpler than that. The next episode shows that ice counts for it as well, which is only a small step away from the original premise, but each time they dare to step just a little bit further. If you can bend ice, then you can also bend snow. If you can bend snow, you can also bend vapor. If any water goes, then what about perfume? Mud? Sweat? What about water thatโs inside of plants? What about water thatโs inside ofย you?
Itโs less like the cast is discovering new abilities and more like theyโre pushing the limits of an ability weโve known they have since literally the first twelve seconds of the show. This encourages the audience to think creatively, and rewards them for it with epic pay-off moments like Toph's metalbending or Katara's victory over Azula using nothing but water and some out-of-the-box thinking.ย Every maneuver the characters execute is something you could've reasonably thought of well before they did, so you're either impressed with their cleverness or validated in your own.
Well that's true for almost every maneuver.
See, nothing aboutย โcontrol fireโ implies you could become a lightning rod โ that's a whole new thing. So when talking about bending, it makes sense to separate these special techniques from your ordinary physics-defying and see what exactly the show does to integrate them so well.
First impressions are important. That goes both for job interviews and introducing a new power. How many times have you seen the heroes (or even villains, sometimes) get backed into a corner, and only manage to get out of it because someone suddenly pulls an ability outta nowhere?
Not here though! When a character first demonstrates something really out-there, it's never in the middle of a good guys vs bad guys fight. Instead, there's a scene specifically meant to establish that this is a thing they can do, so that by the time a high-stakes battle does come around, you know exactly what each character is capable of and can follow along no problem.
But you might still wonder how they are capable of it, and how exactly does it fit in with the foundation that the show carefully laid down. In order to actually integrate the new element rather than carelessly throw it on top of everything else, it must be rooted in something familiar. Grounded, you might say.
Toph: โEven though I was blind, Iโve never had a problem seeing. I see with earthbending. Itโsโฆ kind of like seeing with my feet. I feel the vibrations in the earth, and I can see where everything is. You, that tree, even those ants.โ (The Blind Bandit, 2:6)
Iroh: โThere is energy all around us. The energy is both Yin and Yang. Positive energy and negative energy. Only a select few firebenders can separate these energies. This creates an imbalance. The energy wants to restore balance, and in the moment the positive and negative energies come crashing back together, you provide release and guidance, creating lightning.โ (Bitter Work, 2:9)
And if there is no verbal exposition, you can trust there'll at least be a visual one.
So we know when and we know how, but the real question is: why? What is the reason for this to exist?
The answer here is twofold. Threefold, if you count โit's just coolโ as a valid reason. But that's not enough to justify adding an entirely new mechanic to an otherwise very compact power system, so instead we'll consider some of the axes that make up a story: Plot and Themes. And Characters, but that's closely intertwined with Themes in this case.
What does healing do for the plot? It keeps the characters alive, obviously (unless they're Jet). What does healing do for the themes? It's a stand-in for traditionally feminine activities that enhaces the show's gender commentary. โGo back to the healing huts where you belongโ = โgo back to the kitchen where you belongโ; โsoftโ skill that is simultaneously invaluable and undervalued because of who performs it; Katara fighting to be more than a healer while not rejecting healing as a concept, so on.
What does lightning-bending do for the plot? It helps Aang to inadvertently fake his death, among other things. What does lightning-bending do for the themes? Much like healing, it symbolizes something else: abuse. The only characters using it on other people are textually abusive, and it becomes their first response to disobedience betrayal. Zuko wants to learn it so he can feel equal with the rest of his family, but the attempt only hurts him and the people around him. Instead Iroh teaches him how to let it pass through you without touching your heart, something Aang had to learn as well so he could face the man whose proud legacy was the genocide of his people.
Now, what does seismic sense do for the plot? Toph. What does it do for the themes? Also Toph.
But for real, seismic sense is an invention born of inability โ no one else would think of it because no one else needs to (except Bumi but his sight is also going judging by the eyes and the fact that he's a hundred-something). It's weakness turned strength and limitation turned opportunity. It is not โeyesight but differentโ and Toph is not โdifferently abledโ. She still can't hang a poster right or write a letter without help. What she can do is see an entire underground structure where other people just see grass. And that's cooler.
โฆnow having said all that, I must admit nobody's perfect. There is an ill-fitting piece in this beautiful mozaic, and his name is Sparky Sparky Boom Man.
Now Sparky here is a rule-breaker in a lot of ways. He certainly breaks the rule of even minor characters being entertaining and memorable, having no real motivations or relationships or even a voice actor to squeeze out some personality where the writers didn't. If he did have lines, they'd be spoken by the equally soulless text-to-speech.
His power feels just as out-of-place. It comes out swinging immediately, with no prior introduction, is never explained or even remarked upon by other characters, and its sole purpose seems to be creating a temporary problem the Gaang can't simply deal with like they deal with everything else. Also it unbalances things by giving Fire two specials while Air still has none.
My point with this? That Book 3 had noticeably weaker writing in some parts, even though it was a good season overall. โCombustion-bendingโ that goes against the show's worldbuilding philosophy is one clear example of that. But it does perhaps serve to highlight how well-thought-out the rest of ATLA's worldbuilding is. Not every piece of fiction has to follow these exact conventions of course, but I do wish media in general placed more emphasis on foreshadowing and narrative meaning than plain flashiness.
pixelskylines
titsay
tangentwithtanner
ellievsbear
blakekathryn
izzy806
gamechangershow
