opinion on tvl ep6 "dialogue controversy"
i've been seeing posts criticising "montreal" using "slave" in the dialogue when claudia finally confronts louis, actually mirroring a scene from s1 when she and he are trapped in a 'house arrest' state following lestat's domestic terror. please y'all, what about exercising some cinematic critical thinking and diving into the possible whys (*since we know that both jacob and delainey were involved in scripting!!*)
slave means that somebody is entirely robbed of their agency, legally owned by others and is forced to work without freedom or fair pay. it is a substantial ingredient of colonisation. the word is drenched in discrimination, racism and oppression the black community had to endure. that's why it's important to lean a little back into the era in question and look at the reasons why could the use be relevant in claudia's context.
going back to s1, many people miss out on the fact that human louis was a bloody dirty-handed opportunist, willing and forced to micro-conform white standards, which kept him, as a Black person, utterly discriminated and hopelessly trapped, but it also served a further personal step towards satisfying his sense of ambition and status. both aspects are a survival strategy for him and his family, the price to upkeep their lifestyle. that is the meaning of moral ambiguity, of morally grey characters. he's severely traumatized, like all his contemporaries, but eventually commits to bury his hurt to gain an entrance into the slum's underworld which is controlled by, once again, white criminals. we see later that once he's turned, he's absolutely ruthless toward any whites discriminating him or questioning his competence or worth (go lou get 'em!). he's instantly refusing to conform any more. but beware, this doesn't mean, he'll be oblivious to the discriminational trauma he experienced as a human, as white vampires are not cured of racism the minute they get turned. the human power dynamic is still very much there, hence the absolutely brilliant subtext of the abuse louis and claudia endured in s1.
as a human, louis wasn't a just man, he was, once again, a figure of new orleans underworld. to elevate and preserve his status within that hierarchy, he had an iron hold on his quarter, pimping black women and exploiting black men and black families in his gambling facilities. various historical researches focus on how white america forced the black population to basically conserve their own systemic oppression by making them dependent on an economic framework designed to serve colonial/oppressor interest. this is a base principle of colonial rule: to lure or force ambitious collaborators under its influence by promising money, position or the illusion of a 'different treatment'. this is exactly what happened in louis's case. it's not louis's fault, nor the fault of many other black men. the system was created such so only those could flourish with greater chance of success who collaborated with the oppressors. it is a widely-applied tactic to divide the oppressed, as recognized by postcolonial studies.
louis viewed himself as an 'independent businessman', not a collaborator, consciously and unconsciously trying to construst a sense of agency for himself, when, in fact, he had none.
when claudia uses the word "slave", she's speaking from the perspective of someone who had been exploited by louis's business the same way louis was exploited by white businesses. the lynching leading to her turning was inflicted by whites in order to punish louis's defiance. louis had psychical immunity due to his vampiric nature by then, but claudia and her family did not.
that's how her misery started.
from a historical perspective, claudia calling louis's a slave refers to the phenomenon described above. in claudia's eyes, louis was, in fact, a slave to white people as long as she saw him conforming them, may they be humans or vampires. in tvl's ep6 we see claudia completely demolishing the idyllic father-daughter picture we were presented with before. claudia knows what will hurt louis the most and explicitly reminding him of his 'collaborator era', however forced was that, is a card she's not gonna let go to waste.
it is a reminder of her beginning, of how she came to be, how she caught up with a death that, in truth, just had been postponed by four decades. she plainly and simply forces louis to face his own role in her misery and to acknowledge the immense responsibility he had in her tragedy, an aspect he had tried to redirect to all others during the past interview.
Let me know your thoughts.