I am going to quickly start this off by stating that I have spent the last four years relearning Ancient, World, and American History in order to teach it to the best of my abilities. I have read numerous textbooks, reference books, websites, and articles, and have watched hours of documentaries to be as knowledgeable as I can on the subjects I teach. I am not an expert. However, from having to teach World History- more specifically Islamic, Arabic, and Indian History-Â I see no issue with Naomi Scott playing the role of Princess Jasmine in the upcoming live action film. In fact, I feel that this is a huge step forward for Disney in comparison to how they cast the voices in the 1992 film.Â
Traditionally, the tale of Aladdin is credited to â1001 Nightsâ or âArabian Nightsâ a collection of stories, fables, fairy tales, romances, and legends that were mainly complied during the Abbasid Caliphate between the 8th and 13th Century A.D. However, most historians believe that the stories and tales were collected over centuries and originated from a variety of cultures including, but not limited to, ancient and medieval Arabic, Persian, Mesopotamian, Indian, Jewish, and Egyptian folklore and literature. Although many of the tales have Arabic ideas and influence, the original frame story is believed to be Indian. â1001 Nightsâ has had a multitude of stories added and changed throughout the years by a multitude of authors and cultures. It is not exclusively of Arabian or Muslim heritage. Many cultural ideas and stories from throughout the Asian and African continent were added.
I think many forget how wide spread the Islamic culture was once it began in the 7th century. Islamic empires controlled Spain, Africa, the Middle East, Turkey, Greece, China, and even India. At one point an Islamic Mongolian dynasty controlled a majority of the Indian Subcontinent for over 300 years. The Mughal Dynasty started an architectural and cultural movement whose influence can still be seen throughout the areas of Pakistan and India. Â That entire swath of the world, from the Middle East to the Indian subcontinent has seen multiple empires and cultures gain control.Â
When it comes to the story of Aladdin itself it wasnât added to â1001 Nightsâ until the 18th century by a Frenchman. In the original tale Aladdin is Chinese, is tricked into the cave by an African sorcerer pretending to be his uncle, and eventually marries the sultanâs daughter. The story itself is multi-ethnic, so we cannot claim that Aladdin is an Arabic only story. Disney took creative license with many aspects for the original animated film, but they drew most of their inspiration from ARABIC and INDIAN architecture and culture. â1001 Nightsâ and the stories it contains can be attributed to many cultures throughout Asia and the Middle East so claiming an actor or actress should not be cast in the role because they are not Arabic is a close-minded claim. Â
Aladdin and â1001 Nightsâ can find influence from both Arabic and Indian cultures and history. Therefore, casting an actress of Indian descent is a valid decision. Please stop hating on the actress for the direction that Disney and the director took. If you truly take issue with this, aim your anger at the executives in charge of the film and not the actors themselves.Â
https://www.britannica.com/topic/The-Thousand-and-One-Nights
https://www.britannica.com/topic/Abbasid-dynasty
https://www.britannica.com/topic/Mughal-dynasty
Architectural Inspiration:
Sultanâs Palace (Aladdin 1992)
For Reference: Aladdin (1992)