I, and the... hmm, six other people I know on tumblr at least, would be extremely happy to see your analysis and commentary on these books!
The fandom is absolutely rabid and will dogpile anyone they see breathing even slightly in the direction of criticizing these books, and if you have anonymous asks turned on, you'll probably get racist anons in your inbox saying that I am actually @rjalker or claiming that *you* are Rjalker, and we're all just a million evil sockpuppets for the crime of *checks notes* "criticizing racist books written by a white woman from texas".
People will legitimately try to claim that it's ""geographic discrimination" to mention that Martha Wells is a white woman from Texas, (When Geographic Discrimination is a very real thing that this situation does not apply to!) when talking about the bigotry baked into *all* of her books, because it really is just that key piece of information that draws all of it together and makes it really "click" about why her writing is the way it is.
Literally just watched an interview from late 2025, where she literally was happy for Gurathin in the show to be played by a very pale man, and give *him* Pin-Lee's job as a lawyer to give him more screen time, because the show not only whitewashes and ciswashes the main character (that Martha Wells spent years telling people was a nonbinary dark-skinned person of color), it also whitewashes Gurathin and prioritizes the two white or white-passing male leads while apparently demonizing all of the other cast who are non-white, and not even making them evil because they're slave owners but just because It's Funny To Make Fun of Queer Brown People, I guess???
But yeah, like, the show apparently takes Pin-Lee, the background cardboard cutout female character who's *only thing* is that she is a Laywer, and gives her job to *Gurathin*, who is whitewashed and made into a male lead.
[ID: a screenshot from the Murderbot tv show, Showing Murderbot and Gurathin, both played by white actors. Murderbot has short blonde hair, while Gurathin has short black hair. End ID]
There's plenty of people on goodreads, youtube, and various book review podcasts that are talking about the flaws in this series, but most people on tumblr are terrified of the racist fandom and don't want to step on their toes, so the more people who start talking about the blatant racism (and more! So much more!) in this series, the better.
One thing to note, is you'll see a *ton* of Murderbot stans who claim they regularly re-read the books....
....but not a single one of them will be able to actually, accurately describe or even remember the basic plot or scenes in any of the books. To the point that I made a series of polls, and less than half of the readers who voted could accurately remember how the "villains" of the first book were defeated, with most either not have any clue, or actively mis-remembering that the characters actually had an active role and used their wits to defeat them, instead of the enemies self-sabotaging themselves because Martha Wells wanted the story to end.
It comes as no surprise to me to hear that most Murderbot fans are not *actually* reading the text with their own two eyes, but they're literally just listening to the audiobook...... as background noise,instead of even actively listening.
Someone actually saw @rjalker talking about racial phrenology in Martha Well's books and compared it to an example quote from Moby Dick which is a prime example of the origin of a lot of modern, more subtle racial phrenology, and a Murderbot stan crawled out of the woodwork to exclaim that of course Martha Wells wasn't being racist, she [Martha Wells] compared this Black man to George Washington 😭
Murderbot stans legitimately know so little of the work they claim to love and re-read all of the time that they will see a quote from the 1800s and full-throatedly defend it thinking that Martha Fucking Wells wrote it as part of the Murderbot Diaries , despite the obscenely clear difference in tone, style, prose, and you know, actual content of the quote that has nothing to do with scifi 💀
So yes. *please* keep reading them and post your thoughts and critiques because they're extremely quick reads and trust me, it *only gets worse* the furher into the series you get, and we need more people to call this shit out on social media outside of private podcasts.
I cannot wait for the 9th and last book to come out, and start getting "complete series retrospective" reviews from people once everyone realizes the entire book series was a streaming crock of scamming shit the whole time that goes nowhere and accomplishes nothing whatsoever, and that the "progressive" politics are actually just extremely regressive once you actually start thinking critically about the messages instead of cheering it on purely for the diverse names the author herself can't even pronounce correctly because she doesn't do any research ever.
Like, the pricing scheme is so bad that *collector's edition complete sets* cost less to buy brand new than it would for someone to buy the individual, standard trade books new.
There were no less than three different "Complete series collector's sets" released for $100+ in 2025/2026 alone, including that that was almost $100 for just *dustjackets to put on the existing standard books*, and at least one that proved the point of the books being a scam, by combining the first 4 books into one single volume of around 600 pages, proving that there was absolutely no reason to split them up into seperate books except to make big bucks by parceling them out as DLC.
They literally charge people $16 to buy the first book as an ebook, and want almost $20 per book purely as ebooks, which leads to people purchasing them thinking they're getting huge, well-written novels only to get a novella with a plot that makes no sense, zero worldbuilding, and nothing happening.
It's even worse with her new Fantasy series, "The Rising World" where she and Tor actively adertized the first book as "an Epic Standalone Fantasy novel" only for it to be 400 pages of absolute slogging shit where nothing happens, we romanticize pedophilia, incest, and eugenics programs, she invents an entire Fantasy Indigenous People just so she can say they're all incestuous pedophiles who traffic children (while framing this as a positive thing???) and then genocide them to give her main character a tragic backstory. It's even worse, because she and tor *exclusively* advertized this shit book as Epic Standalone.... only for it to not standalone, and six months after it was published they announced a sequel... and it's actually a trilogy now, which she and Tor knew all along it was going to be, and she still allowed them to advertize it as a standalone despite her knowing she had signed a contract with them to make it a trilogy.
The book is so bad that literally, the second book a year later still only has 600 reviews on Goodreads (where book 1 has 4k+) and of those 600, 200+ were all ARC copies, which Tor is still handing out a year later in a desperate attempt to make more sales for when the third one comes out and flops hard directly into a dumpster.
And in this fantasy series, not only does she make Fantasy Native Americans who traffic children into their pedophilic eugenics program, she also woobifies literal Fantasy Nazis and has a dark-skinned Black woman fall in love with and marry a White Supremacist Fantasy Nazi woman as instalove in the background, but it's okay, because that Fantasy Nazi didn't take part in the active genocide of the main character's people, just other people, so he doesn't give a fuck about her actions 💀
I can't exactly reccomend anyone read Witch King because it will make your brain melt from the sheer slog of it, but if you want to see just how bad the Murderbot Diaries is, they at least are quick and easy reads that will only melt your brain a *little bit* in rage and frustration!
Oh, and a lot more people are also just.... using the Murderbot Diaries as direct inspiration to write actual science fiction stories that actually critically examine capitalism an its impact on disabled and marginalized people, including people who are dehumanized under these systems in order to exploit them, and while there's no official group, I've made the tags #RobotRevolutionCyborgSolidarity / # Robot Revolution Cyborg Solidarity to collect posts and writing prompts about it, and for old Public Domain stories exploring the topic as civil rights as inspiration as well!