Every single word Ollie says sounds the same—your fault. You fucked up. You’re wrong. It’s your fault. And all Eli wants to do is nod and say he’s right, even if it’s not actually what his husband’s saying. He’s in his head again but this time he isn’t trying to run away—he’s looking for the right thing to say. But there’s nothing. Everything that comes to mind feels like it’s only going to make things worse. But maybe that’s the point. Maybe that’s what they need to make things better again.
“Ollie, that’s not fair. Bringing the accident into this. I told you I fell and that needs to be enough for you, you know that.” He’s always operated on the less Oliver knows, the better rule, that’s the only way Eli can can sleep at night without feeling guilty about putting his family in potential danger. It’s always been like this and Eli’s always made it clear, that this is how he needs to handle these things. “And I told you what I needed. I needed you. Just you. To be there. That’s it. I don’t know what else you expected from me.” Eli still avoids looking at his husband as he talks but then he finally does look up at him and tries not to break down in front of him. Not again.
“And I’m angry. I’m so fucking angry and that’s the problem,” he says; Eli sounds frustrated and his voice rises in volume just a little. He covers his face with his hands and groans, trying to piece his thoughts together. It doesn’t work, everything’s still a mess—what did he expect. “I don’t like me when I’m like this. I don’t like being angry because it reminds me of how I used to be when things were bad for me. And if I hate myself when I’m like this, I—I’m afraid you’d hate me like this, too.”
He turns to look at Ollie and at first, he wants to wave the apology away, say that Ollie shouldn’t be apologizing. Maybe he should just shut up and take it, though. Maybe he needs that. “Listen, I’m—fuck, I’m not keeping shit from you because I don’t think you can’t handle it, I do that because I love you. And that’s how I try to show it, by trying to give you as little reason for worrying about me as possible.” Too bad it backfired. “I can’t just talk to you about how I basically daydream about putting a hit on that motherfucker or how every fucking time I see him on the street, I have to try really fucking hard to make myself walk the other direction. Or how much I’d love to put him in the hospital.”
“That’s not the kind of shit you want to hear. And I don’t even like talking about this. I told you, I hate myself like this.”
As his husband speaks, Oliver just listens. Brows furrowed, heart thumping. There’s newfound guilt pooling through him, a sudden tidal wave of regret for unleashing these untapped feelings that swarm him like a patch of bumblebees. He fucked up. Not Eli, not anyone else. Oliver messed everything up.
He continues to listen, the nervousness making a home inside his stomach increasing by the second. His eyes dart between the wall and Eli’s face, watching as it scrunches into the familiar state of sorrow that he often tried to hide.
When the premise of hating Eli comes in, the words moving out through the air and hitting Oliver’s ears in moments, his mouth opens a tad, about to say something. “What?” He asks breathlessly, his gaze now glued to Eli and only Eli. “I could never hate you. Never. You’re the only person I’ve ever really loved inside and out. More than anyone.” One hand swats the air as if to prove his point further, a look of true desperation cascading across his expression. “Why do you hate yourself when you’re angry? You’re supposed to be angry. You’re human, Eli. Everyday I get scared that you’re gonna pop like a balloon because you keep reverting into yourself. It scares me, especially since I don’t really know what you do everyday. In the club, at work. I’m in the dark.”
One hand reaches up to cup the side of Eli’s face then, Oliver moving himself closer to the other man. There’s more guilt plowing through him at the way he silently likes the idea of Eli wanting to hurt Hallen. Damn, Oliver, you’re really fucked up, is all he can think to himself now. It does still shock him to say hear Eli speak like this. So open, vulgar. Once again, Oliver is a little speechless. Silence comes once again. “I’ve...shit,” He says, “I’ve never heard you..talk like that before..”
After speaking, his hand travels, moving over Eli’s beard and then down his mouth and to his neck. “It’s the truth, though, isn’t it? I want the truth. No matter what it is. But, I — I won’t push it anymore, if that’s what you want..” Just as before, he swallows hard, also attempting to muster his thoughts in a coherent manner.
For a moment, he removes his grip on Eli, turning back towards the front of their room, resting his hands in his own lap. “I could never be with anyone else. Or love anyone else. Ever. I hope you know that,” It’s another confession, one that scares him too. Loving someone so much sometimes seemed so futile. “Even when we broke up all those years ago. I just always thought of you. Always. I’d bring men home and I’d say your name by mistake and they wouldn’t even realize..” Oliver shrugs a little, “And then when Hallen kissed me, after all my stupid pleas for attention, I just wanted you there. I didn’t like tasting him. I wanted you to just — wash it off me somehow.” Now Oliver was crying. It wasn’t a wail or sob, tears just fall down his cheeks without a trace. “That fucking terrifies me sometimes. How much I love you. As I get older, it gets so scary..”