the difference is that Biggles/Erich/Marie would make everything better and Jack/Stephen/Diana would make everything worse :)
trying on a metaphor

❣ Chile in a Photography ❣
One Nice Bug Per Day

JBB: An Artblog!
Sweet Seals For You, Always

★
wallacepolsom

@theartofmadeline
🪼

Origami Around
Cosmic Funnies
styofa doing anything

No title available
No title available
TVSTRANGERTHINGS
AnasAbdin
todays bird

Kiana Khansmith

if i look back, i am lost

祝日 / Permanent Vacation
seen from Hong Kong SAR China
seen from South Africa
seen from Oman
seen from United States
seen from India

seen from United Kingdom
seen from Brazil
seen from Brazil

seen from Australia
seen from Albania
seen from Türkiye
seen from United States
seen from United States
seen from Sweden
seen from United States

seen from Germany
seen from Brazil
seen from Malaysia
seen from Finland

seen from Australia
@onefellsloop
the difference is that Biggles/Erich/Marie would make everything better and Jack/Stephen/Diana would make everything worse :)
American planes fly near the sailing ship "Joseph Conrad" launched in 1880. Photo from 1942. She was then used as a training ship in the United States, and is currently a museum ship at the Mystic Seaport in Connecticut.
Today's xkcd is going to be another hit with the boat crowd. [x]
approaching from upwind at 4 mph vs approaching from the sun at 400 mph
pleased to find that WE Johns got here 80 years before I did
Sarah and Emily Sweetings
approaching from upwind at 4 mph vs approaching from the sun at 400 mph
The surviving editions of the world’s oldest, continuously published English-language daily can now be accessed free
'Let me look to your pistols,' said Jack, as the trees came closer to the road. 'You have no notion of hammering your flints.'
'They are very well,' said Stephen, unwilling to open his holsters (a teratoma in one, a bottled Arabian dormouse in the other). 'Do you apprehend any danger?'
'This is an ugly stretch of road, with all these disbanded soldiers turned loose. They made an attempt upon the mail not far from Aker's Cross. Come, let me have your pistols. I thought as much: what is this?'
'A teratoma,' said Stephen sulkily.
'What is a teratoma?' asked Jack, holding the object in his hand. 'A kind of grenado?'
'It is an inward wen, a tumour we find them, occasionally, in the abdominal cavity. Sometimes they contain long black hair, sometimes a set of teeth: this has both hair and teeth. It belonged to a Mr Elkins of the City, an eminent cheese-monger. I prize it much.'
'By God,' cried Jack, thrusting it back into the holster and wiping his hand vehemently upon the horse, 'I do wish you would leave people's bellies alone. So you have no pistols at all, I collect?'
'If you wish to be so absolute, no, I have not.'
'You will never make old bones, brother,' said Jack.
--Post Captain
-Post Captain
-The Surgeon's Mate
right
-Post Captain
-The Surgeon's Mate
more stories where falling in love is a horrifying fate worse than death rather than a source of comfort and hope. more stories where love is understood as a terminal affliction.
more stories where someone falls in love and understands that this means they will be changed and made more vulnerable by it, compelled to do irrational things in the name of it, and be willing to die for it, and starts lashing out and stress vomiting about it
Diana in her Tipu's Tiger/The death of Munro dress.
his swagless mental breakdowns this, his homoerotic patterns of grief that. what about HER grief-stricken moments of extremely poor decisionmaking? what about HER incredibly alarming isolation and trauma-driven life choices?!?!?!
there's been some really fantastic posts lately in the aubreyad tag about stephen maturin and his political place in the world, how he for all love speaks and thinks as progressively as he does but does nothing to really challenge the way his profession and position benefit him (and british imperialism as a whole). i've been really fascinated by these writings and i wanted to add my own narrative cents to them!
i was reading dean king's aubreyad companion book "a sea of words" (i have the 3rd edition) recently, and a couple of passages about naval medicine really stuck out to me with how stephen's status as a doctor in the 18th century is really a sort of stunning situational metaphor for his place in the narrative as a whole. i think possibly a facet of analysing stephen's character that i had been missing lies nearly perfectly in his experience with 18th century medicine, and tells us much that we need to know about his motivations as a character!!
the quotes which i cite here are all from section 2 of the book, "Stephen Maturin and Naval Medicine in the Age of Sail" by J. Worth Estes, starting on page 31 and continuing thereon. there's a lot, so stick with me!!
I think this is a really interesting post! But it is crucial to remember the two major geopolitical events of Stephen's youth which would have had an enormous impact on his conceptions of what we might call 'ideology' and on outright rebellion.
The first of these is the French Revolution, during which time Stephen was a Jacobin in Paris, in which the noble fight for an ideology turned into the Reign of Terror. The second is the Rebellion of 1798, for which Stephen was in Ireland, and which was marked by particular gruesome punishments, executions, and massacres.
Master and Commander starts in 1800; Stephen has literally just fled from the fall-out, having lost several members of his family and his fiancée. His anxiety in M&C that random officers could have him flogged is not paranoia; as a Catholic civilian he absolutely could be flogged on a slim pretext, or worse (e.g. pitchcapping). During their fall-out in Post Captain, Jack threatens to have him flogged, and is only mostly joking. Basically, I think your post is brilliant, but very focused on the abstract philosophy of Stephen's characterisation, rather than the more immediate and concrete reasons why he is very 'progressive' but seems relatively content to be part of the British system. By the beginning of the series he is traumatised and severely oppressed on multiple axis (he might be educated, but he is illegitimate, homeless, Catholic, Irish, and racially classed as 'non-white' by many). Without his position and profession as a doctor, he would be on the utter margins of society.
i mean of course!! my question is not so much "what makes him this way" but "what makes him okay with being this way, given all he's done and been through", as well as trying to consider a less watsonian and more doylist perspective about POB writing stephen's experiences as a sort of pseudo-racialised man? if that makes sense? for example how in foreign countries stephen acts as this sort of fantasy idealistic everyman who can blend in racially or socially wherever he goes, or is respected on account of his profession. there's a lot of tension, i think, between stephen maturin as a character and stephen maturin as his narrative symbolic function in the aubreyad? how on a simple level he might embody a contrast between himself and every circle he finds himself in (which is how we get all these facets of marginalization you mention) but overall in a grand scheme he fits in as much of the time as he doesn't, or at least enjoys the benefits and privileges of his position, even if he is socially understood as the other (for example the respect he commands aboard jack's ships as their surgeon, even as the crews and officers don't really consider him one of their own, or how he's a successful intelligence agent and not denied career opportunities even though he is all those things you mention). overall my impression is stephen the character is almost more aware of his marginalization than we the readers are meant to be aware of it? and that for the reader he might embody a very comfortable sort of "other", one who does not have to face his othering all that often, even if that is not true for stephen the character. if that makes sense!
all in all what you have to say is very correct!! but my point in these musings was intentionally geared more towards a philosophical understanding of where stephen fits in narratively and symbolically rather than purely in-fiction analysis.
STEPHEN. "uhhh sorry y'all i have to go. important business lots of things to do and important people to see." and it's an aardvark he wants to draw a picture of