Thoughts On: "Staying Behind" and AMC's Pantheon
Spoilers for "Staying Behind" by Ken Liu, one of the short stories that inspired Pantheon, particularly the ending of Season 2. It's not long, you can read it right here. I recommend it!
Also spoilers for the last two episodes of Pantheon.
I just read "Staying Behind", and wow, I wish the last two episodes were more like this. At least a little.
One of the issues I have with the ending of Pantheon is that it loses its audience surrogate. Maddie has always been the down to earth protagonist that the audience can identify with. Despite finding herself in the middle of these historical events that will change the future, watching the show through her perspective makes the story more emotionally grounded.
But in the future, Maddie is the representative of the entire embodied world. She's the opposite of down to earth, and we lose the ability to see everyday struggles in other people through her perspective. Or at least, we never see her associate with normal citizens. She's a tech executive with political power, the exact kind of person everyday people look up at and curse at or idolize.
And Caspian might be the audience surrogate at first, but aside from being in the position to deliver exposition and meet Maddie again, I don't know if he's a good audience surrogate. Caspian goes from this edgy high school kid to the only one who can broker peace between the uploaded and the embodied.
But in Staying Behind, we read about this future from the perspective of everyday people far from Maddie's perspective. In this version, most people have uploaded, and society is breaking down as everyone leaves. Finding medical treatment is getting harder, people have to live off their own generators, school is not a guarantee. And worst of all, the uploaded are really pushing the holdouts to join them, dropping propaganda pamphlets from drones trying to convince them how wonderful it is.
Kind of like the hivemind in Pluribus, honestly. They're SO excited to upload them all that they come up rather cult-like. "We've been you, but you've never been us."
We watch this unnamed guy grow up and see his parents debate on whether their family should upload or not. When he gets older and marries, he watches the next generation try to keep their traditions going. They come together for classes. His kids throw their own prom. But gradually our protagonist sees his family members betray the embodied survivors and submit to the uploaded, like survivors in a zombie movie slowly succumbing to the zombie horde.
The last two episodes of Pantheon are lacking in this everyday family life and how normal people live with these colossal changes in the world. This is part of what made Season 1 and most of Season 2 so great. Of course Season 2 was more of a globetrotting political thriller since Maddie didn't spend much time at home, but that anchor to normal family dynamics still existed in the very familiar teenage relationship between Maddie and Caspian, and Maddie's strained relationship with her new sister, MIST.
In the future, Maddie's falling out with MIST felt very realistic, and so does her feud with her son; but the latter didn't have time to develop. But her romance with Caspian...although the lengths she goes to live the same timeline with him over again are incredibly romantic, the relationship comes off as a bit inaccessible, since Maddie is a middle aged woman and Caspian is the 18 year old UI that she hasn't seen in 20 years.
We did get a bit of that family life in the scenes of Ellen telling Maddie that she was going to upload; but it was only one conversation. And in this scene, we're not watching people far away from action respond to history happening offscreen like the family in Staying Behind. Ellen and Maddie are responding to events that basically happened to them. It's not quite the same.
So to cut to the chase, if the show had one more episode, it would have been great to follow a perspective that wasn't anchored to Maddie and Caspian - maybe Justine, for example, and watch them deal with their family leaving to be uploaded. Maybe this can even take place between the events of Maddie uploading and the later part of Deep Time, farther in the future where most of humanity has uploaded, and the remnants of the embodied are trying to carry on.
It would make a great miniseries...just sayin', AMC. Neflix. Amazon? Whoever wants to do it.