The great wing debate
Background
I recently participated in a lively debate on Facebook about whether the 'flats' or 'drumettes' are better when it comes to chicken wings. Preferences for taste aside, some claims were made about which of the two have more meat. That's at least one part of the debate which could be settled scientifically. So a few weeks later, I got to work.
Objective
I decided there were two things I was looking for when it come to meatiness of wings: overall meatiness, and value.
Meatiness
This is a calculation of how much cooked meat you get per wing. If you're ordering a certain count of wings and want to get the most meat, this number is for you.
Value
This is a calculation of how much cooked meat you get per unit of raw chicken. If you're buying raw chicken wings to cook, and would prefer your money to go towards meat and not bones, this is your number.
Terminology
flats: the wing section with two bones drumettes: the wing section with one larger bone, which looks like a miniature drumstick cooked meat: meat and skin, no bone or cartilage, after cooking - what most rational people would consider the edible pieces of a chicken wing
Procedure
Preparation
I purchased about 3lb of whole chicken wings, cut off the wing tips, and then separated the wings into flats and drumetts by cutting through the joint. The wings were seasoned with salt, pepper, cayenne, and a few other spices. I obtained the total weight of both the flats and drumettes using a kitchen scale.
(click images to enlarge)
Cooking
Wings were cooked on a half sheet pan in a 400 degree oven for 60 minutes. They rested on a silicone non-stick mat for the first half of cooking, and were moved onto a wire rack for the second half. They were flipped twice while cooking on the mat to ensure nice crispy skin.
Disassembly
Wings were allowed to cool for 10 minutes, then I removed the meat from the bone. For flats, this was done by pulling off the cartilage ends, then twisting and sliding out the bones, leaving a mostly-intact boneless chicken wing. For the drumetes, I twisted and pulled the meat from the bone.
Since the wings were well-cooked, the meat from each wing was easily separated from the bone in one big piece. Any small pieces leftover were added to the meat pile. Cartilage was added to the discard pile.
I then weighed the total meat obtained from each wing type.
Results
Conclusion
Meatiness
The drumettes are the clear winner when it comes to meatiness, averaging 37.5g of meat per wing compared to only 26.25g for the flats.
Value
Flats have the best value, with 45g of cooked wing meat per 100g of raw chicken. Both types of wings lost about 39% of their weight during the cooking process. The difference came down to bone and cartilage, which is much more prevalent in the drumettes.
Overall
Both the flats and drumettes tasted absolutely delicious.
Future research
This is only one test... a variety of brands of wings from all over the country can be tested, and prepared in several different ways.
Determining other factors, like ease of eating and tenderness of meat, might be possible with the right experiments.













