Smallâs Sister (Benny Rodriquez x Sister!Reader
I finally finished this one ayyyy đ„čâïž
Summary: Moving to the valley wasnât exactly hard for youâyou already had friends and were settling in just fine. Your little brother, Scotty Smalls? Not so much. But when Benny Rodriguez takes Scotty under his wing, he ends up noticing someone else too: you. Unfortunately for Scotty, he may be the last person on earth to realize why Benny keeps coming over.
Warnings: Implied Making Out, No Y/N Use, Sneaking In Through Window
You and your family had just moved to the valley. You were already making a bunch of friends and living your best life, not so much for your dorky brother though. He had no friends and he told you he made a fool of himself at the thing the guys in town called, âThe Sandlot.â
Scotty thought he was never gonna have a social life until a boy from The Sandlot came and knocked on the door. Scotty opens the door.
Scotty says, âOh, uh hi Benny.â
Benny says, âCome to the Sandlot with us, we need an extra player.â
Scotty sighs, âI can't.â
Benny asks, âWhy not, man?â
âMy glove is busted.â
Benny smirks, âHere man I have an extra one in my pocket, you can use that one.â
Scotty lights up, âThank you!â
Benny nods as they walk away.
You were perched on your windowsill, nose buried in a book, when you noticed Benny walking by with Scotty. God, he was⊠really something, and you tried not to stare. Or so you hoped he wouldnât notice.
Bennyâs eyes briefly flicked toward the window. He thought heâd seen someone watching⊠a girl. He smirked slightly before turning back to Scotty.
Benny thought you were pretty. The two walked up to the convenience store where all Bennyâs friends were.
âHey guys, this is Scotty Smalls,â Benny said as they approached the group. âHeâs gonna play with us today.â
You were sitting alone in your room, when you decided to go hang out with your friends.
âWe should go watch the Sandlot boys!â Your friend, Sarah, exclaims.
You and your friends nod and start getting ready to watch them play. You all finish and go outside and walk down the road towards the Sandlot.
âHey hey hey! What are girls doing here!â Ham exclaims.
You and your friends sit in the grass behind the fence and watch.
Squints waves Ham off, âAs long as they don't mess up the game, who cares?â
Benny nods, âGuys focus lets play the game, alright?â
You and your friends were painting your nails and gossiping.
Kenny says, âWhy are they here if theyâre just gonna paint nails and not pay attention!â
Benny scoffs, âGuys calm down Iâll go talk to them.â
He walks over and leans forward on the fence.
âHey ladies, how about you watch us play, instead of doing your girly stuff?â He has the hottest smirk on his face.
You nod, âYeah sure, weâll watch.â
Benny bites his lip and nods before walking back to his friends.
He does everything in his power to show off for you, such as hitting as hard and far as he can. He smirks at you while running the bases. Your friends giggle and nudge you.
Ella smirks, âSomeone has a lover boy!â
Your face goes bright red, âShut up Ella! I don't!â
Soon the sun starts setting, so everyone heads home. You, Scotty, and Benny are walking to the house. You go inside, but Benny and Scotty stay outside.
Scotty takes the glove off, âHere's your glove back, Benny.â
He shakes his head, âNah man, keep it.â
Scotty smiles, âThank you!â
Benny nods and starts walking, but then he stops. âWaitâhey, Smallsâhow oldâs your sister?â
Smalls says, âUh 13? Why?â
Benny shakes his head with a smirk, âNah man it's nothing just wondering.â
The next day, you and your friends go back to the Sandlot. But this time you actually watch. Benny notices and smirks, getting a confidence boost from you watching so attentively.
After the game, Benny comes to you and says, âHey, youâre Smalls sister right?â
You nod, âYes I am.â
Benny rubs the back of his head, âUh I was wondering if you wanted to maybe hang out with me a bit? We could go to this really good ice cream place.â
You smile, âIâd love to, Benny.â
Benny takes your hand and you start walking to the ice cream shop.
The walk to the ice cream place felt longer than it probably was, mostly because neither of you really knew what to say at first. Your hand stayed in his, warm and steady, like he wasnât even thinking about letting go.
Benny starts the conversation, âSo do you always spy on people through your window or am I special?â
You groan and cover your face for a second, âI was not spying!â
Benny smirks, âCouldâve fooled me.â
You nudge his shoulder, âMaybe I just like reading by my window.â
You shake your head while smiling, âYeah I do like reading.â
He shakes his head and laughs, âif I knew any better I think you wanted to stare at me like a creep.â
You laugh along, and without really thinking about it, your hand slips back into Bennyâs. He squeezes it lightly like itâs the most natural thing in the world.
Everything feels easy for a secondâuntil you look up and see the Sandlot boys standing there.
âOHHOHO! Bennyâs dating Smalls sister!â he yells.
Your eyes widen and you instantly let go of Bennyâs hand. âWe are notâ!â
All the boys immediately start laughing and crowding around. Even Squints is grinning.
Smalls blinks in confusion, looking between everyone. âWait⊠whatâs happening?â
Benny rubs the back of his neck, trying to play it off. âNothing, man. Donât worry about it.â
The boys keep teasing Benny while your face burns red. You quickly stand up and dust yourself off.
âScotty, come on,â you mumble, trying to hide your embarrassment. âLetâs just go home.â
Smalls shrugs and follows after you without questioning it.
Before leaving, you glance back at Benny and give him a small smile. He smiles back instantly, but the second you turn away, it fades a little as he watches you leave with Smalls.
**************************************************
Youâre getting ready for bed when you hear a soft knock on your window. You quickly set your chapstick down and pull the curtain open to see Benny standing outside with a grin on his face.
âBenny? What are you doing here?â you whisper-yell. âMy mom is gonna kill me!â
He laughs quietly. âI just needed to ask you something.â
You cross your arms, trying not to smile. âAt midnight?â
Benny rubs the back of his neck nervously, which honestly looked adorable on him. âYeah, well⊠I wanted to ask if youâd be my girlfriend.â
You stare at him for a second before laughing softly. âYou seriously climbed to my window this late at night for that?â
He shrugs with a grin. âMaybe.â
You shake your head, smiling. âWell⊠of course I will.â
Bennyâs face instantly lights up. âReally?â
âReally.â You say as he pulls you into a kiss.
Later that night, Benny sneaks back out your window.
**************************************************
Two days laterâŠ
Benny knocked on the door, relaxed like he owned the place.
Scotty opened it before anyone else could. âOhâhey Benny!â
Benny grinned. âYo, Smalls. Whatâs up?â
Scotty stepped aside immediately, like this was the best thing that had ever happened. âYou wanna play something? We got cards, orâuhâmy roomâs upstairsââ
Benny nodded like he was listening, but already halfway looking past him. âYeah, yeah, maybe later.â
Scotty lit up. âOkay!â
Benny pointed casually toward the hallway. âIâm just gonna go in your sisterâs room real quick.â
Scotty blinked. âOhâuhâokay.â
And just like that, Benny disappeared down the hall.
Scotty waited. And waited.
At one point he even sat down, like this was normal. âHeâs probably just talking or somethingâŠâ
Eventually, Benny came back out, like nothing happened. âAlright, I gotta head out.â
Scotty stood up fast. âOh! Waitâdo you still wanna play cards?â
Benny shrugged, already at the door. âNext time, man.â
Scotty slowly looked down the hallway. ââŠweird.â
**************************************************
The next day, you take Scotty to The Sandlot.
Ham notices you almost immediately. âHEY! Itâs Bennyâs girlfriend!â
Your face immediately heats up. âShut up, Ham!â
Squints snickers. âMan, Benny is down bad.â
Scotty blinks, looking between everyone. âBennyâs what?â
Ham points at you like itâs obvious. âHis girlfriend, genius.â
Scotty just stares for a second. âBut⊠Bennyâs my friend?â
The boys immediately burst out laughing.
Before anyone can explain, Benny cuts in quickly, cheeks pink. âGuys, can we play baseball now?â
He shoots you an embarrassed look before jogging onto the field.
**************************************************
The game finally starts winding down as the sun begins to set. One by one, the boys start grabbing their stuff.
Benny jogs over, slightly out of breath, baseball cap crooked on his head.
âYou heading home?â he asks.
Benny glances at the boys, then back at you like heâs pretending not to care that everyoneâs right there. He leans down and gives you a quick kiss before stepping back like it was nothing.
âSee you later,â he says with a grin before turning away.
Ham immediately bursts out laughing. âNO WAY. You just figured it out?â
Squints points dramatically. âDude, he literally went to her room every day!â
âAnd held hands,â Ham adds.
âAnd took her to get ice cream,â Yeah-Yeah says.
Scotty looks between all of them, completely stunned. âWait⊠THATâS why?â
Benny groans from across the lot. âGuys, seriously?â
Scotty looked between you and Benny, still trying to process everything.
ââŠso thatâs why he kept going to your room.â
The boys burst out laughing again while your face burned red.
Benny groaned, shoving Ham lightly. âCan you guys leave me alone for five minutes?â
âDoes this mean you werenât coming over to hang out with me?â
Benny rubs the back of his neck awkwardly. âUh⊠not really, man. Sorry.â
âHe went over to makeout with your sister hahaha!â Yeah Yeah yells.
Benny hits his shoulder, âBe quiet, will you?â
You immediately know that tone. âOh no.â
Scotty points accusingly. âYou were letting him in your room?!â
Your face burns bright red. âScotty!â
Ham absolutely loses it. âOH THIS JUST GOT GOOD.â
Scotty looks horrified. âAnd you guys were⊠making out?!â
Benny nearly chokes. âOkay, dudeââ
âEW!â Scotty cuts him off, looking personally offended. âThat is so gross!â
âYou literally watched Squints kiss Wendy Peffercorn,â Ham reminds him.
âTHAT WAS DIFFERENT!â Scotty says immediately. âThat wasnât my sister!â
The boys burst into laughter again. Even Benny starts laughing, despite how red his face is getting.
Scotty shakes his head dramatically, still disgusted. âI canât believe this.â
âAnd I thought we were friends.â
Benny laughs and throws an arm over his shoulder. âWe are friends, Smalls.â
Scotty narrows his eyes. âYouâre still weird.â
You canât help laughing as the three of you start walking home, the boys still yelling jokes from the Sandlot behind you.
Shoutout to my girl: @lovingmymans