Windows 8 Consumer Preview Ramblings
I decided to consolidate my various thoughts and feedback (and quick mockups) for Windows 8 (the consumer preview) in one blog post so apologies for the slightly random tone change between sections!
APP FEEDBACK
Messaging:
Needs to be able to send messages to people who are offline (which is how a lot of people who use Facebook and WLM on their phones appear).
Should open by default in snapped-mode. Who needs a full screen messaging app?
Looks like it's built for use with an Xbox controller, not touch/mouse interaction. Everything needs to be smaller and easier to manage.
Live Tile needs cover art/artist art like on Windows Phone.
Live Tile could also do with simple controls built in too, how cool would that be?
More features to allow management of songs like cover art, song information, playlists etc.
Small snapped view needs more info. I can do more with the Windows Phone music app in a smaller screen!
Right now the entire program is slow and buggy but I assume that'll be worked out anyway.
Smaller controls please! Or at least have them vanish quicker as they cover up the start of videos far too much.
Like the music app, the interface seems more designed for Xbox than a PC or Tablet, make things smaller!
Cooler live tile showing box art or screen shots...
Option for POP and IMAP accounts please!
Support for Hotmail Aliases
Option to show more than one tab at a time
When snapped, switch to mobile site view (with an option to change back)
Colour coding for different calendars
Pinch-to-zoom for different views
Facebook calendar integration
Ability to send Facebook messages directly
Ability to post to my social networks directly from the app, just like in Windows Phone. Ditto for changing user photo
Ability to mention in Tweets
Less space taken up by individual items in 'What's New' feed
Ability to filter different Social Networks in 'What's New' feed
Filter people list to only show Windows Live contacts
Display the entire post from Facebook, don't cut it off!
Allow change in amount of tile rows available.
During the Developer Preview sometimes the display settings would get messed up and I'd end up with four rows of tiles instead of three. I found this much better with mouse/keyboard use and also for touch. I'd like the option to change my start screen to display four rows if I want. Heck, five or six or seven even! Windows can start off with the default amount of rows but it should be my choice if I want more.
Use larger icons for tiles showing desktop programs, settings and folders and maybe tint the tile to match the icon colour..
Allow double tiles for desktop folder tiles perhaps showing dynamic thumbnails of what's in the folder..
Pinned websites look dreadful! Make them more colourful, give them larger icons and larger text or allow creation of a screen capture/custom image to use instead...
So this is my start screen right now. I know things get more colourful and vibrant with all Metro apps but as a pro user I have a load of files and programs pinned too. Right now they look dull and very uninviting. The internet shortcuts are equally dull, surely we can make them more visually interesting?
How about this? I loved the Windows 7 taskbar feature of the highlight being the colour of the program icon. I'd like to see that carried over here and having a tile coloured to match the icon. Already looking more vibrant! It would be better to have larger icons though.
For the folders, I'd like to be able to have double length tiles for them that might give my a peek inside them also? Same for the shortcuts, how about having a thumbnail image (as on Windows Phone 7) and then having an overlay occasionally popping up with the name (also like in WP7) and an IE logo? Surely it's more visually interesting and nicer to view?
More variety in live tile transitions. Where are the flips and other cool transitions from Windows Phone?
Jump lists! There are basic versions in the app bar but hopefully we'll see more jump list options as apps mature
Please stop calling them Metro apps. Immersive apps sounded better. Too much confusion with people taking about 'Metro-style' apps vs Metro apps… #headspin
Allow Metro interface to cover two screens
Metro on both screens please! While I don't know many general consumers with multi-monitor setups it would would be nice to have the option. Also, right now it just looks weird when I'm only using Metro and my second screen just displays my desktop wallpaper...
If we can't have Metro on both screens then at least let us use desktop on one screen and Metro on the other. Right now if I clicked on the desktop in this setup I'd lose the Metro screen. I'd like to be able to work with both simultaniously.
Allow four apps side by side on one screen
Why can't we have four apps snapped? This would be a great second screen setup.
Data driven apps need to scale properly on larger screens. If I'm only using my 24" screen I don't want everything to look twice as large as on my tablet… The Mail app is guilty of this. On my tablet I'm glad the accounts pane is hidden but on a larger screen it's more useful to have it always visible.
If you're not using a touch screen I think at least the bottom app bar should always be present. Gestures are very intuitive with touch but surely it would be easier for mouse users to always have the app bar visible?
Allow more customisation (more colours and patterns, ability to add your own patterns)
A 'one-thumb' keyboard in the style of Windows Phone 7
Allow start screen snapping, it would be useful for opening multiple apps.
Allow correct scaling on multiple screens. I can't get more than three rows of tiles whether I'm using my tablet or my 24" screen...
Have a more minimal Metro-inspired theme that can be used as an Aero alternative to perhaps try and make them look a little better integrated…
When hiding the taskbar, allow a swipe up gesture (as with Metro style app bars) to access it.
Why isn't the Recycle Bin just part of the taskbar? Either pinned like Explorer or as part of the notification area? Having it still be on the desktop seems weird...
IN RESPONSE TO CRITICS AND SELF-PROCLAIMED "POWER USERS"
People do realise the desktop is still there, right? And has been improved since Windows 7 with a whole bunch of useful new features? It is, I'm spending most of my time in the desktop as I'm a professional and I use Photoshop and Office daily.
I find the new right-click menu where the start button used to be far more useful for power user features. I mean, did you guys have one-click access to a menu showing Event Viewer and Computer Manager? I prefer that than the run command.
Seriously, the desktop in Windows 8 is snappier, easier to use. Everything just works better and faster and I find that and the new task manager and multi-monitor options worth the upgrade alone.
As for the start menu in general? In my feedback to Microsoft when the Win7 beta came out I asked them why they didn't just remove the start menu as with the new taskbar and start search it just seemed useless. I've not used the start menu in years, only start search and I'm amazed that anyone calling themselves a 'serious PC user' still uses the start menu, makes no sense to me!
Windows 8 is largely consumer focused, every 'normal' PC user I know (and I know a lot, having taught digital design to university students for six years and becoming tech support for all of them on top of friends and family) still finds the Windows desktop and related apps confusing and scary. They're the only people I know who love the Libraries feature because everything's "just there" and the simple Metro interface will be wonderful for them because it's simple to use. It only has what you need there, not 50 other options that just confuse matters.
Regular PC users (from the ones I know) will love Windows 8, even if they're not using it on a touch-enabled machine. I've been using it with both touch and mouse/keyboard and haven't had any usability issues.
Personally I love the new Metro interface and I'm looking forward to seeing it grow and advance in the future. The new contracts features are an incredibly powerful platform that I hope people take advantage of. The app store will be a wonderfully simple way to get new programs and games without having to run crazy installers and be bugged about installing a special taskbar or free trial of some crapware or other...
The live tiles are wonderful, I've got the weather, people, mail and messaging apps all hooked up to my main accounts and having instant overviews of my updates is a wonderful thing to be greeted with when I log on rather than having to launch up all my programs and websites like I used to.
All these apps are only at preview level and their functionality is quite limited but they're only going to get more powerful. The trick to Metro is that the functionality is there if you need it. If you don't, you never need to know about it.
And if you don't like Metro, the classic desktop is only one click away, and it's better than ever!
For enterprise, I believe Metro will actually be of benefit. Using GPO you can just have a list of approved apps on a locked down start screen that is a heck of a lot more simple to access than a start menu.
And I'm sure by the time RTM comes along there will be plenty of utilities to bring back the start menu and boot direct to the desktop.
I just don't understand how people who call themselves serious PC power users are so upset and angry over one little change when there is absolutely zero functionality or control being taken away from them.
If anything, we have more functionality and control with Windows 8 than we ever did!