“It is within the realms of possibility.” Severus would not be surprised if there had been developments within the next fifty to one hundred years. “After all, think of how much is already possible with magic. It’s only the next logical step. Why, I wouldn’t be surprised if they were already working away on it in the Department of Mysteries.” Although that would be something that only the people within the department would know about, as per the department’s nature. “Torture?” He echoed, his brow furrowing. “That’s not quite the word I would use exactly. Besides, it’s not as if we’d share the knowledge with the muggles.” Distaste was evident in his voice. “I think we’d be just fine. The Wizarding population is quite small, after all.” Severus nodded in agreement. “My grandfather has quite the collection in our library at home, as does the library at Malfoy Manor, from what I can remember.” Severus could only assume that Benjy meant Death Eaters when he mentioned people he didn’t want to have access to those kind of texts. Severus, on the other hand, could only think that it would be far from good for any of Dumbledore’s supporters to get their hands on them - nobody should bring that old coot back to life.
“You expect that would be the case? My, aren’t you the proactive sort.” His eyes rolled. “Just because you gave it up doesn’t mean that you shouldn’t stay abreast of things. Only a moron would give it up completely.” His eyes flicked over Benjy pointedly, his lips pursing. A scoff of a laugh escaped him. “Do I consider myself? I know that I’m one of the best. I’ve been brewing since I was child. I was already at a fourth year standard in potions by the time I started at Hogwarts. How many others can say that? Not many, if at all.” He sneered, his lip curling. “It’s not as if I’d tell you to send them after Slughorn now is it?” An eyebrow raised. “If they need it and have the money then by all means, send them my way. My services aren’t cheap.”
“I can’t say that I agree with your sentiments. I’ve never been much of a wide eyed idealist. Happy endings simply aren’t plausible in the real world. A happy ending for some would be others’ worst nightmares.” And would undoubtedly lead to more problems, of that he was certain. “Well, I for one can’t wait for the day that they get caught and end up in Azkaban. It’s the very least they deserve.” The dementors would certainly have their work cut out for them. “The Ministry needs to step up to the plate and control them.”
“They were too unrealistic for me.” He agreed. “But if you can read it then you can criticise it better. Besides, hasn’t every wizarding child read them? I understand that it’s a given.” He shrugged. “Perhaps I might, perhaps I might not. That is none of your business.”
"A lot is possible with magic, that is true. I have seen it with my own eyes. Bringing someone back from the brink of death when otherwise it shouldn’t be possible. It’s quite impressive, we should be thankful every day that we have that kind of talent,” Benjy said, looking thoughtful, his finger tapping against his bottom lip as he considered Severus’s words. It was a hard thing to wrap his mind around, the idea that one day the might all be able to be brought back to life. He wondered how far they would all go once they figured out that magic. If they would raise the darkest wizards that ever existed, or if they would choose the path of light, and raise all those that they knew could make the world a better place. “I don’t know about that, it all depends on who they decide to bring back once that possibility is within grasp, don’t you think? We have plenty of darkness in our history as wizards. Imagine if someone brought back Salazar Slytherin, Morgana, and a whole host of others? Not that it would necessarily be bad, if they like how things are being done, but if they didn’t?” He shook his head, eyes going wide at the prospect. He didn’t want to know what some of the most powerful wizards and witches of their time might do if given half the chance. If someone like Voldemort was given true immortality. “I’d like to see one of those old libraries some day. It seems like it would be buzzing with information and past lives.”
“What’s the point in staying up on it if I don’t plan to go back to it? You think I want to sit around helplessly, watching people die in my arms and under my care? I can do that enough without being a healer these days, thanks,” Benjy retorted, letting out a sigh. It was frustrating that that was the case, he didn’t want to have to give up the work he loved, but the thought of trying to save someone and failing only brought ghostly images of his mother’s prone form to his mind. “No, I imagine not many can say that, I certainly can’t. But... aren’t the others in your field super old? Doesn’t that mean they have more years on you doing that kind of work and practicing? Just, logically, you would think they would be better because of that.” He shrugged his shoulders, not really knowing much about the craft besides what he needed for his own studies and work. He was decent, but he knew he was nowhere near Severus’s level. “I’ll keep that in mind. Though, why not do some cheaper work? I bet it would be good for you. People can be very grateful when you help them out. Sometimes more-so than those with money.”
“I always thought happy endings were something of a goal, honestly. If you’re not working towards what makes you happy, then what are you doing with your life?” He asked rhetorically, shaking his head to clear it and focus on Sev once more. “How is the Ministry supposed to control a force they have no idea even existed? How are they going to find them? I mean, those pamphlets appears out of nowhere over night! Someone really thought it through to be able to cover that much ground in one evening.”
“I guess so, though it depends on what you mean by every child. Muggleborns most likely haven’t, which is fair, given they don’t even know about our world until they get some letter in the post. Imagine that? Not knowing about this world? Not sure if that would be good or bad at this point,” he murmured, more to himself than to Severus. Glancing across at him, he laughed, raising both brows. “Oh, what, you think I’m going to go around gossiping about you Severus? Trust me, that’s not something I’m really focused on.”