Iâm Jewish and American. I find your posts about our 9/11 in Israel to be offensive. Without the IDF we would not survive. I have family over there searching for cloud cousins. We are oppressed around the world and Israel should be where we are safe.
First of all, my prayers that your family remains safe.
Second, the IDF is a terror force. Iâm sorry but they are. I am actually not going to argue about this because Iâve seen their cruelty first hand. The IDF, right now, is indiscriminately bombing Gaza, passing out guns to violent settlers in the West Bank, and pushing dehumanizing propaganda. Do Palestinians not deserve to be safe in their homes, too?
The use of the âIsraelâs 9/11â language should give you pause. Because 9/11 led to two destructive wars that killed 100s of thousands and displaced millions more and lost the lives of thousands of Americans, all under inflamed and false pretenses. We are not safer for the wars waged in the name of vengeance post 9/11. Do you think Israel genociding millions will make you safer? Has it thus far? Because since before the Nakba, Zionists have used violence to claim land and it has not made Jews safer. What makes you think oppressing millions, keeping them locked in an open-air prison, empowering violent settlers, would make you safe long term in Israel? I am not someone who believes that every Israeli must leave or that every Israeli is a European settler because I actually know the history and the complexity of the issue. But, the current status quo is not working and there are many in Israel and around the world who know this. Those voices should be heeded before more calamity ensues.
Third, Antisemitism is a scourge, I condemn it. I have Jewish family and friends who I want to feel nothing but safe including in Israel. Black people and Jewish people have walked side by side in our pursuit of Justice together in the United States because antisemitism and anti-Black racism only reinforce each other. But that solidarity breaks down in Israel where Africans and African Jews are treated as second class citizens. Even now in the US I have seen the ridiculous actions of certain BLM chapters being used as pretense for why Jews should not support Black liberation. It is important we are honest right now about how white supremacy infects us all and works against our collective liberty.
Synagogues should have extra protection as tensions are heightened. However, so should mosques as Muslims face huge backlash right now around the world.
The Jewish community hold immense power in the United States. Politically, culturally, financially, Jews in the US are extremely well placed. This power, which they have worked to establish over decade, serves to protect the community from extremism and discrimination although we all face danger from the rise of the far right and itâs bigotry and hate.
But as a result we are not dealing with equal stakes. People lose their jobs speaking out for Palestinians. Iâve seen it even in Congress where even asking for aid to help Palestinians makes lawmakers afraid. Right now, college students are being blacklisted from jobs because they supported Palestine or are vaguely connected to a group that does. Itâs not a coincidence that many of these students are Muslim, Black, and brown. Meanwhile, our lawmakers are calling for explicit eradication of Palestinians, and no one pushed back at all. Countries around the West are banning the Palestinian flags and protests in support.
This is not symmetrical in any way shape or form. I made it clear that I condemn Hamas, a terror group that cares nothing for Palestinians and whose leaders live in luxury out of Gaza. But I will not be sorry for focusing my energy on the people currently facing eradication and who have faced mounting violence and discrimination for nearly a century.
Equating support for the freedom of Palestinians and condemnation for the Israeli government and violent settlers with antisemitism is wrong. Itâs a sick game of oppression Olympics used by *some* in a group with power within this context against a group with near zero power.
The Jewish community deserve to be safe. The Palestinian people deserve to be safe. It is imperative we call out the policies, governments, institutions, and ideology that make this impossible.
We either get free together, or not at all.