"What do you think about love?"
"Love?" Eeyore scrunched up his nose at the word. "Why does it matter?" He'd been doing so well lately, especially because of the carnival and all of the festivities, and hadn't been looking forward to this session in the slightest. Talking about things never made them better, only worse.
"Come now," Doctor Hook admonished. "You know these sessions are a lot less painless if you answer my questions without complaining."
Eeyore didn't particularly think that questioning him was the same thing as complaining, but he kept his mouth shut. The doctor continued. "Love's pretty important, you know. What kind of love do you remember from when you were growing up?"
"My grandparents, but you know that," said Eeyore slowly. He talked about his grandparents in every session. Surely Hook didn't want to hear about all that again.Â
He shook his head. "I'm talking specifics here. Can you give me concrete moments, memories?"
Eeyore sat in silence for a moment, trying to gather his thoughts. Concrete memories. Those were the ones that hurt the most - those memories that were tangible, emotions he once felt so strongly and knew he could never feel again now that they were past. "Yeah," he started out cautiously. "Alright. Uh. My birthday, when I was six, or seven? I wanted to have a birthday party, y'know, because everyone else had had one and I didn't really like parties but I didn't want my friends to think I was weird. Parties made nervous and I didn't like to be the center of attention. I didn't even want to plan it, so I let my gran do it. Turns out my grandparents invited everyone over to our house for supper. Everyone was there, but it just felt like a special meal, not a real party. It was perfect." He gave a sad little smile at the memory. "Gran cooked beans and potatoes, and granddad told all of us his stories from when he was a kid, everything he got up to with the other old folks in Hartfield when they weren't so old. And they'd told my friends not to bring presents, 'cause they knew that'd make me uncomfortable. And afterwards, they took us out to the Hundred Acre Wood to look at the stars, like we always did, but it was extra special just because it was my birthday."Â
"That's really good, Eeyore. Sounds like your friends loved you just as much as your grandparents did. Try to remember that, hmmm?" Hook hummed, referring to Eeyore's current conflicted feelings about his Hundred Acre friends. Sometimes, he missed them more than anything, but other times, he was convinced they weren't really his friends at all. He was upset that they'd made him come here, angry that the didn't let him be, heartbroken that they hadn't contacted him since he'd been there... "But maybe that's something to come back to later. Do you have another example? From when you were older, maybe?"
Eeyore closed his eyes and covered his face with his hands. Why were these sessions so long? And with so many questions? "Fine, okay. About two years ago. I was always rubbish at fishing, even though it was my granddad's favorite thing to do. He... he was supposed to go out with one of his old mates who was in town just for the weekend, but I'd not had such a great week. I didn't..." he struggled to explain. "I didn't feel as down as I did after, but not great, y'know? I dunno. I didn't say anything about it to him, but somehow he figured it out. So he invited me to go fishing with him instead. We went out on the river for a whole day, just him and me. He spent, god, hours trying to teach me how to do it properly, and didn't complain for a second. And we talked about the woods, and politics, and music... and I didn't even realize he was just trying to distract me until we'd gotten back, and I felt better."
Eeyore opened his eyes and sat up, unable to conceive how Doctor Hook didn't understand. "He gave up his whole day for me. No one wants to teach a dimwit how to fish," he huffed. "But he did, even though I didn't ask for it or even know I needed it. He was there for me. Just like always." He bit his lip and tried not to think about how granddad wasn't there for him anymore.Â
"What about other kinds of love, Eeyore?"
"Aren't we done talking about this yet?" Eeyore quickly cut in, exasperated. "I don't..." he trailed off. He was unsure how to voice his growing discomfort. Â
Hook chuckled. "I know why you're unhappy with this conversation, or at least, I can guess. Sometimes people who are depressed find it hard to believe that others can love them. I'm simply trying to get a feel for how you're doing in that respect. Do you think someone else could love you?"Â
"I dunno," he said quietly, crossing his arms defensively. He didn't want to talk about this.
The doctor leaned forward. "Sometimes it's not even about whether people can love them but whether they deserve that love." Hook paused for dramatic effect. "Talk to me about that. And then we'll be done for the day, I promise."
Eeyore sighed. The faster he got this over with, the better. "I don't know what you want me to say. I don't have a lot of experience in the romantic love department," he said, rolling his eyes. "I've never been in love, as people say. Even though there's a girl here... well, I fancy her, a bit. We're friends though, and she doesn't see me as more than that." He ran a hand through his hair. "Which is fine, I don't want to ruin everything anyway. But it's not being in love, I don't think, at least not yet, maybe not ever." His feelings were there, he knew, but they'd wither away eventually. He was sure that he'd be fine with them just being friends, though whether he was lying to himself or not, he didn't quite know.Â
"And as for whether or not I deserve love," he continued, disdain for the phrase dripping from his tongue. "Why would I?" As soon as the words left his mouth, Eeyore knew that was the wrong answer. He was supposed to say that of course he deserved love, everyone deserved love, he was even trying to embrace the most important type of love, and that was self-love, which he deserved. But really, that was a load of hogwash, in his opinion.
He kept talking. "I dunno. Whether it's romantic or not, barring the question of who in their right mind would ever love me in the first place, why would I deserve it? I haven't done anything to earn it. I'm not an extraordinarily kind person. I'm not overly helpful. I'm not optimistic in the slightest. I think that last one's the one that really puts the nail in the coffin, you know. No one wants to be around a rain cloud. And even if they did, for some reason, they'd get sick of it. Like my friends back home," he couldn't help but bring up again.
"They probably sent me here because they were sick of me. They didn't want to deal with my shit anymore. Who would? They'd have to put up with my complaining, and my gloominess, and my bad moods. One day they might find my dead body, you know? I think that's what they were most afraid of, why they sent me here. No one wants to put up with that. Not even 'cause they'd miss me. But 'cause they'd think it was their fault, feel guilty, and all that. But no matter how much someone might love me, it's not gonna change the fact that my brain is fucked up." Eeyore didn't usually swear, but no other words would do. "Still I'd do that to people, make them feel bad about themselves that they can't make me want to live properly."
He shook his head. "No, that's not right, people shouldn't even care that much about me. They wouldn't. No one would, I'm not worth it in the slightest. I don't know," he rambled, his words picking up speed as they fell from his lips. "If someone ever fell in love with me - which they wouldn't because of everything I mentioned earlier - I can't imagine they'd stay in love for long. And even if they were, they don't deserve that, to be stuck with me.
And friends might love me, in a friendly sort of way, though I don't know why, and I can't stop that if they do for some odd reason, but that doesn't mean that I believe they're right to. It wouldn't make sense and it wouldn't be fair and it wouldn't even make a difference anyway. I thought my old friends loved me but they sent me away. My grandparents loved me but now they're dead. I love my friends here but I can't help them. I'm useless. If I love people or they love me, it doesn't matter. I'm never gonna stop being miserable, or making other people miserable, and everyone's gonna die in the end, and it just... doesn't matter. Nothing matters, alright?"Â
He stopped, out of breath, and sunk further into the couch. Why on earth had he said all of that out loud? Why couldn't he just keep his mouth shut? Idiot.Â
"Thank you for your honesty, Eeyore," said Hook sincerely, looking at Eeyore with concern. He hadn't expected such a rant from such a typically subdued patient. And he had definitely mentioned some worrying subjects. Hook didn't particularly want to let him go for the day in this state of mind, but he thought that in this case, perhaps, continuing would only make things worse. "I did make a promise... you can go ahead and go. But please think about what I said earlier."Â
Eeyore slipped out of the man's office and headed straight for his room, where he planned on hiding under his blankets for the remainder of the afternoon, his previous words running circles around in his slowly darkening mind.Â