Sorry for ranting in your asks but I need to get this off my chest!
As someone who isn’t involved in the fandom LTD and has been a massive FF7 superfan since OG back when I was a kid, it’s mind boggling to see how badly CA fans warp and misunderstand the story. I honestly have to wonder if they know any of the plot beats outside of their CA bubble. CTs see the big picture, while CAs isolate moments from the overarching narrative without any contextualization. This, for me, isn’t about shipping. I don’t care who Cloud is endgame with as long as it makes sense to the rest of the story. What I do care about is the absolute butchering of story I love to champion a myopic view of the narrative.
The way they downplay every other character as blurs in the background to Cloud & Aerith is frustrating as well. CAs only bring up other characters in context to those two without at all championing their original stories. Do they just mash the buttons through every scene featuring anyone but Cloud or Aerith? It’s mind boggling to witness, especially as someone who cherishes each individual character arc and understands that everything is integral to the narrative. It’s not the Cloud&Aerith show, it’s Final Fantasy 7.
Anyway sorry hope you have a lovely day lol
They don't play the game, so no button mashing to begin with. They watch edited scenes on YouTube and tiktok and then go on twitter to scream at anyone who tries to explain why they're so fucking dumb.
And I would say the erasure of the party is because the party all go on about Cloud and Tifa's bond. Not to mention aerith ignores bonding with the party aside from some surface level convos about herself. She has no meaningful conversation with anyone, and that includes Cloud.
I honestly don't understand why the devs made this whole premise of how cherished she is when she spent 3 weeks playing around and not getting to know anyone. If it isn't about her then she spends her time trying to steal Cloud from Tifa or high fiving while giggling.
She's a character of zero depth.
The more I think about it, the more I question why they couldn't use Ifalna who is an actual cetra. They party could've had a mother figure along with them who ultimately dies and imo that would've had a more solid lasting impact than "she was pink and sparkly and we feel bad she died."
Vincent has attachment to Lucrecia, the mother of Sephiroth.
Cid was attached to Ifalna thanks to some random paper thin story stitching in Rebirth.
Reeve was estranged from his mother Ruvie, but we know he loved her from the handkerchief he showed Denzel in case of Denzel.
Barret has Marlene, who is motherless because of his actions.
Tifa's mother died young.
Cloud lost his mother in the nibelheim incident.
Yuffie's mother is never mentioned, so the assumption is she died in the wutai war.
Red adored his brave mother who died defending the canyon.
See? The connection to mothers was present in OG because they made Jenova the anti-mother, but never considered using an actual mother character in the opposing role. Instead they stuffed a character who acts like a 12 yr old while claiming she's motherly, but never showing that. Not ever. Not in AC, not in OtWtaS, not in OG or 7R.
You can't just say a character is motherly and not show it. Even lil kids know to act like a mummy when they play mummies and daddies ffs. They should've just used Ifalna and left Aerith in the monster bestiary for ffv where they dragged her out from.