Coffees of the Year (or Two)
In the days when the weekly British music press was still in existence, an annual feature of both Melody Maker and NME was the top 100 albums of the year.
Leaving aside debates about how a quantitative ranking system can be applied to an aesthetic item, these pieces made for interesting, albeit inherently frustrating, reads. Witness, for example, the perversity and contrariness of NME, which chose Sugar’s Copper Blue as its 1992 album of the year, instead of Nirvana’s opus magnus, Never Mind. The former is, of course, an excellent album, but few critics today, I think, would argue that it is the greatest work of that year.
Judging and comparing coffees is fraught with difficulties, but, as I have mentioned in this blog before, there are objective measurements that we can use, so it is not directly analogous to the process of ranking pieces of art or musical works.
So, here are my top coffees of 2014/15, chosen for their complexity and balance.
1) Transcend Coffee - El Pilon - Costa Rica
I was extremely fortunate to get hold of a small amount of this espresso, which Ben Put used in the 2015 World Barista Championship to finish third overall.
I’ve nearly always been disappointed with the roast profiles used by North American roasters, but this one, from Canada’s Transcend, was absolutely spot on. There was a lovely interplay of tropical fruits - mango, guava and pineapple - but what stood out most was the finish. Like a great Claret, the taste lingered in the mouth for what seemed like minutes.
2) Notes - Gaitana - Colombia
This was another WBC coffee; in this case the one used by Maxwell Colonna-Dashwood to win the UKBC and reach the final six in the world championship.
Colombian coffees can sometimes have acidity levels that are difficult to control. Thankfully this one was roasted to perfection by Notes’ Candice Madison, who managed to perfectly develop the coffee, making it easy to fully extract a balanced espresso, where the acidity is offset by sweetness and complexity.
3) Coffee Collective - Hacienda La Esmerelda - Panama
This may seem like a rather obvious choice, but my list would be incomplete without its inclusion.
I’m often asked whether Esmerelda justifies its significant expense. The answer is that in purely economic terms it isn’t twice as good as other geishas that are half the price, just as, say, a La Tour Claret from a great year isn’t twice or three times as good as the same wine from a lesser vintage.
 However, Esmerelda still stands as the pinnacle of coffee, with a silky texture that few can match. In fact, this texture is sonething that sets Esmerelda apart, making it almost cru classé Claret-like.
4) Round Hill - Kiriani AB - Kenya
We usually run at least one Round Hill coffee in the shop, and I’m always impressed with them. The Kiriani had all of the elegance of a Kenyan espresso, but with the flavours turned up to 11. Interestingly, all of the ABs and AAs from Kenya that I have tasted this year have been superb.
5) Square Mile - Bifdu Gudina - Ethiopia
I sampled this coffee at the London Coffee Festival, and it was the stand-out filter. I promptly ordered a batch and it became one of our best selling filter coffees. Made with an Aeropress at 60g/litre it showed blackcurrant notes with a finely detailed floral finish.