Remembering a Japanese-American Concentration Camp at Manzanar National Historic Site
Janice L. Dubel in Myth, Memory, and the Making of the American Landscape
"V-J Day, came in 1945, and the federal government closed the camps..."
"Of the ten internment camps used during the war, Manzanar was chosen as the location for a National HIstoric Site because it was the best preserved. The site was designated a California Register Historical Landmark in 1972, and the State Department of Park and Recreation placed a plaque on one of the two remaining senry posts in 1973. By 1975, Manzanar was listed in the National REgister of HIstoric PLaces, and by 1985, it had been designated a National Historic Landmark. Congress commemorated the site "to provide for the protection and interpretation of the historical, cultural, and natural resources associated with the relocation of Japanese-Americans during World War II."
"On March 3, 1992, President George Bush signed into law the establishment of Manzanar National Historical Site and turned control of the site over to the National Park service, although no appropriations were part of the bill. While the site as now officially designated a historic site, the federal government did not own the land."
"In 1996, Ross Hopkins, the sole NPS employee at the site, was assigned the job of converting 550 acres of ruin into a suable national monument. As progress continues and the camp is slowly restored, this site presents an opportunity for people of all ages and ethnicities to understand the fear, racism, discrimination, and hatred that led to the establishment of ten American concentration camps. Unfortunately, work at the site has not been as successful as originally planned. Although established in 1992, as of July 1997, one tour guide worked the site. The guide, Richard Stewart, and the tours he conducts were financed by grants from the Eastern California Museum."
"The U.S. Army Corps of Engineers used bulldozers to level the Manzanar complex in 1946. When they were finished, all that remained of the camp were two of the eight sentry posts and the wood-frame auditorium. One journalist wrote that "the camp was dismantled and the remains sank back into the sagebrush. We had won the war, after all, and history is written by the winners. In this case, we decided to let Manzanar fade from memory, as if it didn't really happen"
"Past the gatehouses about half a mile into the camp stands a white obelisk twelve feet high. A dozen graves are outlined in the sand, marked with small stones and surrounded with a barbed-wire fence. "The black Japanese script cut into the white face of the obelisk reads simply, 'A Memorial to the Dead'" (Houston and Houston 1973:136) A large green building that once served as a high school auditorium stands off to the right.
Still visible are the concrete foundations and supports for the buildings that once served as barracks, washrooms, and mess halls, along with the stone paths that led to them. Hundreds of names and dates are carved into the concrete. The garbage dump is still there with its mixture of broken china and the remains of children's toys. Also discernible is the ruin of the once magnificent reflecting pool."
"Improvements to the park continue. Manzanar has been awarded a millennium grant so that the barbed-wire fence that originally surrounded the camp can be reestablished. Additional plans are in the works for reconstructing the auditorium, restoring a gaurd tower, and establishing temporary visitor contact stations."(96)
"In February of 1996, teh NPS released its General Management Plan for the historical interpretation of Manzanar. Although the plan includes the rebuilding of a guard tower and reinstallation of at least one of hte original camp barracks, some think that the inclusion of other historical markers is deliberately intended to soften the impact of the story of the camp. In the years following the publiciation of the plan, the agency "has received anonymous threats that buildings erected or restored at Manzanar will be destroyed" Personal threats have also been leveled against people invovled with the Eastern California Museum that has been maintaining an extensive exhibit on Manzanar."