David looks confused, as if he hadn't expected an apology; && when he speaks, apologizing himself, it's quite obvious why he hadn't been. The guilt that Spencer had spent years burying && ignoring surfaces again all at once, twisting his gut so severely it almost makes him nauseous. He had never meant to make David feel like he'd done something wrong, but he supposes he'd never really thought about how David would feel, waking up alone after a night like that. All he'd been thinking about was himself && his mother, how he couldn't risk arrest, couldn't risk anything or anyone keeping him from helping his mom. Intention really didn't matter when you hurt someone, && it's clear that intentionally or otherwise, Spencer had hurt David quite a bit when he'd vanished.
The guilt is thick in his throat && he can't even appreciate the stretch of David's shirt across his body or the strands of hair that separate from the gel that slicks the rest back; it's hard to even look at David, but he forces himself too, lest that be misconstrued. He feels enough guilt, no need to make David feel worse. He should interrupt him, tell him he has nothing to be sorry for, but it's hard to with the lump in his throat, a lump that only grows larger the more David apologizes.
Then their eyes meet, && Spencer fights hard against the urge to look away. There's nothing but sincerity in David's eyes alongside the years of hurt from blaming himself. The nervous fiddling with his own fingers stops so he can instead squeeze his hands together, the pressure keeping him grounded against the tidal wave of regret that threatens to knock him over.
David keeps talking, && as much as Spencer's remorse continues to grow, there's a bit of contrasting warmth that hits him, both from the brush of David's hand against his shoulder, && the words he says. It's good to know that everything Spencer had felt back then, at least, had been mutual. It had been hard to run, truthfully, but back then he would've done anything to keep his mother under the care she needed. Still would, it was just much easier, now.
Then there's more apologies, && an invitation to dinner that Spencer wants so badly to take, but he can't under the guise of David thinking he has anything to make up for. He can't take any more apologies, he can't listen to David continuing to blame himself for something that was entirely Spencer's fault.
❛❛ Stop, stop. Stop apologizing, you haven't — you didn't do anything wrong. ❜❜ He tries to keep his voice steady, but it wavers subtly. He takes in a steadying breath, an attempt to stem the tide. ❛❛ It wasn't you, it was — it was all me. ❜❜ His gaze darts around the room briefly again, the movements of his hands resuming as he starts fiddling with his fingers again. His gaze darts back to David's again && there's a beat, 2, 3 where he holds his breath, && then his explanation rushes out of him. ❛❛ I was gambling with a fake ID back then, David. Had been for 2 years — I was 20, when we met. I needed the money to pay for my mom's medical bills, and if I dropped out of college to make the money a more legal way she never would've forgiven me. I knew — I knew you probably wouldn't arrest me, that you'd probably understand, but I…I wasn't 100% sure, and I couldn't take that risk. So I ran. ❜❜
He shifts to crossing his arms over his chest, hands rubbing over either opposite bicep to soothe. ❛❛ I guess, in a way, you did frighten me, but…but you couldn't have known. So please stop blaming yourself. ❜❜ Please, if he felt anymore guilty it would consume him whole.
❛❛ And for the record, I liked you a lot, too. It was not an easy decision to run away like that. I don't… ❜❜ Here he laughs, light && short but still genuine. ❛❛ I'd never done that before, and I've never done that since, you know?? Gone — Gone home — or, I guess, to a hotel room — with a stranger, I mean. ❜❜ His expression becomes almost wistful. ❛❛ It just felt…different, with you. I don't know, I'd never — I'd never gotten that kind of attention before, especially not from someone that looked like you. But it was more than that — I don't know if I could phrase it any better than you did; it felt like I'd known you longer than that one night. ❜❜
Spencer didn't believe in love at first sight, but there had definitely been something between them all those years ago. Some kind of spark that was a lot stronger than it should have been after mere hours of knowing each other. Something that made it so that even years later, Spencer still felt that pull, that spark, drawing him to David && begging for more.
❛❛ I would like to go to dinner with you. But it doesn't need to be an apology; I'd really rather it wasn't, because you have nothing to apologize for. It could just be…a normal dinner. Picking up where we left off?? ❜❜ The look he gives David is hopeful; he hopes that after everything he'd just revealed, they could still try again.