i figured that maybe four hours on a plane without internet access were given to me for a reason, so i finally decided to write down all my thoughts about emmrich and his lichdom
(iāve been sitting on these thoughts for a year now, since the game came out)
firstly, i just donāt understand why the game even lets you continue romance with emmrich if he becomes a lich
to me, that goes against the entire concept of lichdom
the lich lord in the necropolis explained that refusing to bring manfred back was a necessary step, because liches, as immortal beings, constantly face death and must never make exceptions for anyone ā otherwise they risk abusing their immense power
and i always felt that his words wasnāt just about manfred. it was about attachment in general. because deep emotional bonds are the biggest temptation of all
and what bond could be stronger than love?
especially when we know how emmrich loves rook. theyāre love of his life ā love heās been waiting and dreaming about for years. his confession before the final battle absolutely breaks my heart ā itās so tender, so sincere
so why is his almost parental attachment to manfred considered a problem, but his love for rook isnāt? itās obviously much stronger
it just doesnāt make sense to me
i think even if emmrich gets the chance to go through the ritual, he shouldnāt succeed
we were told that every soul goes through some kind of final test before becoming a lich ā we never learn exactly what it is (thanks, datv, for explaining nothing), but it feels logical to me that it would test oneās detachment and ability to be fair and impartial as a lich
and emmrich, who loves rook so deeply, just wouldnāt pass it. or heād have to give up his relationship with rook before the ritual, just like he had to give up the idea of bringing manfred back. otherwise, the whole point of that sacrifice becomes meaningless
because whatās the guarantee that later, when rook dies, emmrich wouldnāt try to bring them back? and as a lich, he wouldnāt even need permission or help to do it
iām not saying he would. iām saying the possibility exists ā and it feels odd for the lich lords to ignore that
secondly, i canāt shake the feeling that emmrich doesnāt fully understand how much lichdom would actually change him
and i donāt mean becoming a skeleton with glowing eyes. i mean-
well, in my view, immortality is serious business. it slowly distances you from humanity until you stop being a person in the usual sense
the way human emotions and thought processes work is deeply tied to mortality. even ordinary people often change a lot by the end of their lives ā they grow colder, more withdrawn, more tired, both physically and emotionally. and thatās after less than a century
now imagine eternity ā endless loss, endless solitude. everything you care about eventually fades. people die. cities decay. books, music, art ā all the little things that once brought you joy ā become irrelevant or forgotten, because life keeps moving forward while you stay still
thatās an enormous psychological burden
emotional numbness and detachment would eventually become a coping mechanism. itās not even a choice ā itās something that happens naturally
and emmrich⦠he feels everything so deeply. heās soft, kind, sensitive to beauty and tiny earthly joys ā like the smell of flowers. thatās what makes him so beautiful as a character. and i honestly think that to survive eternity, heād have to stop being himself, little by little
and from his banters with lucanis, it feels like he doesnāt really grasp that yet. when lucanis says, āwhy would you want to outlast everything you love? it sounds like a terrible fateā emmrich replies, āthere's always something to discover in this world. a fresh marvel. a new friend. i think I should never grow tired of thatā
but finding something new always means saying goodbye to the old. and that hurts. the euphoria of āi have all the time in the world nowā will fade eventually, because that feeling never lasts long. but the losses will keep piling up, each leaving a scar, until opening your heart to something new becomes harder and harder
itās like how people whoāve been hurt too many times often shut down emotionally
so to me, emmrichās words sound like a clear sign that he doesnāt yet understand the true weight of immortality. heās still seeing it through the lens of his thanatophobia, which clouds his judgment (and honestly, thatās very human and believable for a phobia)
thirdly, thanatophobia itself
honestly? i donāt see emmrichās lichdom as overcoming his fear of death. it feels more like running from it. the fear doesnāt disappear, it just changes shape. heās no longer afraid of his own death, but now he fears losing rook. and that doesnāt feel like growth
especially when liches are surrounded by death and supposed to accept it as a fact of existence
so emmrich ends up in a situation where he thinks heās escaped his greatest fear, but heās just found a new version of it
and thatās... well. sad
of course, life works like that sometimes ā you donāt get what you want, or you get it and realize itās not what you thought it would be. sometimes what you wish for comes with too many strings attached. thatās realistic ā even beautiful, in a tragic way
but itās not what i want for emmrich
for me in the āmortalā ending of his quest, he feels so much more at peace with himself. thereās a sense of harmony, of acceptance
so⦠yeah
no grand conclusions here. thank you for coming to my ted talk
not here to argue or change anyoneās mind, only sharing my thoughts that refused to leave my brain for way too long. purely subjective, obviously. i just finally had some time to write it all down
(thank you, four-hour st. petersburg ā sochi flight, it was good)