RivetingRosie’s Masterlist
*Credit to @foundynnel for the amazing edit above.
**Photo taken by me at the top of a hike at Lake Tahoe. Please do not repost.
𑁦𐂂𑁦 Reblogs very sincerely appreciated 𑁦𐂂𑁦
Treasure to Me (Also on Ao3.) Arthur Morgan x Female Reader | 1899 | ongoing | Rating: Mature
Summary: Reader struggles with severe body image issues and low self-worth and loves Arthur but is convinced he’s too good for her. Arthur does his best to comfort her and set her straight.
Chapter 1 | Chapter 2 | Chapter 3 | Chapter 4 | Chapter 5 | Chapter 6 | Chapter 7 | Chapter 8 | Chapter 9
One-shots / Few-shots
Duet Arthur x Female reader | modern | complete | Rating: Mature
Summary: Arthur takes you out for a much-needed fancy date. Though you both thoroughly enjoy the whole evening, you’re both eager to get home and make love. When you finally arrive home, Arthur invites you to take a steamy shower with him.
Part 1 | Part 2
Rockets’ Red Glare Arthur x Female reader | Rating: Teen | modern | Summary: Arthur and reader invite John, Abigail, and Jack over to their property for a little Fourth of July celebration, complete with at-home fireworks.
I Was Mommy Kissing Santa Claus Arthur x Female reader | modern | complete | Rating: Mature
Summary: On Christmas Eve, Arthur & reader’s toddler son hears laughter in the house, though everyone’s supposed to be asleep. When he crawls to the stairs to take an investigative peek, he spies something very shocking and funny!
Chapter 1 | Chapter 2 | Chapter 3
Anthologies
Morgan & Family (Fluff Dump) Arthur x female reader | ongoing | Overall rating: Gen - Teen
Part 1: "Arthur bathes his infant daughter in the shower and sings to her" (modern)
Part 2: "What a Life" (modern)
Part 3: "Sweet Love" (modern)
Scootin' Boots & Meet-Cutes Arthur x female reader | ongoing | Current overall rating: Gen
Part 1: "Aisle Be Yours"
To Share a Smile (Also on Ao3.) Arthur Morgan x Female Reader | modern | ongoing | Rating: Teen +
Summary: Arthur’s & Reader’s first date in a modern AU, featuring deep insecurities, fears, and misunderstandings on both sides. Reader Is plus-sized and wears glasses.
Chapter 1 | Chapter 2 | Chapter 3
Yeehawgust 2022:
Day 1: Meowdy! | Day 2: Cowboy Casanova | Day 3: Tequila Sunrise | Day 4: Strange Hoofbeats
Yeehawgust 2025:
Day 1: Stars of the Midnight Range | Day 2: Running with the Wolves | Day 3: Horsin' Around | Day 5: Boot Scootin' Boogie
Blindly Running Down Disaster Road (series) The works can be read in their current order, but if you’d like to read strictly by chronological timeline of Arthur’s life, read: 1) Part 1 of “Disaster Road,” 2) “Only Fools Hold Onto Hope,” 3) Part 2 of “Disaster Road,” 4) “Dreams to Daylight”
Disaster Road (1st work in series. Complete. Also on Ao3.) RDR2 | Relationships: Arthur Morgan x Mary Gillis Linton; Arthur Morgan x Eliza; Arthur Morgan & Isaac Morgan | Rating: Teen/Mature
Summary: A glimpse at Arthur’s relationships with the two women in his life (Mary and Eliza), in different seasons.
Author’s note: When I first wrote this work right after my first playthrough in 2018, this was my way of wrestling with the concept of honor as it affected Arthur’s character. I thought about cleaning it way up before posting on tumblr, but I think the journey of my writing since then (hopefully) documents some of my writing growth over the last few years.
Disaster Road Chapterlist
Only Fools Hold onto Hope (2nd work in series. Complete. Also on Ao3.) RDR2 | Relationships: Arthur Morgan x Eliza; Arthur Morgan & Isaac Morgan | Rating: Mature
Summary: Arthur’s experiences with Eliza & Isaac after meeting her and during his visits. Seeks to honor Eliza & Isaac and offer both their perspectives and a peek into Arthur’s reasonings as to why he never settled down with them. Full of family fluff and angst.
Only Fools Hold onto Hope Chapterlist
Dreams to Daylight (3rd work in series. Complete. Also on Ao3.) RDR2 | Relationships: Arthur Morgan x Eliza; Arthur Morgan / Isaac Morgan; Arthur Morgan & Original character | Rating: Mature
Summary: After having lost Eliza & Isaac and avenging their deaths, Arthur struggles to cope and keeps his grief intensely private, refraining from even journaling about them. His intense emotions grapple with him until they leak into his dreams, the only outlet he’s left for them. Memories first, then regrets, then wishes and lovely imaginings for what could’ve been.
Dreams to Daylight Chapterlist
Requests / Headcanons / Random Scenes
Arthur x f!Reader Trick-or-Treat Headcanon (1899)
The Morgan Family Goes Fishing (Arthur, Eliza, Isaac, & Hope)
OTP Tattoos (Arthur x Eliza)
Baking Shenanigans (Arthur, Eliza, Isaac, & Hope)
*As of 4/1/25, I have one work on Ao3 that I have not posted on tumblr.
