i have a hot take about rotbtd elements/atla AU, i believe that:
jack is water, for obvious reasons
rapunzel is FIRE, because her powers come from the sun, the magic flower blooms from a sundrop
now, i feel like it could go either way for hiccup and merida, but let's say
hiccup is air, because it's only fair to give this element to the only other character besides jack that can actually fly
merida is earth, tho there is a fair defense for her being air, i feel like there are enough stone elements in her story to make up for it
thank you for coming to my ted talk
reading this got me thinking of rotbtd as grishas
rapunzel would be a sun summoner, since her powers do come from the sun
hiccup would be a durast, since he's great at building and engineering stuff
jack would be a tidemaker, ice from water obviously
as for merida, i think she can be a squaller (wind helping her archery) or a durast too tbh (i think she could be like jesper wherein they use their durast abilities to aim their weapons better)
















