Key Lime Pie, in honour of Key and Peele
Sup, dawgs! It’s been a while since I baked anything and a while since I made anything relevant to the blog, but…. Shut up. I’ve had a very busy and fulfilling life. That’s a lie. But I have been watching a lot of television and had some social gatherings to attend. And then watch some more television.
Image source: The New York Times
One afternoon of general doing nothing one of my housemates suggested a Key Lime Pie for Key and Peele. And I did have a birthday/housewarming afternoon tea to cater for. So this seemed a perfect option. A Key and Peele Lime Pie, if you will.
Image source: The Washington Post
For those of you unacquainted with this particular program, Key and Peele is a sketch show co-written and performed by Keegan-Michael Key and Jordan Peele. They’ve popped up in other shows: Jordan Peele was in an episode of The Mindy Project, and Keegan-Michael is the divine Donna Meagle’s gentleman friend in season six (and I hope season 7) of Parks and Recreation. They also appeared together in FX’s Fargo and were MADTV cast members.
One of the cool things about the series is that sketches have an individual hashtag and those that get the most social media traffic are uploaded to Comedy Central’s Youtube site, so you can find a lot of their best sketches very easily online. Read about how they do it here. They’re also extremely good at pop culture and so they appeal to fandoms, and to current film, television and politics.
Another cool thing is that their sketches are a combination of parody and satire. Because they are both biracial (both Key and Peele have a white parent and a black parent), they use their comedy to explore race relations and what it means to be African American in the USA right now. Some of their strongest sketches play on stereotypes and cultural faux pas. One of my favourite sketches revolves around a Power Rangers-esque show called Power Falcons, in which the Green Falcon is constantly referred to as Black Falcon because Green Falcon is African American. It’s a simple premise for a joke but it works beautifully.
It’s this ability to turn something simple into pure fried gold that I love about Key and Peele. Sketch shows can be perilous. Often a series will use the same characters repeatedly and the skill lies in making the same joke as funny as the first time. It’s something Key and Peele manages to achieve consistently. They also use recurring characters sparingly – they will either be used in conjunction with a variety of one-off sketches or they won’t be used in consecutive episodes.
Image source: Serial Optimist
Key and Peele are incredibly funny, intelligent and talented dudes and hopefully you will watch them and also stuff your face with a Key (and Peele) Lime Pie. Well, you’ll probably spit it out because you will be laughing so hard. But what remains will be tasty.
Key Lime Pie seems quite an American dessert. I am not American. Or a dessert. But TV has made it look delicious and so I decided to give it a try. But first, what the fuck is it?
I thought it was a kiwi fruit and lime pie. But no, the Key in the title refers to the Key Lime, a lime famous for its location in the Florida Keys (thank you Wikipedia and my friend Alex). I don’t live near the Florida Keys. Or near any Key Limes. This is essentially a lime pie, but hey – film and television is all about suspension of disbelief, so why can’t baking be about it too?
I approached it in my usual manner: meaning I searched Pinterest for Easy Key Lime Pie recipes. I found this one. I also decided to use the crust from this recipe I used for my 30 Rock post. To make it gluten free for my pal Meado, I used gluten free milk arrowroot biscuits.
For this, I used this handy Tupperware contraption called The Extra Chef. It’s great. For some things. Usually I have to break up the biscuits, grind them in this bitch, then transfer into a mortar and pestle and finish the job. But this bitch did it all today – yay! Well, I still had to break up the biscuits, but you know. Small victories and all that. What I recommend is crushing the biscuits and gradually adding the melted butter rather than just dumping it all in. You probably don’t need that recommendation because you’re not an idiot. I may have put too much butter in, anyway. Because SPOILER ALERT I have already tried the pie and the crust was quite hard. That’s what she said. Me. I said that.
It goes in the fridge, FYI. Good times.
Then I whipped the cream.
They say that a murderer makes 25 mistakes but is lucky if they can remember 5. Well, John Grisham said that in a novel. Well, Matt Damon said it in an adaptation of a John Grisham novel I was disappointed by. I did not remember the vital error I made that lead to Meado not being able to try the pie. I’ll reveal it later. For DRAMA.
After that, I made the rest of the filling; lime juice and condensed milk. You’ll notice I used lime juice and a lime because limes. Are. Fucking. Expensive. One cost me $1.66. ONE DOLLAR AND SIXTY-SIX CENTS. What a fucking liberty. So I cheated and used Lime Juice for the filling because it’s cheaper and kept the lime for decoration. I’m not good at decorating. Just a warning.
So I whipped that to what I thought was thick, as the recipe suggested. But as I started folding in the whipped cream something niggled at me but I thought to myself, hey! Who am I to question the authority of the maker of this recipe? I didn’t even know what the hell Key Limes were before I started this adventure.
If you’re better at baking than me, and of course you are, you’ll know what had me a little worried this wouldn’t go very well. What was going to make the filling set? I just assumed that I had to whip the condensed milk and lime longer than I had, perhaps, and there were no comments from other users regarding this issue, so… to quote Grace Helbig... I don’t know. I put it in the fridge and shit.
Oh, and I also added green food colouring because it wasn't green enough for my liking.
After a couple hours, it seemed ok so I made more whipped cream (making the deadly glutinous mistake again), and added it on top. And at the suggestion of the recipe person I grated some dark chocolate on top. Then I sliced the ridiculously expensive lime and added that to this motherfucker.
These look Pinnable as fuck, right?
So when my friend and I (but not Meado) tried it, it was still runny, which we put down to the lack of a setting agent and the weather (it was 33 degrees Celsius, making it officially as hot as a bastard). I did some research (looked at Pinterest again) and found a recipe that was essentially the same, but with the added step of chilling for an hour in the fridge, followed by 2 hours in the freezer. Which I did. Sort of. We put it in the freezer and forgot about it, which is exactly the same thing, is it not?
My housemates now use my name as a verb. To Sallie is to fuck something up not through either being a stupid bitch, stupid clumsy bitch, or a basic bitch (which I totally am. I did a Buzzfeed quiz. The results were… disheartening), but through a small moment of forgetfulness that means I miss an important step during my process. So I guess you could say I Sallied this pie twice – through not freezing the pie, and by making it unsafe for Meado to eat. I double-Sallied. Actually, this blog is testament to me Sallie-ing things. Rather than being sad about it, I actually quite enjoy my name being used as a verb. To paraphrase Max Blum, using my name as a verb brings me one step closer to being a cultural icon, which is one of my dreams. The other is to be Mindy Kaling. Or to have my cat love me.
So enjoy this pie. Don’t Sallie it like I did. Use your own name as a verb and let it mean, ‘to do something fucking cool as shit.’ Then watch Key and Peele. It’s fucking cool as shit.
I also got this ahmahzing birthday gift from my pals!
And this little guy to warm my house with!
Oh, wait – DRAMA. So when Meado arrived I informed her the pie was gluten free. Well, I was pretty sure, but I checked with her just in case. Whipped cream = safe. Dark chocolate = safe. Lime juice and condensed milk = safe. Biscuits and butter = safe. Oh, but wait, I used icing sugar in the whipped cream because I’m lazy and it doesn’t take as long if you do that…. Safe? Well, it really depends on the brand. What brand did I use? NOT A GLUTEN FREE ONE.
At first I thought it was only the whipped cream on top. So I scraped that off one of the individual ones, made gluten free whipped cream and added that on top. Luckily before she went to eat it, though admittedly it would’ve been pretty cool if I’d remembered just as she went to eat it and I knocked it out of her hands just in time, I remembered it was also in the whipped cream in the filling. Fail. No pie for Meado.
My reputation as a gluten free expert is now shattered. Well, more shattered than when I tried to give her a Malteser bunny for Easter. I also smashed one of those glass ramekins during the making of the pie. A quadruple Sallie. Good god, I’m a human disaster.