Unanswered Pretty Little Liars Questions (S1-S6)
It’s summer and I’m bored so I thought I’d update my list of unanswered questions, since we’ve gotten some answers since I last wrote this list, but mainly because we have a shit tonne of new questions. Enjoy.
Who is Big “A”? Charlotte DiLaurentis AKA CeCe Drake.
What is A’s motive? The Liars seemed happy that Alison was gone/dead. CeCe became addicted to the game and couldn’t stop playing it, even after Alison returned home.
Who attempted to kill Alison? CeCe, thinking Alison was Bethany.
Why did Jessica cover for this person? CeCe was her secret daughter.
Who hit Bethany Young with the shovel? Mona Vanderwaal, thinking that Bethany was Alison.
Why was Bethany Young at the DiLaurentis house that night? She was going to confront Mrs. DiLaurentis about her affair with her father.
Who attacked Mona in her house in 5x12? CeCe Drake (presumably).
Who is the third Red Coat? Sara Harvey.
Who is the Black Widow? Sara Harvey.
What is Melissa’s secret? She buried Bethany Young alive, thinking she was protecting Spencer.
What was Lucas’ true involvement with the ‘A’-Team?
What really happened “that night”? Why did the ‘A’-Team dig up “Alison’s” body?
Who killed Jessica DiLaurentis?
Who killed Ian? He killed himself and Mona staged the note and crime scene.
Why was CeCe wearing the same yellow top that night? According to her she wasn’t. Jason might have seen Bethany or have just imagined the whole thing.
What happened that day at Brookhaven with Alison and ‘A’? Did Alison meet Mona or did nobody show up?
Who gave Alison that bloody lip?
Who is the Beach Hottie? The one Alison had a pregnancy scare with.
Who was the Fragile Patient on the roof with Marion Cavanaugh? Charles DiLaurentis (although he was framed by Bethany).
Did they push her off of the roof on purpose or by accident? Bethany pushed Marion off of the roof and blamed it on Charles to protect Charles’ secret.
Why was Jessica giving Bethany gifts?
Why did Jessica want Bethany to call her Aunt Jessie? Were they related?
Why was Bethany wearing the same outfit as Alison the night she was murdered? Mrs. D always bought CeCe the same clothes she bought for Alison. Bethany stole these clothes and wore them the night she escaped Radley.
How did Alison’s ‘Jenna Thing’ bracelet get on Bethany’s body if she left it with Mona at the Lost Woods Resort? Bethany was wearing another replica.
Who was Melissa speaking to on the phone the night Alison disappeared?
Who did Aria stab with the screwdriver in 3x13? Wilden (presumably)
Who was the shadowy figure hiding in Jason’s house?
Whose bloody bandanges fell out out Jason’s trash?
Where was Alison when she was thought to be dead?
Who was taking pictures for Ezra’s book?
Where are Wren’s loyalties?
Who was he speaking to on the phone regarding taking care of their ends?
And why was he drawing a picture of Red Coat?
Who is the “blonde girl” that Dr. Palmer warned Marion about?
Who was the fourth person who came to meet Jenna, Sydney and Mona in 5x05?
Who started the fire at the DiLaurentis house? Why were they trying to kill Jenna?
Who tried to drown Jenna in 4x09? And why? CeCe, because Jenna knew Alison was still alive.
Were Alison’s visits to Spencer and Aria real?
Why was Alison wanting so much money before she disappeared?
Who pulled Aria, Emily and Mona out of the lodge fire? Sara Harvey.
Who was the blonde in the zoo in 4x20?
Who smashed up Connor’s car?
What did Melissa mean when she said she’d been protecting Spencer “since before it started”? Supposedly she had protected Spencer by burying Bethany’s body before the ‘A’ threats started.
Why did Melissa form an alliance with Jenna and Shana? What was their aim?
What did Alison mean when she said “You know why I chose you” to Aria in 3x16?
Who took the photograph of Alison with Spencer’s shadow in the background the night she disappeared?
Who took the photo of Alison and the Liars in 4x13 that was given to Holbrook? Presumably Ezra.
Who was in the creepy zombie baby costume that attacked Alison in 2x13?
Whose body did Spencer find in the woods in 3x21?
Is Alison’s ghost story about the twins real?
Why did one of them appear to Ashley Marin in 3x13? She was a ghost.
Who blew up the Cavanaugh house in 5x05? CeCe.
Where did Spencer leave the shovel after her encounter with Alison? How did it end up being used to hit Bethany? Somewhere near the gazebo as Mona used it to hit Bethany and left her body there.
What was Jessica and Peter’s ‘agreement’? Peter was threatening to tell Kenneth about their affair and destroy their marriage if Jessica went to the police and told them Spencer and Alison were fighting with the shovel the night she “died”.
Why was Jessica giving CeCe clothes? Didn’t Jessica hate CeCe? CeCe was the secret first child of the DiLaurentis’.
Who was in the car with Alison when she went to Hector’s studio? Why was Alison in such dire need of that money?
Who was in the Gas Mask disguise that attacked Spencer in the greenhouse in 4x13?
What does Alison have on Noel Kahn to make him help her?
What really happened to Sara Harvey if she wasn’t kidnapped by A?
What was on page 5 of Alison’s autopsy report?
Whose blood was on Alison’s anklet? Hers or Bethany’s?
How well did Alison and Wilden know each other?
Was the story Mona told Spencer about her seeing Alison as Vivian in Brookhaven in 2x25 true? Or did she just make it up?
If it was true, who was Alison watching?
Why did CeCe go back to Rosewood after she told somebody she was “sure as hell” not going back there?
And why did was she eavesdropping on Ezra?
AND why was she wearing the black hoodie if she wasn’t ‘A’? Or is she secretly somehow involved? She is ‘A’.
What were CeCe’s reasons for breaking up with Jason that she mentioned in Pretty Dirty Secrets? She thought that she killed Alison and was not allowed to leave Radley because she escaped, so she presumably had to end the relationship.
Who was the girl in the costume that came out of the changing room when Noel and Garrett were arguing in PDS?
Is Melissa good or bad? She seemed to want to push Aria and Garrett off of that train in 3x13.
What was Red Coat’s plan for the Liars in 3x24? Why did she want them all at the lodge? CeCe wanted to trap them at the lodge to lure Alison there, as she knew that if the Liars lives were threatened Alison would come and try to help. She hired Sara to be a decoy Red Coat to distract Mona.
Who set the lodge on fire? Shana.
Who knocked Toby out in the woods in 3x24? Shana, presumably.
Whose finger bones were sewn inside Spencer’s dress in 4x23? Or were they fake? Just some random bones she got from a medical school.
Is there still an ‘A’-Team or is it just one person acting alone? CeCe and Sara have been working together.
What’s up with the two pictures of Alison in her room?
Who was the girl behind the glass with Mona at the end of 5x03?
How is ‘A’ funding themselves? CeCe formed a corporation, the Carissimi Group, and made good investments.
What was going on between Mona and Shana in 4x12 regarding another unknown female “not having a choice”?
Who was Mrs. Grunwald referring to in 4x12 when she said “he”? Ezra? Or Charles?
What happened between Ian and Melissa in Alison’s room after Jenna and Garrett left the night she disappeared?
Who was living under the DiLaurentis porch in 4A?
What did Mona whisper to Lucas after she found the cow brain in her locker in 3x14?
What is on the NAT videos that could bring Alison’s family down?
If CeCe knows who killed Bethany why hasn’t she told Alison as she claims it’s the same person after her? Or was CeCe bluffing? CeCe told the police that Spencer killed Bethany.
Why don’t Eddie Lamb and Wren like each other?
What happened to Eddie Lamb? Why didn’t he turn up to meet Ezra?
Who is the demon in Bethany’s drawings supposed to be? CeCe?
Who was the other yellow dress Ali found for? Charles.
Who was Alison talking to through the personal ads in 5x13? CeCe (presumably).
Who did Wilden tell about Mrs. DiLaurentis’ statement about seeing Spencer and a blonde in the backyard the night she disappeared?
Who was the blonde girl Mrs. Horowitz saw at A’s storage unit? CeCe (presumably).
Whose remains are in the barrel? Some “poor soul” that A stole from a university science lab.
Whose drops of blood were on the floor of the storage unit? Alison’s.
Who sent Alison the note saying “Your friends will see you soon”?
What was going on between Alison and Holbrook?
Who was Mike leaving sweets for on that bridge? Probably Mona as they were meant to meet up at spots during the period she was faking her death.
Why is Mike visiting Alison in jail? To see if she knew anything about Mona faking her death.
Who is the “evil bitch” Bethany is talking about on the tape? CeCe (presumably).
What is the ‘plan’ Bethany is talking about on the tape?
What does the cryptic message the girls found in Mona’s room mean? They are all anagrams for Charles DiLaurentis.
Who left the anagrams in Mona’s room?
Why was Andrew listening in on Veronica and Melissa’s phone call? Apparently trying to find out where the girls were following their abduction.
Why was Melissa calling Veronica? She was just checking up on what was happening with Spencer’s arrest.
Who exactly is Charles DiLaurentis? The secret first child of the DiLaurentis’. He was institutionalised at Radley after a string of events and the fact that he dressed up like a girl. He spent his entire childhood in Radley until Mrs. D faked his death and he was re-institutionalised as Charlotte, shortened to CeCe.
Why did Mona look so dead in A’s trunk if she was in fact alive? CeCe used some type of drug (the same one she used on Jason and Mr. D)
How long had A been planning/building the dollhouse?
Is Charles really dead? No. Mrs D faked his death.
Why did Mrs. D fake Charles’ death? Mrs. D did it so that he could transition into a female.
Who was inside Aunt Carol’s house when Jason turned up there?
Whose blood was Spencer covered in whilst in the Dollhouse? Or was it fake?
Why did Lesli hate Bethany?
Who’s behind the Carissimi Group? CeCe.
Feel free to submit me Qs in my ask and I’ll add them!
