A Slice of Orange
Chp. 5: Nobody
pairing: joel miller x reader
summary: The most dangerous man in town has been staring at you nonstop, but keeps his distance until the night he walks you home...
tags: smut, medium burn, sexy stuff starts in chp.3, age difference, M/F, a lot of goddamn eye contact that turns into porn, porn w plot, zaddy joel, hand/finger kink, praise kink, mild blood in later chps, TLOU pt.II, NO Y/N
notes: Set at the beginning of The Last of Us Part II when Joel and Ellie live in the Jackson, Wyoming community, a few years after TLOU part I. Deviates from canon apart from that. Characterizations based mostly on the first game.
AO3 link:
An Archive of Our Own, a project of the Organization for Transformative Works
You wake up drooling. The sun is coming in sharp and bright, a sword of light piercing your shuttered lids, your face smashed up against something warm and hard yet still soft. And you are definitely drooling. You can feel that early morning sun beckoning you to wake but you don’t move, wanting a few more minutes before you face another day. You think of nothing as you feel the heat on your face and your bed beneath you. Except…since when does your bed have…chest hair? And suddenly the form under you shifts slightly, and last night comes rushing back to you all at once.
You snap your lids open, wincing as soon as the yellow rays hit your naked eyes, and jolt upright, the sudden movement causing the world to spin as you take in Joel. He lays on your bed, underneath you, still deliciously shirtless and sturdy and strong, one arm folded behind his head, the other hand playing with a strand of your hair. And his eyes are on you.
“Mornin’.” he drawls.
He’s here. He’s still here. You slept so hard you woke up not remembering anything, and now your brain is scrambling to put all the pieces back together in real time. You realize that you honestly had expected Joel to have taken off before you awoke or maybe that you dreamt the entire thing altogether. Either way, you’re surprised to see him so comfortably leaning against your pillow, the golden light cascading over his tan skin, making him glow. And, dear Jesus, the tiniest pool of your drool on his chest.
You let out an incomprehensible noise of muddled alarm, sleep dragging heavy on your tongue, and rip the blanket up to wipe at his chest, feeling suddenly breathless.
Joel smirks at you and cocks his head, reaching a hand up to your face as he uses a thumb to wipe your bottom lip. Quickly you grab his hand and wipe it with the blanket as well. You feel whiplashed at the blazing embarrassment so immediately upon waking.
“How’d you sleep?” he asks, lazy, easy. Not seeming fazed by any of it.
You just stare at him, unable to form the tangled thoughts of your half-awake brain into comprehensible sentences.
“You look like you slept well…wonder why…” he muses, going back to lightly pull at a strand of your hair.
Not a single word on earth comes to you as you just stare at Joel like an idiot.
His easiness falters now and he looks slightly concerned.
“Is it ok--?....I can leave if you’d rather--” he begins, and panic rises within you at his misinterpretation of your silence, setting the gears of your brain clunking back to disorderly movement.
“No!” you almost yell, your voice cracking with sleep. You emphasize the sentiment by smacking both hands to his chest, holding him in place, as if you are even remotely physically capable of doing anything of the sort.
His smirk returns, mischievous now at your blatant display of desire. You haven’t been awake long enough to remember to not be too obvious. So, you clear your throat as you readjust yourself.
“I mean…whatever you wanna do…is cool.” you say offhandedly.
To this Joel reaches out and places a warm, rough hand on your thigh, running it up to your stomach and back down again to your hip, squeezing your flesh. Your eyes follow his hand and dear God that is a lot of hickeys. Deep red and violet patches, ranging in size, mark the skin of your inner thighs, your lower stomach, and when you crane your neck down further you see them trailing up your breasts. You don’t remember feeling him make all of those, don’t recall his mouth lingering that long in all those places, entirely too focused on the sheer ecstasy of the moment.
“Woah.” is all you can manage, marveling at the love bites.
Joel lets out a chuckle at this and grabs your arm, swinging you around until you thud to your mattress, your back pressed up against his chest. He draws you into him, running his hands to feel up and down your stomach and breasts, and presses a kiss to your neck.
“It ain’t fair how good you look first thing in the morning.” Joel rumbles against your neck and your breathing hitches as he nibbles at the skin there.
In an instant, surprised at how quickly he flips the switch within you, your focus shifts entirely to animal desire, the feeling blooming low within you. Heat ladles in your stomach at both his praise and continued touch and you can’t help the movement of your hips as you arch backwards into him.
He lets out a mmmm as he squeezes against you tighter and you feel something hard and large press against your ass.
You want to touch him, you want to feel him and see him and know him in that way. You grind backwards, loving the feeling of the long length of him throbbing through his boxers against the soft flesh of your bare ass. He sucks in a breath through his teeth and grips your hip tightly as you continue to roll backwards onto him, your breathing coming ragged at the thought of how close he is to your already drenched entrance. How easily he could dip his waistband and angle the head of his cock to slide right into you. How badly you want him to fuck you right into this mattress. And you are caught between equal desires to reach between your legs and maneuver him inside of you yourself or turning around to yank down his boxers to finally see him. To feel the skin in your palm, maybe even dropping down to slide him into your mouth. The thought makes you salivate. But then Joel slows to a stop and stills your hips with both hands. Before you can question this sudden break he dips his mouth to your ear.
“So…you asked me a lot of questions last night….” his voice rumbles low, and he trails his nose along the side of your throat making you shiver.
“Mhm.” you agree, not sure where he is going with this. You strain in his grip, wanting to return to the close contact, wanting friction, something, but he holds you still before him, seeming to contemplate.
“I feel like it should be my turn. That seems only fair to me.” he says, still drawing feather light circles on your neck and shoulder with his mouth, the scruff on his jaw, but a space remains between his groin and your backside and you whine impatiently. His thumb draws a slow circle on your caught hip.
“What kind of questions?” you ask suspiciously, restless for more touch. You have no idea what he would want to know about you, and there isn’t much you feel inclined to share anyway.
“I don’t really know a lot about you…besides what you sound like when my fingers are inside you…” he whispers at the end, making you blush. You can feel a heat begin to throb between your legs, and you’re getting impatient. You figure he’ll be able to stop most of your physical attempts at breaking free from his grasp, but he seems concentrated on internal deliberations and maybe if you take him by surprise, you’ll be able to spin quickly and throw a leg over him, climbing on top.
“And it sure is a pretty sound…but…I’d like to know more.” he muses.
You lean your head back against him and his grip loosens ever so slightly as he presses a soft kiss behind your ear.
You take the chance you get and push on the mattress to spin to face him. He isn’t expecting it and you make it almost all the way, your leg coming up to just barely reach over his lap before his hands move like lightning. They grab both your wrists and pin them together between both your chests as his right leg shifts free from you and locks down over both of your thighs, trapping you completely, with the annoying gap still between your lower halves.
“Nice try.”
“Can you please just say whatever it is you’re trying to say?” you groan, frustrated.
Joel chuckles at the genuine irritation in your voice.
“Why? You want something from me?” he says, his voice teasing.
You glare at him, annoyed to another level.
“How about we make another kind of deal? You talk, I touch.” he says, fastening both of your wrists in one hand and moving the other to brush a thumb across your bottom lip and then up along a cheekbone. And the touch is so gentle, so careful, as if he is trying not to break you, his gaze so wholly reverent, that your core goes molten. It’s all you can do just to nod weakly.
He breaks into a grin, running his hand down to your throat, and you’re surprised at just how far his fingers wrap around your neck. He squeezes for half a second, his eyes glazed and widening, but he shakes his head slightly before he breaks his hold and moves down to your collarbone. Your brain is hot mush at the briefly tight grip, at the break in air, wishing he had kept going and surprising yourself with how much you liked it.
“Where did you come from before this?” Joel asks calmly.
“I-uh-well-I t-t-traveled around a lot, b-but I was in Nevada before t-this.” you stutter as he runs a hand down your breast, squeezing each firmly before sliding down your bare stomach.
“Were you alone?”
“N-n-not r-really, no.” you gasp out as he lands between your legs, his fingers finding your center already drenched. Joel’s eye flash at you, dark and liquid.
“What does ‘not really’ mean?”
“It means s-sort of yes and sort of n-no.” you say breathlessly.
His fingers pause at that, causing you to let out a whine.
“The deal was you talk, princess.”
You squirm under his leveled gaze but keep talking.
“I…was with a group.”
Joel keeps looking at you, his fingers still not moving.
He is SO annoying.
“Just some people! No one that mattered, okay, I was never really a part of them. Most split off.”
His fingers dive into you at that and you gasp, two of them, slowly working in and out of you. You begin moving in tandem to them.
“Most?” he questions.
“One st-stayed with me. But, eventually he left too.” you say, not even really thinking about your answers anymore, just letting the truth come out as you feel yourself clamp onto his thick fingers.
“He?” Joel stops suddenly.
“Hey, I’m talking! The deal was I talk and you—”
“Who was he?”
“Just some guy.” you say gritting your teeth, moving your hips to try and encourage his fingers to begin again.
But your tone must have revealed something because Joel’s eyes flash and he picks his rhythm back up, this time more forcefully and you let out a moan at the increased pace and power.
“Did you ever…?” his question trails off, his eyes furiously scanning your face.
Your brain is muddled chaos at this point, his fingers bringing you close to the edge within you, and you are unsure how much to reveal but your pause makes him stop for just a moment so you spit out the truth.
“A couple times.”
“Did he make you cum?” Joel asks bluntly, his eyes full of fervor. His fingers curl up inside you.
“No.” you manage to choke out. And it’s the truth. The man you were with before was nobody. You never had any feelings for him and he didn’t for you. It was just physical, pure necessity what you did with him. Nothing like this.
“What happened to him?” Joel asks next, his eyes still searching yours.
“He left.” you say, not even really focused on the conversation, you are so close to climax.
“He left?” he asks, stopping.
“Ugh, Joel!” you almost yell.
“Tell me.” he demands, still not moving.
“He just left! He said I was slowing him down so he left, and then I came here.” you say, at your wits end. If he keeps starting and stopping like this you’re going to lose your mind. But something about Joel’s face stops your internal annoyance. He is looking at you with an expression you can’t quite read, and you think one of his eyes twitch.
“Where did he leave you?” he asks, his voice controlled, and to your dismay, removes his fingers from you completely, placing his hand on your inner thigh.
You huff out a breath. He stares back at you, unwavering.
“I traveled for maybe a week alone before I got here so, I dunno, somewhere in Utah?” A beat. “I managed.”
You haven’t thought about your trek here alone in a while, you had a few bad run-ins, and almost got torn apart by some clickers at the end but you scrambled up a tree last minute and waited up there for about two days before they wandered far enough away. You had clambered down, muscles shrieking, exhausted out of your mind, and starving. But you were alive. You found Jackson the next day, thankfully.
Joel’s eyes flit back and forth between yours for a long moment before he speaks.
“I hope he’s dead.” he says matter-of-factly.
And before you can respond or really even process his words he crushes his mouth to yours, fucking you deeply with his fingers once again, and all thoughts go out the window.
You moan into his mouth and press forwards, suddenly feeling his length against your leg. It is straining in his boxers, hard and large, and you suddenly feel desperate with the need to feel it, but Joel still has your wrists grasped in one of his.
You break from his mouth.
“Let me f-feel you too, p-please.” you almost beg.
“No. I want-” he begins to say.
“P-please, Joel.” you do beg now, looking up at him through your lashes.
He lets out a low growl and pulls your hand down into his boxers. You gasp as your palm touches his skin, so smooth and soft. And so hard you would think it would be painful. It’s like velvet and steel, and it twitches in your grip as soon as you lightly squeeze it. He’s big. You expected big, but this is something else, and you wonder how you’ll ever even fit it all inside pf you. Your fingertips barely meet around it as you grip it, his hand still covering yours.
Joel shudders against you and lets out a stuttering breath, his face falling into your neck.
You have no idea what he likes, how he wants to be touched, so you start with gentle pressure but he tightens your hand on him. So you oblige until you are squeezing his cock firmly, and he removes his hand as you begin pumping him up and down. Joel is panting into your neck, letting out noises you never expected from him, tight and breathless. You feel yourself get even wetter from the sounds right in your ear like this. You run your hand down his length and gently squeeze his balls. Joel’s head falls back at this, letting you see the way his eyebrows are knitted together, the way his lips are parted. He meets your gaze and groans, moving his fingers inside you again. You hadn’t even noticed that he had stilled them, so transfixed on the reaction you were eliciting from him, from such a simple touch. You can’t imagine how he would react to your mouth. You pull your fist back up his length and he stutters again, his fingers stopping.
You have never felt more powerful in your life.
You swipe your thumb over the top of his cock, smearing a drop of precum across the head. You want nothing more than to taste it, to shimmy down on the bed and take him in your mouth, licking and sucking on that velvety hot skin, until he is cumming down your throat. You move to do just that, sliding down on the bed and he growls, pinning you with his body as he crushes his mouth back to yours, and begins curling his fingers inside of you, hitting that one blissful spot. You go liquid. He then makes a move to slide down the bed himself and you use your fleeing strength to grip his shoulder.
“Let me.” you both say at the same time, your voices rushed and insistent. And that makes you giggle, and it makes him let out a short, huffed laugh, but soon he is making to move down your body again.
“Wait, please. I really want to.” you say, the idea of him in your mouth all you can think about now.
“I said I would make you cum many times before you did anything to me.” Joel says, hovering above you.
“You made me cum three times last night. That’s a lot!” you insist. “It’s my turn, I want you on my tongue now.” you say softly, causing Joel to pause, his eyes on your face.
“I want to fuck you.” He says bluntly. And the idea of that, of him driving inside you, of you pinned beneath him or you on top is so alluring that you almost change your mind. But you want this. You like how reactive he has been to your touch, and you want to feel all of that control now, as he lays powerless before you. Big strong man brought to his knees because of a girl like you and her open mouth.
“Please, I want to feel how hard you are. Against my hands-” you say, giving his length another squeeze upwards, causing him to shudder, and bring your lips up to his ear. “-and in my mouth. I want to slide you over my tongue. I want to see how far down my throat you can go.” you whisper against him.
And he stays very still above you, not making any moves, so you push him back as you sit upwards in front him. And before he can change his mind you’re using all your might to press him to lay back down on the bed. He slowly relents, as if you were a gentle breeze and not a human being using all her strength to try and shove him back.
“I have to f-finish with fucking you at least. I need to know what you feel like.” Joel says, beginning to prop himself up again so you scramble on top of him, pressing your lips to his until he lets himself lay flat again, his head propped up by pillows.
“Sorry handsome, but I want to swallow every single drop you give me.” you say against his mouth, feeling a rush of power as you straddle him.
Joel’s eyes flash at you but before he has a chance to argue further you shimmy lower and pull his boxers down.
His cock springs free, and it’s even bigger than you thought, maybe 8 inches and thick. It’s framed with dark curls at the base, running up his happy trail and the skin is golden, the tip slightly pink and leaking precum. You can’t help yourself, you flick your tongue over the head to taste him, and he groans at the contact. He tastes fucking delicious. You grin, running your hands up his abdomen and scraping your nails down the muscles there as you drop your head to the base of his hard cock and swipe your hot tongue up his shaft. Your hands meet to grasp his length just as you swirl your tongue over his head. Joel jerks, his fists clenching your sheets.
“Oh, fuck me.” Joel hisses out.
“Do you like that…Joel?” you say his name sweetly as his eyes meet yours and you keep them locked as you lick another wet line up the side of his dick, pressing a soft kiss to the tip this time. Joel just lets out a small moan. You smile, holding his length against your cheek with one hand as you scrape your nails down his thigh.
“I like your cock.” you say playfully.
“I think it likes you too.” Joel says pressing his hands to his face, breathing sharply. And with that you take him back into your wet mouth, slowly seeing how deep you can get him; only a little further than halfway without much effort. So, you slather both hands in your spit and begin jerking him off, your hands slowly twisting in opposite directions as you begin swirling your tongue over his head.
“Fuck…Baby your mouth feels s-so good.” Joel pants out as you take him down as far as he will go, choking a bit. The sound seems to do something to Joel, his abs clenching. You push him farther back in your throat and gag more, making him groan.
“Yeah?” you ask, coming up to take a breath.
“Y-yes. You’re such a good girl.” he says, bringing a hand up to stroke your hair, his voice low and his gaze heavy. You feel like your pupils dilate at the praise and you give him a Cheshire smile.
“Keep talking.” you purr as you lower your mouth to his balls, kissing each one before licking and sucking them too, liking how tight the skin gets in response to your contact.
“You’re such a good girl, such a good little slut taking my cock like that, y-you, ughnn, shit, you look so fucking pretty looking up at me like that, such a pr-pretty girl, I, God—you—oh fuck--"
You are now pumping him in and out of your mouth as if your life depended on it, sucking and jerking him off at the same time, gagging when you push him far back in your throat. You remove your mouth to lay a kiss on the sensitive skin of his thigh and then make eye contact with him as you bite him there, as he had with you last night. He does not retract from the pain, in fact the fire in his eyes only seems to become wilder. You notice how white his knuckles are fisting your sheets, how his muscles are so tense that he feels like stone. He’s holding himself back.
You want him unleashed, you want him to fuck your throat.
You pump him a few more times and then come up for breath, a line of saliva dropping from your bottom lip to the tip of his cock.
“I want you to be rough. Please. I want you to cum down my throat. Use me.”
Joel looks wildly at you.
You answer by lightly smacking his cock against your open mouth and cheek. He groans, pausing for only a moment before doing what you ask, his hands pushing your head down and slowly fucking into your throat. You dig your nails into his thighs, hard, and his hips start to come off the bed as he increases the pace. There we go.
“Fuck, look at me, look at me pretty girl.” Joel all but whispers with one hand on the back of your head and the other wrapping down around your neck as he thrusts into your waiting mouth.
You look up at him and he looks so close to being undone, so on the verge of unravelling, his eyebrows pulled together and his mouth slightly parted, breathing heavy. You moan around him, eyes still locked in his, sending vibrations across his cock.
And then Joel Miller lets out a whimper as he cums hard down your throat. His body is hard as stone, jerking slightly as he moans your name. You stay attached to him, sucking down every single drop he gives you, but when you slowly pull off of him, one last spurt of cum paints your lips. Joel is looking at you, panting, as you bring your hands up and scoop it all in your mouth. You suck your fingers of the taste, reveling in it. It’s warm and slightly salty but also tastes like him. You wish there was more.
Joel watches you do this, transfixed. You smile up at him.
“I think you might kill me.” he says, his voice weak.
You chuckle lightly at this and he reaches forwards, grabbing you and hauling you up until you are laying on his chest. He kisses you and you melt against him. You think this might be your favorite thing. Even though everything is else is really fucking nice, kissing him is different. You feel like jelly against his mouth, the way he holds your face so steadily, how soft his lips are and the scruff of his beard against your jaw. The smell of him, citrus and leather and wood oil. You begin pressing your lower half against him. You know you just made him cum very hard in your mouth but the pounding within you has not decreased. Joel doesn’t hesitate for a moment, pushing your shoulders up until you are perpendicular to him, straddling him. He then holds your hips above his body slightly as he slides down in one smooth movement and you are hovering over his face.
“Joel.” you gasp.
“Sit.” he commands.
You hesitate for a moment but his unwavering gaze has you slowly lowering your body onto him, still holding most of your weight in your legs. Joel licks up between your folds and you moan at the contact, jerking up slightly. Joel grabs your hips tightly.
“I said, sit.” he says sharply. And then pulls you down onto his face until all your body weight rests on him. You feel worried for a split second, until he licks up into you and around your clit, sucking on it passionately, and you can do nothing but grind against his tongue, your hands reaching down to twist in his hair.
“Oh, f-fuck, J-J-Joel.” you stutter out, as he continues sucking on your sensitive skin before laying his tongue flat for you to ride. You move on him slowly at first but are soon grinding onto his face with abandon. You are already so close, so close, and you look down and see Joel beneath you, face buried in you, his salt and pepper hair, his golden skin, and it’s almost too much. And then he flashes his jade and chocolate eyes at you and it is too much. Your orgasm barrels towards you.
“I-I’m gunna c-cu—I’m gunna cum-” you exhale, and Joel just moans, sending vibrations along your clit. You feel the force of it hit you, hard, a cry ripped from your throat as you cum against his tongue, reaching your hand out to brace yourself against the bed as you ride it out above him. Sparks flash in your core, shooting out into your limbs and you feel your legs and arms shake as Joel continues licking you throughout it all. You can barely hold yourself up, trembling above him. You let out a whine as you eventually start to slump over, jerking away with sensitivity.
Joel catches you, pulling you down to lay against his chest once again. You groan weakly and he chuckles.
“I didn’t expect that.” you croak out, your insides like honey as melt against him.
“There’s no way I’d cum in your mouth without having you cum in mine.” he says nipping your shoulder.
You flutter your eyes open to meet his. They are warm, warmer than you’ve seen them while directly looking at you. Your stomach does a flip.
“I guess I should let you ask me questions more often.” you say wryly.
“I guess I should be hit in the head with beer bottles more often.” he smirks.
“Are you mad you didn’t get to fuck me?” you ask, brushing your fingers over the short scar over the bridge of his nose.
“Next time. And that’s a promise.” he says, grabbing your hand in his, kissing each finger.
“You’ll have to catch me first.” you respond coyly.
Joel’s eyes flash at that and he uses a hand to grip your face, smushing your cheeks and making your lips purse together.
“Wherever you go, I’ll find you.”
You smile at him through the hold. He returns it and dips his head, kissing you deeply, softly. Like you are the answer to a question he’s been asking for a long time. And the sun shines on you both, and the birds outside continue their declaring chirps, to the breeze and the trees and the moon somewhere far away. And you kiss, and you kiss, and you kiss.
**********
Well, damn.
Joel left a lot of hickeys on you. Most are covered by your jacket, but you have to keep tightening the collar to cover one that creeps up the side of your neck. You want to be annoyed, but you secretly like the idea of having his mark on you. You feel tied to him in this way. You smile at your reflection one last time before heading out to the stables to help Kali.
Kali has been employing you since you got here, and while you like to spend time with the horses, with her, it doesn’t pay nearly enough. There isn’t enough work to get you very far, and you’ve been considering asking to go on patrol for a while now. You watch the rangers pick up their horses and drop them off with awe. It is as impressive as it is a lucrative job. And that makes sense, those who go out with weapons to clear the surrounding areas of infected are putting their lives at risk. You never thought you’d be willing to go back outside the wall after your harrowing week alone prior to Jackson and your many past run-ins with clickers.
You haven’t considered it in a, though. But you are now. Ever since Joel brought those memories back to the surface, you've been ruminating. You were pretty helpless back then, could only run. But what if you could fight? Perhaps you could be taught how to shoot, how to defend yourself. And you’d be lying if you were to say you didn’t envy those who went out beyond the wall. In the sense that they seemed so self-assured, so strong and capable. They were used to danger and adventure, and they could take care of themselves. You look down at your hands as you open the door before the porch steps. Weak, no callouses. You flex them. You could change that, you think, if you wanted to.
The thought stirs in your head as you step out in the increasingly warmer weather, but before you get far something colorful catches your eye. Resting on the top step, on a folded piece of newspaper, is a bright, round orange. You stare at it.
Is this for you?
You look around and see nothing, no trace of anyone, so you lean to scoop it up in your hands. That’s when you notice the pen marking the upwards facing page. It’s a paper from May 2010, roughly 28 years ago, turned to the funnies with a joke circled once in pen:
What did the citrus fruit say to his friend?
Orange you glad you met me?
**********
You can’t help the giant, stupid smile on your face as you wash your hands in a bowl of cold melted snow. Blood runs off your fingers in tiny rivulets, dyeing the water pink, and you scrub underneath your nails, smiling. A mare had given birth today and you had been right there with Kali to pull the new slippery body out into the world. To watch as mere minutes after coming to life, this thing was standing and ready to run. The joy of it, of that new spirit, combined with the orange you carefully ate on your way here has you practically buzzing. You’ve been replaying the way you and Joel kissed yesterday morning in your head over and over again. You feel like your feet might lift off the ground at any moment.
Don’t be stupid. Don’t get ahead of yourself.
Wiping your hands on a rag, you go to restock the mother and baby’s stall with fresh hay. As you shovel the last lump, Kali pokes her head in.
“I’ll ask John if he can set you up with a trainer next time I see him.” she says.
You had asked earlier if she knew how to get you started on patrol training. A buzzing begins in your chest, exciting and terrifying. You thank her, finish refilling the stall, and pet the new horse once more before heading out.
Watching your boots crunch on loose gravel, you can’t not think of him. You are not sure exactly what you and Joel are, if he feels the same way, and you would be tempted to remain doubtful. But…the orange. You shake your head.
This terrifies you. Because what is given can be taken away. And you are very, very scared of this being taken away. You are scared of how the wide-open hole that had been punched through your chest years ago is slowly filling up with him. There is one thing worse than having nothing at all, and that is having something to miss. You already have plenty of things to miss, you don’t need to add another.
But humans are stupid and fickle and forgetful. And the high is so vicious and trembling, so good after so much emptiness. Your cheeks hurt from grinning as you ignore the possibilities. Maybe you’ll invite him over this week, wanting to continue what you two had started yesterday Wanting him to finally fuck you, and fuck you right. But maybe you should have an activity planned. Maybe he wouldn’t want to only see you in your shabby apartment. Maybe you both could go to the small theater in town? You feel silly but…maybe he would want to go. On a date. With you. You feel entirely stupid at the idea. He would probably never want to do something like that. But…the orange. You bite your thumbnail to hide your smile as you pass a group of passerbys.
Giddy, you round the corner, passing the utility shop, a place for fixing faulty guns or searching for tools, and something inside catches your attention. A familiar tan jacket. You come to a stop as you realize Joel is beyond the open double doors, fiddling with a gun on a wooden work bench. Seeing him feels like a gravitational pull, and you aren’t even thinking as you step towards him, to say hello, and maybe even bring up the movie idea, when you notice that he is talking to someone. The words that trickle out to you stop you dead in your tracks, but it’s not so much what is being said as much as it is the tone of sharp anger.
“You’re allowed to have feelings you know, Joel.” the woman in front of him speaks.
“I’m not having this conversation with you right now, Maria.” he says, spitting the words at her.
You pivot back to have your back pressed up against the outside wall, out of sight but still within ear shot. The bitter anger of his voice cracks through your buoyant mood. Your curiosity flares, bright and wild. You should leave. You should walk away and definitely not be eavesdropping on a private, angry conversation between Joel and his brother’s wife. You should really, really leave. But…you remain in place.
“Ellie will be fine. How much do you even see her these da—”
“I don’t need you to tell me anything about Ellie.” Joel snaps back, and the sound of metal being forcibly smacked on wood is indication enough of his level of irritation. Your brain reels at what they could possibly be discussing to make Joel this pissed off.
“I don’t know why I try. God forbid you find someone to love and just be happy, right?” Maria sighs heavily and your heart thuds in your chest. Are they talking about…no…you don’t let yourself get that far. You can’t even begin to process her word choice in that statement. You really should walk away, now.
“Oh, Jesus. Give me a break, nobody is in love and nobody will be.” Joel retorts, and his next sentence is said quieter, so you can’t make it out except for one word. Your name.
You can’t explain the sensation happening in your chest, like everything has been wrapped up in a tight knot and someone is squeezing on it hard.
“I know these kinds of things make you think about Sarah. I get it. I had the same fears because of Kevin, but—”
Joel’s voice is deadly quiet now as he speaks, each word enunciated carefully, as if they are grenades dropping out of his mouth one by one, and he is trying not to pull any of their triggers.
“Do. Not. Bring. Up. Sarah. Ever again. Do you understand me?”
“Joel--”
“Fucking drop it, Maria! She’s just a lonely kid with no family who nobody cares about. She doesn’t mean anything. She’s nobody. Everybody leaves her and I will too. So, DROP it.”
The vice grip inside your chest tightens and tightens until it feels like something inside of you viciously severs in two. Your lungs you think. You can no longer breathe.
She’s nobody.
Everybody leaves her and I will too.
You aren’t seeing, or hearing, or feeling anything anymore, you’re just stuck. You only have his words, replaying over and over again on a loop.
Nobody. Nobody. Nobody.
Everybody leaves her and I will too.
You should have walked away, you really should have just walked away.
And then you are too late to notice the sounds of footsteps approaching. And suddenly Joel is exiting the store with Maria at his heels, his bag at his shoulder, and they both stop when they notice you standing there, utterly frozen.
Joel’s eyes go wide for a moment at the sight of you. A flurry of emotions pass over his face as he becomes just as still as you. Maria next to him lets out a long sigh, her expression crumpling into crushing pity. And that face of pity, of concerned sadness for you, it shatters your numbness, and the inky, vast pool of repressed grief and shame maws open before you. One more push and you would fall in, heavy as a rock, right to the bottom.
Maria looks expectantly at Joel, as if she is waiting on him to apologize, to explain himself, to do anything. And Joel’s gaze flickers with uncertainty for a moment before hardening.
“What?” he questions gruffly. And it takes you a moment before you realize he is speaking to you.
“Uh-I s-sorry I-I didn’t mean to-I was just-” you stutter through your regret for eavesdropping, but are not sure why you are the one apologizing in this moment. You shouldn’t have been listening to a private conversation, and maybe Joel would never have been so harsh had he known you were listening, but it was still him being cruel just now. Not you. And you wonder if it’s something he simply said to Maria to get her off his back, or if he really feels that way. If you are just some sorry nobody he seeks out for physical gratification. If…if he really only sees you like that. Like the girl that gets abandoned.
I will too.
Is he planning on leaving once he gets what he wants? And what does he want? Just sex? But then why…why any of the rest of it? You haven’t discussed feelings or anything close. Had only had a handful of interactions. But you realize in this moment just how much you are already attached to the idea of having him around. And how he simply might not care. Not even a little bit. Not even at all.
“Today.” he commands, indicating how long it is taking for you to get a sentence out. His tone stings more than anything. You can feel your face crumple in reaction and you hate it, you hate how pathetic you must seem right now, how small and sad you feel. Like nobody.
No.
He doesn’t get to talk to you like that. He isn’t allowed to do this. You are the girl who tears men a new asshole when they deserve it. You aren’t going to roll over this time. If he wants to be a dick, you can step up to the plate too. You feel your devastation be replaced with anger as it so often is, and that fury is a ball of heat inside you, alive and purring to be let out. So, you open the door for it.
“Fuck you.” you breath out to him. Your voice is quieter than you’d like, but the sentiment feels clearly written on your face.
Maria’s eyebrows shoot upwards and Joel’s face twitches. He looks between you both and you see his stony expression falter for just a moment before he inhales once, slowly, and lets it out evenly. He then turns on his heel and makes to head away, beckoning for Maria to follow him.
Your anger growls unsatisfied at the lack of response, the lack of play.
“Alright, I’ll see you at my doorsteps in a couple days then? For whenever you feel like begging to put your face between my legs again.” you call out to him, your heart thudding.
Joel freezes completely on the street for a second before he ever so slowly turns to you. His face is incredulous. And mad.
Shit. Shit shit shit.
You might have pushed the very scary, dangerous man too far on this one. But you couldn’t help it, and it feels good to hit your mark. Maria coughs besides him, hands on her hips, looking anywhere but at either of you. But her mouth is pulled up at the corners. She mutters something about Tommy and begins walking up the street.
You’re glad she’s amused, because Joel is clearly not.
“Excuse me?” Joel all but breathes at you, his eyes wild.
It’s probably time to go now, so you spin and begin power-walking away.
"Hey!" you hear him half-yell behind you.
You don't slow down, instead you speed up, breaking into a flat out run, turning into an alley. You make it maybe ten steps before you hear his footsteps catch up to you. His hand grabs your elbow, yanking you to a stop. Goddamn him and his stupid fucking fast legs.
Joel's face is wild.
"What the hell was that?" he demands.
"Me?!" you can't believe you are the one being prompted to explain yourself in this moment. You twist in his grip but find zero release point.
"You can't just-" he starts, but you've had enough.
"Can't what? Tell the truth? Exist around you outside of my fucking bedroom? It shouldn’t bother you should it? Considering I’m nobody.”
"Oh, sweet Jesus, listen, please-" Joel grumbles, wiping his face with a hand.
"Unhand me, you oaf." you say, using your other fist to bang on his fingers, but still he doesn't let go.
"Oaf?" he snorts once, shock breaking his frustration for a brief moment.
"Argh, let GO!" you yell, and finally he does. However, the way you were pulling away from him at a 45-degree angle causes the lack of his hold to have you fall clean on your ass with a hard thump.
"Oh god. Are you okay, pretty girl?" Joel asks, obviously trying to hide a full on laugh now.
You look up at him and he is smothering a smile, and only then do you realize where you both stand. The barrels and brick, the familiar ramshackle buildings. The same alleyway from your first kiss. And the difference from that moment to this one, him literally standing over you laughing, the pain from the fall, the different kind of pain from hearing him call you your favorite pet name just moments after he called you nobody. All of that mixes with your still lingering, hot shame. You sense tears begin to smart the corners of your eyes. You feel like the dumbest child on earth. How did you ever fantasize that this would end in anything but pain? He was always going to leave. Of course he was going to leave. Joel's face softens at your expression, into regret and guilt, and something else.
"Hey-" he begins, his tone gentle now, leaning towards you to help you up, but you smack his hand away and get up yourself, ungracefully.
“Can you…just…you don’t understand.” Joel says, unable to find his words, running his hand through his hair.
You huff but press your mouth closed and look at him waiting.
But Joel seems unsure how to continue. He falters and look at the ground.
“Did you mean it?” you ask finally, quietly.
He looks up at you and his face is unreadable, tense. He just stares at you. And then looks back to the ground.
You slowly close your eyes.
“Okay.” you breathe.
Somehow this is worse. Having him in front of you, silent, is so much worse.
You make to leave and he reaches out to you one more time.
"Please just leave me alone." you say to him, a cold wall coming up inside of you.
Joel drops his hand, and you turn on your heel towards your apartment. You keep your head forward until you exit the alleyway and don’t look behind you until you make it another block.
He is not following you.
You hate that you wish he was.













