Transgender or not, sheâs a person... just like you!
*** I want to begin by openly acknowledging that I am a cisgender person, who is inherently privileged due to this factor. As such, I do not have full understanding of what it means to be, nor what it is like to live as a transgender individual.***
Like many people, I have been following the transition of Caitlyn Jenner, formerly known as Bruce Jenner. However, unlike most, I have been more fascinated by the response on social media than her actual transition. I find it intriguing that so much attention has been placed on this event, especially when it is the reality of so many ordinary (non-famous) people. I think it is wonderful that Caitlyn is now able to present herself as she always knew she was, as well as that the spotlight is opening a conversation about issues surrounding those who identify as transgender. However, I question if societyâs infatuation with Caitlyn is a sign of our inability to merely allow people to live their lives their way.
Now, I am not saying that curiosity is a bad thing or that people should not endeavor to learn more about those who are different from them. However, I have not seen many people asking Caitlyn, or any transgender people for that matter, about their own experiences, Rather I have noticed people passing judgment on Caitlynâs character. Many of those who wish to demonstrate support have characterized her as brave and inspirational, while those who disagree with her decision to come out as a transgender woman deem her immoral and a liar.This is problematic because they are solely basing their judgments on her gender identity and nothing more. This would be equivalent to saying all women of great people and all men are horrible... which is outright ridiculous. Furthermore, some people have used Caitlynâs transparency of her identity as the butt of cruel jokes. Â
Possibly one of the worst cases of this so far is a ploy to strip Caitlyn of her 1976 Olympic gold medal. As a prank started by a user of the popular trolling site 4chan.org, a petition was created claiming that since Caitlyn competed in the male portion of the Olympics, but states she has always identified as a female, she broke the âsame sex competitors onlyâ rules,and therefore should relinquish her gold medal. To most, this is probably one of the most illogical thought processes ever and we probably just laughed it off. However, as of the last time I checked, the petition had 12,441 signatures and many twitter followers. This goes to show how ignorant many social media users are to the realities of transgender people.Â
So, I would like to help change this. I think we all need to learn how to be curious and respectful at the same time. This means asking questions that we, ourselves, would be comfortable answering. For example, you probably would not want someone to question what your genitalia looks like, so why would you ask someone out about theirs? Additionally, letâs remember everyone is different and, as such, experiences life differently, so Caitlyn cannot be the spokesperson for every transgender individual on the planet. Therefore, before falling into the trap of overgeneralization, avoid stereotyping this group of people based solely on how she presents herself or her experiences. And for those who want to dialogue about Caitlynâs transition, here are some great guidelines from GLAAD on how to do so respectfully.
In short, we are all human and we all want to be treated as such. Keep this in mind the next time you are talking to, or about, anyone who is different from you, and youâll be fine!