In DMC, Jack steals a ring from Tia Dalma’s shack and wears it from then on, making it his fourth ring. In actuality, this ring was once Angelica’s - Jack gave it to her during their previous relationship. Angelica then traded it to Tia Dalma for the secret of the Fountain of Youth’s ritual. This is why Jack steals it back after spotting it in Tia’s shack. In On Stranger Tides, after the Tango scene, Angelica is once again wearing this ring, meaning Jack gave it back to her. Funny that Jack stole this ring when Tia was trying to explain what “vexes all men” - and Jack answers with “a woman” - right after he re-gained Angelica’s ring!
Still don’t believe me? Check this out, from the OST Visual Guide Book:
E questo non prova il suo amore per Angelica?
Dopo avere rubato l'anello, avrebbe potuto regalarlo a un'altra donna o tenerlo semplicemente per sé, ma decide di ridarlo ad Angelica.
Fosse anche solo per ricordare il loro passato, senza che lui provi ancora qualcosa. Ma non mi sembra il caso. Angelica è stata importante e se la pensa ancora vuol dire che questo non è cambiato. Prova ancora un sentimento per lei.











