2018 Midterm Losers Claim Outcome Tainted—Sounds Familiar
Democrats recaptured control of the House of Representatives and Republicans increased their grip on the U.S. Senate—but plenty contests continued after election day.
“Tainted by Suspicion: The Secret Deals and Electoral Chaos of Disputed Presidential Elections” by Fred Lucas offers plenty of historical lessons on the recent election disputes.
Pro-longed statewide elections carried on well beyond election day in Arizona for U.S. Senate; in Florida for governor and U.S. Senate; and in Georgia for governor. As of the close of last week, 10 House races still hadn’t been called.
President Donald Trump claimed mass voter fraud. Numerous Democrats claimed mass voter suppression this year. Both charges erode confidence in free and fair elections—leaving the public to doubt the legitimacy of their leaders.
That was the case in the elections profiled in “Tainted by Suspicion,” with the presidential elections of 2000, 1876, 1824 and 1800.
It took more than a week to count the votes in the Arizona Senate race where Democrat Kyrsten Sinema narrowly defeated her Republican opponent Martha McSally.
Last Friday in Georgia, Democrat Stacey Abrams ended her campaign, but called the outcome “rotten and rigged” by Governor-elect Brian Kemp, a Republican. The reason is that Kemp is the outgoing Secretary of State, the top state election official.
Sen. Bill Nelson, a Democrat, finally conceded his seat on Sunday, only after demanding more votes be counted. Nelson clung to hope while trailing Gov. Rick Scott, a Republican, in a statewide recount.
Democrat Andrew Gillum conceded on election night to Republican Ron DeSantis in the Florida governor’s race. But un-conceded since the race was close enough to trigger an automatic recount. On Saturday, he re-conceded after a statewide recount.
Noticeably, two of the closest races were in Florida.
U.S. District Judge Mark Walker, who presided over several post-election lawsuits in Florida, asserted, “We have been the laughingstock of the world, election after election, and we chose not to fix this.”
That’s quite true, and it goes back further than the judge might have considered.
“Tainted by Suspicion,” opens with the question, “What is it about Florida anyway?”
It goes on to explain, “The question above is based on the oddity that one state would play such a big role in controversial presidential elections. First, in 1876, Florida was the most closely contested of the four states in question during the Hayes-Tilden election. In 2000, it was the only state in question for the Bush-Gore dispute.”
Click here to order “Tainted by Suspicion: The Secret Deals and Electoral Chaos of Disputed Presidential Elections.”