“Why is everyone so afraid of me?”

One AU roleplay blog!

[starlit-pasts]

WELCOME TO THE STARLIT PASTS AU BLOG! BEFORE YOU INTERACT, HERE ARE SOME BASICS:

LORE ⭐

This blog documents an AU where One never killed Three in a fit of rage, instead taking the time to calm herself before properly confronting her over it. The two talked things out and are closer than ever now. Though Four and X (and eventually Two) still leave, everyone else stays, and One manages to build a close circle of friends (that being said, feel free to be wary of her to spice up the roleplay).

RULES 🌕

| I'm open to roleplay for any fandom, even ones outside of the OSC. Crossovers are fun!

| Magic anons are okay, but please be aware I have the right to reject them if they aren't something I want to do.

| Please be respectful during OOC interactions!

| Don't worry if I reject your ask, it's most likely something I'm not comfortable with.

| Bigots aren't welcome here! If you have bigoted views, don't even bother interacting with this blog.

DNI ☄️

Don't even think about interacting if you are:

| Bigoted in any way (homophobic, transphobic, racist, misogynistic, etc). All are welcome here!

| Pro-MAGA.

| Pedophilic or zoophilic. CHILDREN AND ANIMALS CANNOT CONSENT.

| A proshipper. Things like incest or rape are absolutely not welcome on this blog.

| Pro-AI. AI is not real art!

I think that covers everything you need to know. Have a fun time~ ⭐

[starlit-pasts]

Fank ‘ou… < leans into them >

She didn't say anything, simply continuing to hold them.

[starlit-pasts]

…huh.

- @lets-make-a-deal11

(Ooc: evil and intimidating canon one. Hopefully she won’t kill you out of jealousy)

"Huh yourself. Why do you look like me?" she asked, getting closer to study this odd doppelganger.

//Awesome happy ending One vs the evil and intimidating canon One//

[lets-make-a-deal11]

Because I am you. Well, you from a different universe.

So, three’s still alive and well in your universe? Lucky you.

*her voice is sharp with envy.*

[starlit-pasts]

"Is she not in yours?" One's expression was pure confusion, with a bit of fear over her other self's sharp tone.

[lets-make-a-deal11]

I accidentally killed her when she told everyone else about the yoylite.

[starlit-pasts]

One's eyes widened in shock. "Why?! What the hell could you have had to gain from that?!"

[lets-make-a-deal11]

Don’t look at me like that, I’ve been trying to fix it.

And as for why, she betrayed us. We told her to keep it a secret, didn’t we?

[starlit-pasts]

"Yes, but it would have been so easy to just.. talk to her about it! She would've been so understanding, if you had just taken the time to calm down and-"

[lets-make-a-deal11]

SHUT. UP! YOU THINK I DON’T KNOW THAT?? I WASN’T THINKING STRAIGHT AT THE TIME.

*she takes a deep breath, regaining her composure.*

I don’t need your dumb advice. It won’t help me now.

[starlit-pasts]

One flinched back like a struck animal. "I just wanted to help, you didn't have to yell at me."

[lets-make-a-deal11]

I don’t need help, especially not from you.

[starlit-pasts]

"...Are you sure about that?"

[lets-make-a-deal11]

Mhm.

[starlit-pasts]

She was silent, looking over her other self. "You seem lonely."

[lets-make-a-deal11]

Could you just GO AWAY?!

*without thinking, she zaps the alternate her.*

[starlit-pasts]

One gave a cry as she was blasted and sent flying backwards. She slammed rather harshly against a tree, and struggled to stand up. "Why won't you let me HELP YOU?!" she yelled, tears in her eyes.

[lets-make-a-deal11]

I ALREADY TOLD YOU I DON’T NEED HELP! LEAVE ME ALONE!

[starlit-pasts]

"I know you," she said, trying to stand tall, "because you're me. And I know you need help right now. You just don't want to accept it, because you fear you don't deserve it."

[lets-make-a-deal11]

*she’s on the verge of crying.*

Why are you being so STUBBORN?! I could kill you! I’ll- I’ll kill you!-

[starlit-pasts]

"Could you? Yes. But the question is: will you?" She stepped closer. "I know you don't have it in you. You're not bad or evil or any of that. Right?"

[lets-make-a-deal11]

…

*…she’s crying. Poor one :(*

[starlit-pasts]

One walked closer to her.

[lets-make-a-deal11]

…why do you want to help me so bad?

[starlit-pasts]

"Because you need it. I can see the pain in your eyes."

[starlit-pasts]

…huh.

- @lets-make-a-deal11

(Ooc: evil and intimidating canon one. Hopefully she won’t kill you out of jealousy)

"Huh yourself. Why do you look like me?" she asked, getting closer to study this odd doppelganger.

//Awesome happy ending One vs the evil and intimidating canon One//

[lets-make-a-deal11]

Because I am you. Well, you from a different universe.

So, three’s still alive and well in your universe? Lucky you.

*her voice is sharp with envy.*

[starlit-pasts]

"Is she not in yours?" One's expression was pure confusion, with a bit of fear over her other self's sharp tone.

[lets-make-a-deal11]

I accidentally killed her when she told everyone else about the yoylite.

[starlit-pasts]

One's eyes widened in shock. "Why?! What the hell could you have had to gain from that?!"

[lets-make-a-deal11]

Don’t look at me like that, I’ve been trying to fix it.

And as for why, she betrayed us. We told her to keep it a secret, didn’t we?

[starlit-pasts]

"Yes, but it would have been so easy to just.. talk to her about it! She would've been so understanding, if you had just taken the time to calm down and-"

[lets-make-a-deal11]

SHUT. UP! YOU THINK I DON’T KNOW THAT?? I WASN’T THINKING STRAIGHT AT THE TIME.

*she takes a deep breath, regaining her composure.*

I don’t need your dumb advice. It won’t help me now.

[starlit-pasts]

One flinched back like a struck animal. "I just wanted to help, you didn't have to yell at me."

[lets-make-a-deal11]

I don’t need help, especially not from you.

[starlit-pasts]

"...Are you sure about that?"

[lets-make-a-deal11]

Mhm.

[starlit-pasts]

She was silent, looking over her other self. "You seem lonely."

[lets-make-a-deal11]

Could you just GO AWAY?!

*without thinking, she zaps the alternate her.*

[starlit-pasts]

One gave a cry as she was blasted and sent flying backwards. She slammed rather harshly against a tree, and struggled to stand up. "Why won't you let me HELP YOU?!" she yelled, tears in her eyes.

[lets-make-a-deal11]

I ALREADY TOLD YOU I DON’T NEED HELP! LEAVE ME ALONE!

[starlit-pasts]

"I know you," she said, trying to stand tall, "because you're me. And I know you need help right now. You just don't want to accept it, because you fear you don't deserve it."

[lets-make-a-deal11]

*she’s on the verge of crying.*

Why are you being so STUBBORN?! I could kill you! I’ll- I’ll kill you!-

[starlit-pasts]

"Could you? Yes. But the question is: will you?" She stepped closer. "I know you don't have it in you. You're not bad or evil or any of that. Right?"

[lets-make-a-deal11]

…

*…she’s crying. Poor one :(*

[starlit-pasts]

One walked closer to her.

[starlit-pasts]

< whines and makes a grabby motion at them > (it’s ok Ɛ:)

"There, there, you're okay." One picked her up to the best of her ability.

[starlit-pasts]

…huh.

- @lets-make-a-deal11

(Ooc: evil and intimidating canon one. Hopefully she won’t kill you out of jealousy)

"Huh yourself. Why do you look like me?" she asked, getting closer to study this odd doppelganger.

//Awesome happy ending One vs the evil and intimidating canon One//

[lets-make-a-deal11]

Because I am you. Well, you from a different universe.

So, three’s still alive and well in your universe? Lucky you.

*her voice is sharp with envy.*

[starlit-pasts]

"Is she not in yours?" One's expression was pure confusion, with a bit of fear over her other self's sharp tone.

[lets-make-a-deal11]

I accidentally killed her when she told everyone else about the yoylite.

[starlit-pasts]

One's eyes widened in shock. "Why?! What the hell could you have had to gain from that?!"

[lets-make-a-deal11]

Don’t look at me like that, I’ve been trying to fix it.

And as for why, she betrayed us. We told her to keep it a secret, didn’t we?

[starlit-pasts]

"Yes, but it would have been so easy to just.. talk to her about it! She would've been so understanding, if you had just taken the time to calm down and-"

[lets-make-a-deal11]

SHUT. UP! YOU THINK I DON’T KNOW THAT?? I WASN’T THINKING STRAIGHT AT THE TIME.

*she takes a deep breath, regaining her composure.*

I don’t need your dumb advice. It won’t help me now.

[starlit-pasts]

One flinched back like a struck animal. "I just wanted to help, you didn't have to yell at me."

[lets-make-a-deal11]

I don’t need help, especially not from you.

[starlit-pasts]

"...Are you sure about that?"

[lets-make-a-deal11]

Mhm.

[starlit-pasts]

She was silent, looking over her other self. "You seem lonely."

[lets-make-a-deal11]

Could you just GO AWAY?!

*without thinking, she zaps the alternate her.*

[starlit-pasts]

One gave a cry as she was blasted and sent flying backwards. She slammed rather harshly against a tree, and struggled to stand up. "Why won't you let me HELP YOU?!" she yelled, tears in her eyes.

[lets-make-a-deal11]

I ALREADY TOLD YOU I DON’T NEED HELP! LEAVE ME ALONE!

[starlit-pasts]

"I know you," she said, trying to stand tall, "because you're me. And I know you need help right now. You just don't want to accept it, because you fear you don't deserve it."

[lets-make-a-deal11]

*she’s on the verge of crying.*

Why are you being so STUBBORN?! I could kill you! I’ll- I’ll kill you!-

[starlit-pasts]

"Could you? Yes. But the question is: will you?" She stepped closer. "I know you don't have it in you. You're not bad or evil or any of that. Right?"

[starlit-pasts]

(They’re not physically any smaller than the other Ones)

//OOOHHHHH OOPSY//

[starlit-pasts]

< curls into herself and cries >

"Hey, hey, it's okay." She rocked the smaller creature, gently talking to it to try and numb its tears.

[starlit-pasts]

…huh.

- @lets-make-a-deal11

(Ooc: evil and intimidating canon one. Hopefully she won’t kill you out of jealousy)

"Huh yourself. Why do you look like me?" she asked, getting closer to study this odd doppelganger.

//Awesome happy ending One vs the evil and intimidating canon One//

[lets-make-a-deal11]

Because I am you. Well, you from a different universe.

So, three’s still alive and well in your universe? Lucky you.

*her voice is sharp with envy.*

[starlit-pasts]

"Is she not in yours?" One's expression was pure confusion, with a bit of fear over her other self's sharp tone.

[lets-make-a-deal11]

I accidentally killed her when she told everyone else about the yoylite.

[starlit-pasts]

One's eyes widened in shock. "Why?! What the hell could you have had to gain from that?!"

[lets-make-a-deal11]

Don’t look at me like that, I’ve been trying to fix it.

And as for why, she betrayed us. We told her to keep it a secret, didn’t we?

[starlit-pasts]

"Yes, but it would have been so easy to just.. talk to her about it! She would've been so understanding, if you had just taken the time to calm down and-"

[lets-make-a-deal11]

SHUT. UP! YOU THINK I DON’T KNOW THAT?? I WASN’T THINKING STRAIGHT AT THE TIME.

*she takes a deep breath, regaining her composure.*

I don’t need your dumb advice. It won’t help me now.

[starlit-pasts]

One flinched back like a struck animal. "I just wanted to help, you didn't have to yell at me."

[lets-make-a-deal11]

I don’t need help, especially not from you.

[starlit-pasts]

"...Are you sure about that?"

[lets-make-a-deal11]

Mhm.

[starlit-pasts]

She was silent, looking over her other self. "You seem lonely."

[lets-make-a-deal11]

Could you just GO AWAY?!

*without thinking, she zaps the alternate her.*

[starlit-pasts]

One gave a cry as she was blasted and sent flying backwards. She slammed rather harshly against a tree, and struggled to stand up. "Why won't you let me HELP YOU?!" she yelled, tears in her eyes.

[lets-make-a-deal11]

I ALREADY TOLD YOU I DON’T NEED HELP! LEAVE ME ALONE!

[starlit-pasts]

"I know you," she said, trying to stand tall, "because you're me. And I know you need help right now. You just don't want to accept it, because you fear you don't deserve it."

[starlit-pasts]

…huh.

- @lets-make-a-deal11

(Ooc: evil and intimidating canon one. Hopefully she won’t kill you out of jealousy)

"Huh yourself. Why do you look like me?" she asked, getting closer to study this odd doppelganger.

//Awesome happy ending One vs the evil and intimidating canon One//

[lets-make-a-deal11]

Because I am you. Well, you from a different universe.

So, three’s still alive and well in your universe? Lucky you.

*her voice is sharp with envy.*

[starlit-pasts]

"Is she not in yours?" One's expression was pure confusion, with a bit of fear over her other self's sharp tone.

[lets-make-a-deal11]

I accidentally killed her when she told everyone else about the yoylite.

[starlit-pasts]

One's eyes widened in shock. "Why?! What the hell could you have had to gain from that?!"

[lets-make-a-deal11]

Don’t look at me like that, I’ve been trying to fix it.

And as for why, she betrayed us. We told her to keep it a secret, didn’t we?

[starlit-pasts]

"Yes, but it would have been so easy to just.. talk to her about it! She would've been so understanding, if you had just taken the time to calm down and-"

[lets-make-a-deal11]

SHUT. UP! YOU THINK I DON’T KNOW THAT?? I WASN’T THINKING STRAIGHT AT THE TIME.

*she takes a deep breath, regaining her composure.*

I don’t need your dumb advice. It won’t help me now.

[starlit-pasts]

One flinched back like a struck animal. "I just wanted to help, you didn't have to yell at me."

[lets-make-a-deal11]

I don’t need help, especially not from you.

[starlit-pasts]

"...Are you sure about that?"

[lets-make-a-deal11]

Mhm.

[starlit-pasts]

She was silent, looking over her other self. "You seem lonely."

[lets-make-a-deal11]

Could you just GO AWAY?!

*without thinking, she zaps the alternate her.*

[starlit-pasts]

One gave a cry as she was blasted and sent flying backwards. She slammed rather harshly against a tree, and struggled to stand up. "Why won't you let me HELP YOU?!" she yelled, tears in her eyes.

[starlit-pasts]

Mhm.. < sob >

"It's okay, I'm sure it was just an accident.." One used her magic to pick up the kid, rocking her gently. "Don't cry."

[starlit-pasts]

…huh.

- @lets-make-a-deal11

(Ooc: evil and intimidating canon one. Hopefully she won’t kill you out of jealousy)

"Huh yourself. Why do you look like me?" she asked, getting closer to study this odd doppelganger.

//Awesome happy ending One vs the evil and intimidating canon One//

[lets-make-a-deal11]

Because I am you. Well, you from a different universe.

So, three’s still alive and well in your universe? Lucky you.

*her voice is sharp with envy.*

[starlit-pasts]

"Is she not in yours?" One's expression was pure confusion, with a bit of fear over her other self's sharp tone.

[lets-make-a-deal11]

I accidentally killed her when she told everyone else about the yoylite.

[starlit-pasts]

One's eyes widened in shock. "Why?! What the hell could you have had to gain from that?!"

[lets-make-a-deal11]

Don’t look at me like that, I’ve been trying to fix it.

And as for why, she betrayed us. We told her to keep it a secret, didn’t we?

[starlit-pasts]

"Yes, but it would have been so easy to just.. talk to her about it! She would've been so understanding, if you had just taken the time to calm down and-"

[lets-make-a-deal11]

SHUT. UP! YOU THINK I DON’T KNOW THAT?? I WASN’T THINKING STRAIGHT AT THE TIME.

*she takes a deep breath, regaining her composure.*

I don’t need your dumb advice. It won’t help me now.

[starlit-pasts]

One flinched back like a struck animal. "I just wanted to help, you didn't have to yell at me."

[lets-make-a-deal11]

I don’t need help, especially not from you.

[starlit-pasts]

"...Are you sure about that?"

[lets-make-a-deal11]

Mhm.

[starlit-pasts]

She was silent, looking over her other self. "You seem lonely."

[starlit-pasts]

Cuz ‘m bad n I killed hew… < sniffle >

"You?! But you're so small and cute!"

[shattered-thirds]

"Hiii!! Hi Three!!! Hiiiii!!!!!!!!!" - @starlit-pasts

Hi! Nice to see you!

[starlit-pasts]

"It's been so long!!" It's only been five minutes.

[shattered-thirds]

It has, what’ve you been up to?

[starlit-pasts]

"Oh, nothing much. Been just wandering around, exploring, the usual. What about you?"

[shattered-thirds]

I’ve been hanging out with Five a lot recently!

[starlit-pasts]

"Five's pretty chill. He's kinda scary though, I'll admit," she confessed with a laugh.

[shattered-thirds]

You get used to him, don’t worry

[starlit-pasts]

"Well I would hope so." She smiled, content to be with her favorite person in the whole world. "The way he stares at me gives me the creeps sometimes."

[shattered-thirds]

He’s just trying to get a read on you, he’ll come around

[starlit-pasts]

"He's like a cat in that way."

[shattered-thirds]

Yep, I can confirm, he did that with me when we first meet, but he’ll like you I’m sure

*she pats her head*

[starlit-pasts]

"I hope so.." Though she hid it well, the sting of being alone for so long had never left her heart.

[shattered-thirds]

He pretty much likes all of his friend’s friends, so you should be good!

[starlit-pasts]

One fell over, laying in the grassy fields. "You wanna know something?"

[pillow-bfdi-rp]

What?

[starlit-pasts]

"I often wonder to myself "what if in another universe, we didn't talk anything out"?"

[shattered-thirds]

(Wrong aac on the last reblog I’m sorry :()

Talk what out?

[starlit-pasts]

//It's okay it was really funny to have Pillow just barge in//

"The yoylite thing?" She tilted her head. "Don't you remember?"

[shattered-thirds]

No, what’s yoylite?

*she sounds confused*

[starlit-pasts]

It finally clicked that this wasn't her Three. "Ah, never mind. Long story."

[starlit-pasts]

…huh.

- @lets-make-a-deal11

(Ooc: evil and intimidating canon one. Hopefully she won’t kill you out of jealousy)

"Huh yourself. Why do you look like me?" she asked, getting closer to study this odd doppelganger.

//Awesome happy ending One vs the evil and intimidating canon One//

[lets-make-a-deal11]

Because I am you. Well, you from a different universe.

So, three’s still alive and well in your universe? Lucky you.

*her voice is sharp with envy.*

[starlit-pasts]

"Is she not in yours?" One's expression was pure confusion, with a bit of fear over her other self's sharp tone.

[lets-make-a-deal11]

I accidentally killed her when she told everyone else about the yoylite.

[starlit-pasts]

One's eyes widened in shock. "Why?! What the hell could you have had to gain from that?!"

[lets-make-a-deal11]

Don’t look at me like that, I’ve been trying to fix it.

And as for why, she betrayed us. We told her to keep it a secret, didn’t we?

[starlit-pasts]

"Yes, but it would have been so easy to just.. talk to her about it! She would've been so understanding, if you had just taken the time to calm down and-"

[lets-make-a-deal11]

SHUT. UP! YOU THINK I DON’T KNOW THAT?? I WASN’T THINKING STRAIGHT AT THE TIME.

*she takes a deep breath, regaining her composure.*

I don’t need your dumb advice. It won’t help me now.

[starlit-pasts]

One flinched back like a struck animal. "I just wanted to help, you didn't have to yell at me."

[lets-make-a-deal11]

I don’t need help, especially not from you.

[starlit-pasts]

"...Are you sure about that?"

[starlit-pasts]

Mhm.. my th’ees nice ta me buh I c’n tell she’s stiw scaw’d of me…

"Why would she be scared, little one?"

[shattered-thirds]

"Hiii!! Hi Three!!! Hiiiii!!!!!!!!!" - @starlit-pasts

Hi! Nice to see you!

[starlit-pasts]

"It's been so long!!" It's only been five minutes.

[shattered-thirds]

It has, what’ve you been up to?

[starlit-pasts]

"Oh, nothing much. Been just wandering around, exploring, the usual. What about you?"

[shattered-thirds]

I’ve been hanging out with Five a lot recently!

[starlit-pasts]

"Five's pretty chill. He's kinda scary though, I'll admit," she confessed with a laugh.

[shattered-thirds]

You get used to him, don’t worry

[starlit-pasts]

"Well I would hope so." She smiled, content to be with her favorite person in the whole world. "The way he stares at me gives me the creeps sometimes."

[shattered-thirds]

He’s just trying to get a read on you, he’ll come around

[starlit-pasts]

"He's like a cat in that way."

[shattered-thirds]

Yep, I can confirm, he did that with me when we first meet, but he’ll like you I’m sure

*she pats her head*

[starlit-pasts]

"I hope so.." Though she hid it well, the sting of being alone for so long had never left her heart.

[shattered-thirds]

He pretty much likes all of his friend’s friends, so you should be good!

[starlit-pasts]

One fell over, laying in the grassy fields. "You wanna know something?"

[pillow-bfdi-rp]

What?

[starlit-pasts]

"I often wonder to myself "what if in another universe, we didn't talk anything out"?"

[shattered-thirds]

(Wrong aac on the last reblog I’m sorry :()

Talk what out?

[starlit-pasts]

//It's okay it was really funny to have Pillow just barge in//

"The yoylite thing?" She tilted her head. "Don't you remember?"