warnings: angsty at first, fluffy at the end
authors note: my longest oneshot so far! i hope you like it, we are almost at 300 followers, so exciting!! thank you so much for all the love you gave to the second imagine, it made me so happy!
*Based on the song Don’t You Wanna Stay by Jason Aldean and Kelly Clarkson
“I should probably get going,” you whispered sitting up in the bed, sheets covering your naked body.
Don’t go, Chris wanted to say, but he didn’t. He couldn’t. He never could ask you to stay and you couldn’t ever ask him to stay either. That wasn’t part of the deal. At least not at first.
Whenever the time came for you to leave, you always told him you were about to head home and you would always hesitate before getting out of bed for a few minutes, hoping he would ask you to stay.
But he never did. So, you got up from the bed and got dressed. Both of you hating this moment, the moment when the other had to leave, but you would never tell the other because you didn’t want to ruin what you had.
You and Chris were friends, who met through mutual friends and working on movies and songs together. One night you both were hanging out and one thing and a few drinks lead to another and you two hooked up. Somehow from that one night, you two both decided on being in sort of a friends with benefits relationship.
Both of you were single and weren’t really looking for a serious relationship, so it worked out. You both got the companionship both of you desired without having to deal with everything that came from a relationship. You two just had one rule, the other person couldn’t stay the night whenever you two slept together.
However, as time went on, you found yourself falling for him. You knew you shouldn’t because he didn’t feel the same way about you. Except he did, he had fallen hard for you, but due to the circumstances of your little arrangement, he had yet to find the courage to tell you how he really felt about you.
Chris watched you as you got dressed. Part of you hoped he didn’t notice how you slowly put on your clothes one item at a time waiting for something that would never happen. But the other part of you wished that he did and he would ask you to stay.
He bit his lip as he forced himself not to open his mouth to say anything because he couldn’t trust what might come out of it.
Once your boots were on, you got up from the bed and grabbed your bag.
“So, uh… I guess I’ll talk to you later?” You asked.
“Yeah, we’ll talk later,” he nodded.
“Well, uh… bye then,” you said waving a bit.
His lips turned into a small smile as he waved back to you. You walked out of his room and his house before getting into your car. You looked at yourself in the rearview mirror of your car. Your hair was a mess and your lipstick stained the skin around your lips. Tears welled up in your eyes as you realized you couldn’t keep doing this. You couldn’t keep putting yourself through this anymore.
As soon as you left, Chris found himself getting up from his bed and went straight to the door. His hand was on the doorknob, but he didn’t turn it. He pressed his forehead against the cool surface of his front door. His heart told him to open the door and stop you. Tell you how he felt and bring you back inside and show you just how he feels about you, but his head, his head was telling him to just let you go.
That night, his head won.
“I don’t want to just make love, I wanna make love last,” you softly sang to yourself, thinking about making a new song out of this. “When you’re up this high, it’s a sad goodbye.”
You sighed reaching over to grab your drink and downing the remains of it. It had been two days since you last saw Chris and it was driving you insane, but it was your own fault. You hadn’t returned his calls or texts because you couldn’t face him right now. Your heart was still calling for him. Still aching for him, but didn’t have the courage to tell him how you felt.
So, you were avoiding him. You just needed some time to yourself, a few days to get your head and heart on the same page, and then you could go back to the little arrangement you two had like nothing ever happened. Except, would that really be enough for you.
There would be one day when he’d find someone to not only share his bed with but also his heart… and he’d end what you two had with one another. Would you honestly be able to handle seeing him with someone else… being with someone else? You could tell yourself you’d be fine all you wanted, but deep down you knew you’d be broken inside.
Broken because you both had made a promise to each other that what you two had was just for fun. You both were single and it was just casual. You were friends first and foremost, who on multiple occasions ended up naked in each other’s beds. That was it.
That was what you always told yourself. But it didn’t matter because you were without a doubt in love with him.
Chris gripped his phone as the other line went straight to your voicemail.
“Fuck!” He shouted throwing his phone onto the couch in his living room.
Chris was beyond frustrated with you. You hadn’t answered any of his phone calls or his text messages in the last few days. That was like you. You always answered, okay, but not everytime the first time, but you could always call back or respond to him within a few hours… but now he had yet to get anything.
What if… what if you were with someone else? What if he lost you because he was too fucking stubborn and scared to tell you how he really felt about you. He had brought dinner, your favorite, in hopes you’d stop by, but it remained on the table where it was now cold after sitting there, untouched for over two hours.
He swallowed the lump in his throat as he stared at the food containers. It was almost like they were mocking him, rubbing it in his face that you stood him up. That you were avoiding him. He couldn’t take anymore, so he grabbed the trash bin and shoved all of the food inside of it.
Except he didn’t stop there, everything in his house reminded him of you. Your perfume still lingered in the air. It didn’t matter how many candles he had lit, he still smelled you. God, he wanted you more than anything, but he fucked up.
He should have gone after you that night. He should have told you to get out of your car and come back inside. He should have made you breakfast the next morning and told you he was in love with you.
Your phone rang once again. You stared at the name lighting up across the screen. It had been a week now. You had ghosted him for almost over a week, and he was still trying to contact you. You felt bad not talking to him, but it better for you if you didn’t. If you were going to get over these feelings for him, you just had to walk away for a bit.
But Chris being Chris, you knew it wouldn’t that easy. Once you did start talking to him again, he would ask you what happened. What was wrong, what he did wrong. And you’d have to lie… and keep lying to him, to yourself. All because you were afraid of a little heartbreak.
Was ignoring one of your best friends, someone you could always turn to, really working out for you? Not really. You hated not seeing him. Not hearing his voice. But you were scared.
You were scared of letting your heart win and finally telling him how you felt. Scared of opening yourself up to all of that again. You had yet to have a healthy, stable relationship and you don’t know if you could go through having another relationship fail, especially with him.
That’s why you agreed to have the arrangement because it meant you two had a relationship, without actually having the relationship. And now you wanted more, but you were too scared to want it enough to tell him how you felt.
And you weren’t strong enough to stay away from him any longer.
Chris was shocked to see your name come across the screen of his iPhone.
Sorry, been working in the studio all week. If you don’t mind, I’ll be there in 10. I’ll even bring a pizza and ice cream.
As long as you get double cheese, I don’t mind.
Chris typed his response and quickly went around cleaning up his room and the living room. There were a few more wine and beer bottles than necessary, so he made sure to get rid of those before you walked in. He knew you well enough that you weren’t just working on the script. You had always made time to talk to him, to see him, to be with him regardless of how late it was or how tired you were.
So, he had a feeling that tonight would be your last night together and he didn’t want to screw it up.
When the doorbell rang, he quickly went over to answer it. He took a deep breath before opening it and see you standing there, with a pizza box in one hand, and few pints of ice cream in a bag in the other.
“One large veggie pizza with extra cheese,” you smiled. “And one pint of mint chocolate chip ice cream and another of chocolate chip cookie dough.”
He laughed, “Hm, good choices, so I guess I can let you in then.”
“You better because one hand is burning and the other is about to freeze itself off,” you laughed.
“Here, let me take one of those,” he said grabbing the pizza and walking inside.
You followed him in and put the ice cream in the freezer for when you two were ready for it. Harry grabbed two plates and glasses from the cabinet and put you both two slices a piece of the plate before handing it to you.
“Do you want water, wine, or soda?” He asked.
“Water’s fine,” you said.
He nodded pouring you both some water and walking over to the couch, where you both ate your pizza in silence.
Chris took a sip of his water and looked over at you. “You said you’ve been working in the studio? Have you been writing on a new song?”
“Oh, uh, yeah, it’s particularly almost finished,” you said.
“Do you mind if I hear what you have so far?” He asked.
“Uh, sure, but um when I say it’s unfinished I mean, it’s unfinished,” you said. “I only really have like one verse and a bit of the chorus and maybe a little bit of a bridge.”
“I don’t mind… maybe I could help you out a bit,” he added.
You took a deep breath and put your plate of half eaten pizza on the coffee table and grabbed your phone out of your pocket. You picked the notes app and cleared your throat.
“Let’s take it slow, I don’t wanna move to fast. I don’t wanna just make love, I wanna make love last. When you’re up this high, it’s a sad goodbye,” you sang softly.
“Don’t you wanna stay here a little while? Oh, you feel so perfect, baby. Yeah, you feel so perfect,” You paused.
“Um, see it’s really botched up right now,” you laughed. “I don’t know. it’s just uh… missing something that I can’t get out out right now.”
“I might have something… if you want to hear it,” he said.
“Okay,” you nodded. “I’m all ears.”
“I really hate to let this moment go. Touching your skin and your hair falling slow. When a goodbye kiss feels like this…” he sang.
“Don’t you wanna stay here a little while? Don’t you wanna hold each other tight? Don’t you wanna fall asleep with me tonight?” He added.
“Sorry,” he said. “I didn’t mean to add to the chorus.”
“No, no it’s great… it’s actually better than what I had,” you said. “What if I…hold on… let me write along.”
You quickly started writing down the lyrics he sang.
“How about this… Don’t you wanna stay here a little while? Don’t you wanna hold each other tight? Don’t you wanna fall asleep with me tonight? Don’t you wanna stay here a little while? We could make forever feel this way… Don’t wanna stay?” You sang.
“What if we arranged your verse first, then add in the chorus next. Then my verse, and continue with the same chorus… but maybe added a “Hey, yeah, oh yeeah,” to it makes it a little different,” you said. “And then has like a bridge, we can use the, oh, you feel so perfect, baby and lead into a softer version of the chorus before building it up.”
“I think that could work,” he nodded. “Except for the bridge part, instead of us singing it together, what if we did like an echo effect. Where I sing and then you follow it up or vice versa.”
“Oh, you feel so perfect, baby,” He sang.
“Yeah, you feel so perfect, baaby,” you sang after him.
He smiled,”Why don’t we try putting it all together.”
“I really hate to let this moment go…” he sang softly looking at you, starting the song.
“Don’t you wanna staaaay,” you sang ending the song once you pieced it all together.
You both finished singing and the air was filled with silence and tension. Chris looked over at you. Your arms were sat upon a couch pillow and you looked back up at him. He leaned in, closing the distance between the two of you, pressing his lips against yours.
Chris took the pillow away from you as he kissed you. You wrapped your arms around his neck and he deepened the kiss. His hands were at your waist before wrapping them around you. He picked you up and carried you to his bedroom. He took your shirt off, while you pulled his shirt up and over his head.
He walked you two back towards his bed, laying you on top of his mattress.
When it was over a few hours later, you both laid on the bed, side by side. Yet again you two were silent and you sighed. It was getting late, which meant it was time for you to leave.
“I should probably get going,” you whispered sitting up and throwing your legs over the edge of the mattress.
The hardwood floor was chilly as your feet touched the ground. You reached down for your clothes when you felt a hand grab your own. You froze. This never happened. Once the deed was done, you two didn’t touch the other. Hell, you hardly spoke afterward other your goodbyes and get home safe.
“You can stay… um.. if you want,” he whispered.
You turned around, looking at him. He was holding your hand and staring up at you.
“Are… are you sure?” You whispered.
Chris sat up and moved closer to where you were sitting. “Y/N… I can’t… we can’t keep doing this,” he whispered. “I hate when you leave… or when I leave your place. I hated not talking to you this past week and I hate… I hate what we have right now. I want more with you. This arrangement… it was never… it was never just about fucking for me and while I definitely enjoy it, I don’t want only that anymore.”
“It was never just about fucking for me either,” you whispered. “And I lied when I said I was busy this week… I was avoiding you because… because I realized I’m in love with you and I was scared to te-”
Chris pressed his lips against yours interrupting you the moment you said you were in love with him. After pulling away, he pressed his forehead against yours.
“I’m in love with you, too,” he whispered.
You smiled putting your hand on his shoulder and pressing your lips to his in a kiss. He laughed holding you close to him.
“Does this mean you’re going to stay?” He whispered.
You smiled nodding. Chris smiled laying back on the bed and pulling you into his arms. He kissed your forehead as he both held each other tight.
“Just so you know, I really enjoy pancakes for breakfast,” you giggled.
“Good to know,” he laughed.
You smiled pressing a kiss to his shoulder before closing your eyes and falling asleep.