Nancy Pelosi was an incredible Speaker.
She didn’t let anything go to the floor unless she knew that she had the votes to pass it. It was masterful.
But you don’t really hear people talk about her when she was minority leader, right?
That’s because she didn’t really have much power.
She didn’t get to choose when something came to the floor.
She couldn’t wait till she had enough votes to kill something the majority wanted to pass. That’s not how it worked.
We don’t know what Hakeem Jeffries will be like as a Speaker.
Maybe you’re right. Maybe he will bring things to the floor he doesn’t have the votes for. Maybe he will work with Republicans on things we really don’t need to work with Republicans on.
But, he learned from Pelosi, so I doubt it.
Right now, he is minority leader.
Speaker Mike Johnson chooses what comes to the floor and what doesn’t. And he definitely didn’t learn from the Nancy Pelosi school of speakership.
Jeffries does his best. And that’s all he can do.
There are several Democrats who vote with Republicans between 10 and 20% of the time, it feels like.
Jeffries could make the most compelling argument in history — I’m sure he and several other members, including whip Katherine Clark have — and it wouldn’t matter.
These reps think they know what is best for them, for getting reelected and for their constituents. And that’s that.
Short of taking a page out of the fascist playbook and literally bribing or threatening them, they’re not budging.
Is that on Jeffries? Is that on Democrats at large?
I certainly don’t think so. And I don’t understand why anyone else does either.
Sometimes it feels like social media reads too many science fiction books.
It’s almost like there’s this assumption that we live in an episode of Black Mirror where as leader of the minority party, Jeffries has a switchboard with the name of each member on it.
He is the only one with access to the switchboard. And it has several buttons. “AIPAC,” “ICE,” “SAVE Act” and he pulls a lever to determine who should support a given Republican bill.
Luckily we don’t live in that made up episode of the Black Mirror. We live in a world where we still have free will and Democrats are not a cult.
And that means that there are a handful of Reps who do not vote like we want them to. And some of those are frustrating, like Adam Gray, who is about to be in a safe Dem district.
And some of those are like Don Davis, who is in a very Trumpy area probably does need to vote these ways to stay in office — and we NEED him to stay in office. (I mean, we need both of them, but, votes like this will no longer help Gray like it might help Davis.)
We are a big tent party. And until the Republican party sorts its shit out, we’re gonna continue to be.
But that’s not Jeffries’ fault.
Jeffries leads 212 separate humans, not 212 homogenous robots.
And given that, it’s INCREDIBLY impressive what he and Whip Clark have been able to do. That on a lot of really big monumental issues they’ve gotten the Goldens and the Jayapals alike to vote in line with each other.
The amount of discharge petitions that have passed the House (most years there are none) and the incredible task forces he’s put together, choosing the perfect members to chair each one, are pretty remarkable.
It’s easy to shit on Jeffries and Democrats at large. It’s the popular thing to do.
It’s harder to praise him for doing everything he has done as minority leader. It’s hard to accept that we are the minority and his ability is incredibly limited.
It’s hard to accept that because we are in the minority the votes of these more moderate Dems are much more visible and infuriating than if we were in a comfortable majority.
It’s frustrating to have to acknowledge that Jeffries has no say as to what comes to the floor or if we have enough Dems to kill something.
But just cause it’s hard doesn’t mean we shouldn’t do it anyway.
We HAVE to win in November. And that means that once the primary is over, the Dem who is left standing MUST get elected (except in certain cases where the Independent is more electable, if that’s your district, you already know.)
That means reelecting Don Davis and Adam Gray and Vicente Gonzalez etc. And for the ones that haven’t had their primary yet, voting for the person you want but accepting that if he doesn’t win, you will have to vote for Marie Glusenkamp Perez again in November too.
And it means not blaming Jeffries for any of it.
Jeffries isn’t a fascist and isn’t a cult leader. He and Whip Clark can’t force these members to do anything they don’t want to do. But what they HAVE been able to do deserves support and praise, cause I really don’t know if a different minority leader would have been equally as successful.
Our voices are our superpower, so let’s use them to change the narrative.
Imagine how popular Democrats could be if the focus was on praising them when they did the right thing, not working overtime to seek out things they may have done wrong.
Just some food for thought.
You will not be shocked that this won't be very popular, so if you agree with this post, please follow for more nuance, anti-doomerism content and calls to action!
Turn on my notifications and subscribe to this newsletter so these stories come right to your inbox!
And join my group Election Day Is Every Tuesday, so you’re informed for every election, cause that’s how we start changing things