Not So Tough After All...
The Kyjen "Tough Turtle" along with their "Hide-A-Squirrel" and "Egg Baby" series are all marketed to be "tough toys" with statements like
"Dogs learn to remove hidden squeaker eggs without destroying the toy!" - Kygen on the Egg Babies
and "Durable design and craftsmanship ensures long-lasting puzzle-solving fun!" - Kyjen on the Tough Turtle
But can it really be true?
"Designed for dogs that love to chew" and "Solid construction for added durability. " - Orka on the Petstages Bone Chew
But are they really so tough and durable? Well, suffice it to say that my chihuahua/feist mix puppies destroyed them at approximately 3.5 months of age within half an hour. (So, definitely not that durable.)
**Note: Puppies begin growing their adult teeth at approximately 4 months - 5 months of age. During this time puppy chew toys which previously may have been acceptable like the Nylabone Puppy Teether will become innapropriate. When observing packaging make sure that you determine what age and chew strength is appropriate!
Some things to consider when choosing toys:
Do research on the brand. Companies like Planet Dog, Kong, Nylabone, and the eco-friendly West Paw Design for example give a thorough description of all of their toys. These descriptions are likely not to be found on the actual packaging so avoid impulse buys unless you're willing to take a chance!
Take note of what kind of toys your dog tends to destroy, are they plushies? Rope toys? Squeakers? Chew bones? When choosing another toy, consider the faults of the last one and avoid similar construction, fabric, and most importantly craftsmanship.
Do your own inspection. If a toy has "hair" try tugging on it. If it comes out easily, be sure your dog will be swallowing massive quantities of it at once! If a toy is very flexible try to stretch it. If it stretches easily your dog may be able to tear chunks of it off. Look at the seams, is stuffing or string already coming out? Your dog may be able to tear it open if the stitching isn't sturdy to begin with. Look at appendages, is anything sticking out made of felt? You will probably have to cut these bits off as your dog will definitely chew through it during a chew session.
What toys seem to be the safest / most long-lasting? I will give my Top 10 Durability Ratings based on length of time toy tends to survive in households with strong chewers! This is from my own experience as well as testimonials from others with larger breeds and aggressive chewers.
High Durability - Most people with large dogs and aggressive chewers were satisfied with the length of time the toys lasted (at least 3 months on average). Still fun enough for small dogs to gnaw on!
Moderate Durability - Most people with small-medium sized dogs were satisfied, many people with large / strong chewers were satisfied. These are usually toys that are a little more "chewable" so aggressive chewers may not be as satisfied with the life of the product.
1.) Toys from West Paw Design (High durability made with zogoflex, eco-friendly, comes with a garuantee and less than 1% returns.)
2.) Tire Tugs made from hard rubber. (High Durability.)
3.) Planet Dog Orbee Bouncy Ball (High Durability) :
4.) Jolly Pet Products comes with a guarantee! (High Durability):
5.) Nylabone Dura-Chew Series (Highly Durable) - but very heavy and hard, some dogs may not be interested in such hard plastic toys, this dinosaur is one of the most likable:
6.) Black Kong Toys (Highly Durable for most large breed dogs) The Red Kongs may be more suitable for a small breed dog or a medium breed depending on chew strength:
7.) Tuffie's Dog Toys (Moderate - Highly Durable, made with luggage material coated in plastic, another layer of luggage material on top of that and a soft layer of fleece. Seems the binding is the weakest link):
8.) Thick Rope Toys with knots and in particular monkey-paw style knots (Moderate/Highly durable depending on the quality of the rope as well as the strength of the chewer)
9.) Solid Basic Thick and Well Made Plushies (like the Kyjen Invincible Snake) or the Huggables Knottie Toys made from Corduroy (Moderate / High durability for small / medium sized dogs or larger dogs with less aggressive chew habits):
10.) The Jumbo Kyjen Hedgehog (Moderate / High durability due to it's shape and size, for dogs with aggressive chewing habits, it like most plushies may possibly be destroyed despite the design! However, my small dogs love it and can't wrap their jaws around it.):
As with all toys, you must supervise your dogs play to make sure that the toys are not being ingested. Always examine the toys during and after play, if it becomes destroyed with pieces hanging off (or missing!) Remove immediately, as an ingestion of toy parts could cause medical problems including choking or blockages.
No toys are meant to last forever, however the toys selected on this list have the durability to last longer than most! (Of course, there are always exceptions, so please be mindful of your dogs chewing habits!)
A great alternative to letting your dog destroy toys is to only bring certain toys out during certain play (i.e. Rope Toys for Tug Sessions, Balls for Ball Toss)
If your dog wants a chew session perhaps a toy is not the right choice for him or her. You could always supplement the urge to chew with an edible chew such as
- Antlers (naturally shed, do not shatter or splinter, available in most pet stores):
- and Flossies (my puppie's favorites!):