Retrospective: Deep Purple Mark VIII and Mark IX
Mark VIII features Ian Gillan on vocals, Steve Morse on guitar, Roger Glover on bass, Don Airey on keyboards, and Ian Paice on drums.
Likewise, Mark IX features all of the above except Steve Morse is replaced by Simon McBride on guitar.
These are the modern eras of the band. Deep Purple has been in this state since 2002. That's over 20 years as of writing this.
They barely have a single song I enjoy during these eras. Everything after Purpendicular suffered the same issues that Purpendicular did, only without the highlights. This is a band that has lost its identity and its soul. These are expert musicians going through the motions just to stay in the game. As someone who puts the art first, I find this hard to respect and therefore these eras are hard to enjoy.
Mark VIII in particular is the lame era. They have too much of this modern music seriousness which just does not suit the band. Then, of course, they have outright goofy stuff (as they always have), but none of it seems to land. Awkward ideas. Half-baked songwriting. The word that sums it all up for me is "trite".
I sense that Mark IX is trying to push the music in a heavier direction, but they haven't solved any of the problems that make their lighter material bad to begin with. Simply putting in some heavier riffs isn't going to fix this situation. You'll just suck louder.
I hope I've been clear. I really do respect these musicians. Even the newer guitarists are perfectly good players. The only member whose performances are suffering is Ian Gillan and that's just because he's an aging vocalist, which is a tale as old as time.
The artist in me wants them to hang up the hat. The human in me understands that this is their job. I hate the world we live in that forces old men to parade themselves around on stage until they die just because they don't have a real backup plan. At the end of the day, as much as I feel resentment towards them for continuing this charade, I cannot blame them. In their position, I'd probably do the same.
And let's make another thing clear: this is not just about Deep Purple. Many aging hard rock and metal bands suffer these same issues. This is an aging rocker problem. There's just no great way to do this thing. You create these explosive moments in your youth, some more thoughtful ones as you age, and then eventually you fizzle out.
It's sad. It makes you feel bad to witness. It makes you feel gross about your mortality. But it's real, human shit.
I love you, Deep Purple. This was one of my best musical journeys in a long time. I've found a lifelong favorite band by exploring your music. My hope in writing this is for another metalhead to discover an old band that they'd probably overlooked, most likely due to thinking Smoke on the Water is lame and overplayed. Even if you only learn about Speed King and Highway Star and Burn and Fireball, my work is done. Those songs deserve to live forever and ever.