summary: a few vague answers from your boyfriend andrew, turns into a missed date, turns into an argument, turns into a breakup, turns into makeup sex
content warnings: 18+ smut, oral sex (f!receiving), unprotected piv, creampie, breeding kink if you squint, pope makes reader use her words, secretive pope, slightly stalker pope; pope breaks into readerâs apartment, kind of insecure reader, yes chef one liner in there if you catch it, reader only addresses pope as âandrewâ and âandyâ, use of petnames (sweetheart, love, angel), prob some ooc pope cs i didnât know what petnames heâd use, afab reader, umm i think thatâs it lmk if i missed anything
andrew has always been quiet. thatâs why you two worked, with you always talking and him listening attentively to every word. but thereâs a fine line between quiet and secretive.
you canât exactly pinpoint when you first noticed it. the mumbles when youâd ask what it was like to be a property manager, or the one word answers when youâd ask how his day was. just the vagueness of it all.
when he started keeping a toothbrush at your apartment, you picked up on his irregular work hours more. how heâd leave early during game night because he needed to do an emergency property inspection for one of his tenants, or how heâd come late to a date because of an urgent heating issue in one of his building in san diego.
youâd tried to push it to the back of your mind and convince yourself it was just the weird, flexible work hours of a property manager. but that didnât change the fact that youâd been dating for almost six months and he still hadnât introduced you to his family. you had heard him mention his brothers, craig and deran, once or twice in casual conversation, but you didnât know where they lived or what their lives were like. would they even like you?
the real problem was when he had never showed up for what was supposed to be a movie night but ended with you falling asleep on the couch with a bucket of cold popcorn on your coffee table. the only thing that pulls you out of your sleep is the echo made from the loud click of your front door unlocking, making your head snap up.
there he stood in your doorway, looking frozen and guilty as if he had just been caughtâwhich he had. you rise to your feet, your blood pressure already rising as you stand in front of the sofa with your arms crossed, glaring from the small distance that felt so far.
âwhat time is it?â the question couldâve sounded genuinely curious if it werenât for the icy look on your face.
âwhat?â andrew quietly asks, only speaking after a long moment when he realizes you actually want an answer.
he hesitantly pulls his phone out of his back pocket to check, saying, â2:17.â
you hum in response, pressing your lips together into a straight line. âso whyâd you even bother coming?â you ask rhetorically.
âbecause i wanted to see you,â he says, the rhetoric seemingly flying over his head.
âyou were supposed to be here at 8.â
âsomething came up at work.â
ââtil 2am?â you scoff. when he doesnât respond, you pick up the bowl of wasted popcorn, moving to your right to discard of it in your kitchen. when you turn around from the trash can, you crash hard into his chest, not expecting him to be right behind you.
âiâm sorry,â he spoke, once you regained your balance.
âi told you. work stuff.â
âwhat kind of work stuff?â
âproperty manager work stuff.â
âi canât keep doing this with you, andrew,â you sigh as you walk past him, your small kitchen feeling claustrophobic at the moment. honestly, your whole apartment feels too full. like the air gets thinner every time you try to get a breath.
you turn around to face him once more, âyouâre hiding stuff from me.â
âiâm not hiding anyââ
you donât understand why he wonât tell you. does he not trust you with whatever he has going on in his life? you were supposed to be a team, but it seemed like everytime you pushed, he stepped back a little more. is there something worth hiding from you specifically?
âjust tell me. whatever you got going on, i wouldnât judge you.â
âi know you wouldnât.â
âthen why wonât you tell me?!â youâre begging at this point, desperate for your boyfriend to let you in.
he swallows at your outburst, seeming intimidated as if heâs not the most intimidating person on the planet. âthereâs nothing to tell.â
you let out a breath that you didnât realize you were holding. youâre just so over it. you donât have enough energy to fight for something that shouldnât need to be asked forâtransparity.
âiâm done,â you sigh as you sit back on the couch. âjust go.â
he puts out his hand, âsweetheartââ
âif we donât have honesty, we donât have anything. so just go.â
he stands there for another few seconds, like heâs either hoping youâll change your mind or just straight up ignoring your protests.
he flinches back at the contrast of your harsh tone from your previously disengaged one. once he realizes youâre serious, he turns and walks out of your house, the door clicking quietly behind him.
the click echoes throughout your body. your heart is pounding against your rib cage. there was no taking it back now. but would you even want to? you had meant what you saidâabout the secrets, and the lying, and the honesty. but your heart still aches in his absence. the truth is, your heart has always ached without andrew cody in your life.
your next day isnât much better on top of that. your boss gives you double your usual workload, so you have to stay late to finish it all, and your male coworker, for some reason, finds it necessary to comment multiple times on how âtiredâ you looked.
usually when you had a bad day, youâd go home and cuddle up on the bed with andrew, ranting about all the shitty things that had pissed you off. but now you had no one to go home to.
you fumble with your keys, dropping them as you try to unlock your front door. just another shitty annoyance to add to the list of shitty annoyances on this very shitty day. when you finally get into your house, you drop your bag right by the door, not having the energy to put it in its proper place. you kick off your shoes too, letting them lay in whatever spot they had found themselves in. you drag yourself to your bedroom, rubbing your eyes. when you open them, standing in the doorway, you jump at the sight of a figure sitting in your desk chair.
âholy shit!â you exclaim.
âyouâre home later than usual,â andrew says with a steady voice, as if you were the one who had intruded and he was right where he was supposed to be.
âwhat are you doing here, andrew?â
âi told you to get out. itâs over.â
you cross your arms over your chest, unamused by his protectivenessâwhich was new for you. âmy boss gave me a lot of work, i had to stay late to finish it all.â
âhe giving you a hard time?â
âwhy are you here, andrew?â
you scoff. âalways? yeah, always, except when i need you to be.â
âiâm here now. so câmon, lay down, and you can tell me all about your daââ
âi donât want to lay down. i donât want you here, what donât you understand?â
you scoff again. âlook, i told you, itâs either you be honest with me or get out.â
he says it so quickly and smoothly that you almost believe him. almost.
âreally? then tell me the real reason you were late last night. and every night before that.â
âitâs not important.â
âso, yesterday there was nothing to tell, and now itâs not important?â
your mind races at the same rate as your heart. you donât want to go there, but why else would he be lying to you? what else needed this secrecy?
âare you cheating on me?â
he takes a moment before speaking, furrowing his brows as if dumbfounded by the question, âwhat?â
âare you seeing somebody else?â
âno. why would you think that?â
âwhat else would you need to keep from me?â
seconds feel like hours as you both just look at each other. you want to believe him, you really do. you canât even imagine andrew with another person, especially since it took a while before he truly got comfortable with you. but you canât think of another logical reason for him to be keeping things from you. and if he was seeing somebody else, itâd make sense that he wouldnât introduce you to his family. maybe you were the other woman.
he stands, ending the intense staring contest you were both engaged in. âif i could tell you everything, i would; but i canât. i wouldnât be keeping something private if i didnât have a reason. i love you.â
tears prick at the corners or your eyes as your throat tightens, because you believe him. you truly believe he loves you and you love him too. but none of it is adding up. âthen act like it.â
you turn your back to him as the tears finally spill over and coat your cheeks. your hands quickly move up to cover your face, wishing you could just sink into a hole in the floor. the exhaustion of work and arguing with andrew had finally silently imploded inside of you.
you feel big arms wrap around you, thumbs drawing small circles on your elbows, a broad chest pressed against your back. ââm sorry, sweetheart. didnât mean to make you cry. let me make it up to you.â
you shouldnât let him. you should fight back and insist he tell you the truth. but in this moment, in his arms, all you want is for him to take care of you.
you turn around in his arms, burying your head into his chest and letting the rest of your tears fall. one of his hands comes up to cradle your head while the other rubs your back in gentle circles. âi know. let it all out.â
when your sobs finally slow and your breathing evens out, he removes the hand from the back of your head, causing you to move away from his chest before his hand catches the side of your jaw. âlisten to me. i would never do anything to hurt you. you understand?â
you nod in response before his lips capture yours. his hands move from your face to your waist to the back of your thighs, giving you a little tap as a signal to jump. you wrap your legs around his waist as the kiss continues and he moves you over to your bed.
he places you down on the mattress, settling in between your legs. he brings his lips to your tear-stained cheeks, whispering, âtoo pretty to cry,â as he peppers kisses along the wet lines.
he removes both of your clothes slowly as he goes back to kissing your lips, stripping you both down to just your underwear. he scoots down to be eyelevel with your cotton covered cunt, slowly moving his thumb up and down the shielded slit. âwant me to make you feel good?â
you nod, making him remove him thumb. âuse your words, sweetheart.â
âyes, i want you to make me feel good.â
âokay,â he whispers before placing a peck to your covered clit, making your hips buck up.
âdonât worry. wonât take long.â he hooks his fingers into your undergarments, pulling them down your ankles. his breath ghosts over your core before he dives in, eating you like a starved man. your fingers grasp around his auburn curls as you suck in a breath through your teeth. he doesnât slow his pace once as he devours you, licking and sucking in all the right places. his index and middle finger teases your entrance, gathering the slick before pushing in.
your head falls back against the pillows at the feeling. his digits are big but you know heâll be bigger. soon. that exact thought is what makes you pull at his curls harder. âplease, andy⊠insideâŠâ
andrew keeps lapping at your folds, pulling away only for a moment to pull your legs over his shoulders and press messy kisses to your inner thighs. âneed you to cum first. donât want it to hurt,â he groans before shoving his face back down to your core. he zeroâs in on your sensitive pearl while still slowly working his fingers inside you, making you clamp your legs together around his head. his movement donât falter under the new grip, and you swear, under the haze of pleasure, you can feel him grinning against you.
it doesnât take long before your breathy moans turn into high pitch whimpers and youâre grinding against his tongue. the noises you make are a mix of âandyâŠâ, âyes!â, and âuh uh uh uh uh!â to the same rhythm of andrewâs tongue.
âyou close, sweetheart?â andrew asks, pulling away his mouth for a moment to look up at you while his two fingers still works on your insides. âyou gonna cum fâme?â you whine in response, words seeming impossible for me. âi know, angel. i know,â he cooâs.
his mouth goes back to focusing on your heat, sucking and pulling at your clit. your choke on your gasp as he presses a third finger into you, thrusting faster. your hips buck up instinctively, chasing the feeling of that familiar pressure building. andrewâs free hand shoots up press his arm over your lower belly, holding you down to the mattress.
youâre finally pushed over the edge when you hear, and feel, andrew groan into you. your head falls back against the pillows, letting out a string of moans that starts with andrewâs name and ends in gibberish, as the vibrations flow through you.
when your thighs relax on his shoulders, andrew pulls away, placing one last peck to your clit. he moves his face to be level with yours again, holding himself up on his forearms by your head. âyâknow, usually youâd be in trouble for doing that without asking,â he says before kissing you. smiles as he slides his tongue into your mouth, letting you taste yourself, then takes it away just as quickly. âyouâre lucky you taste so good.â
he moves his lips to lick, suck, and bite your neck, collarbones, and chest. your fingers stay running through andrewâs locks as he works on marking you. he never wants you to think heâs seeing anybody else ever again. he is yours and you are his. âonly you, baby. only ever you.â
he only stops when you start whining his name. âplease. please, andy.â youâre grinding your bare heat against his boxers in desperation, adding even more moisture to the wet patch that was already present. andrew keeps kissing a line up the column of your neck, almost deliberately teasing as he starts rocking his hips against you.
âyou donât have to beg me to fuck you,â he whispers, looking up at you with his big, chocolate-brown eyes, âiâm going to.â he captures your lips with his once again, his right hand positioned next to your head so his body can hover over yours, and the other groping your waist. he moves his dominant hand from your waist to his boxers, pulling them down just enough for his cock to spring out, falling to rest heavily on your thigh. your hand reaches down to stroke it, once, twice, before you feel a hand placed over yours to stop you.
âi need to get inside you, sweetheart.â you immediately respond with an eager nod, but andrew keeps speaking. ânoâ no condom this time. wanna feel all of you. want you to feel all of me.â
you respond by putting your lips on his. he groans into the kiss, moving to line up with hips with yours. he pulls back just enough to look into your eyes. âready?â
he pushes into you slowly, filling you completely. you both let out a breath when he bottoms out. âoh, andy,â you pant.
âlet me know when your ready for me to move,â he immediately replied, knowing your body needed to adjust to his size. by now, youâre used to the initial burn from your boyfriend stretching you out, but this was different. it was like you could feel him hit every crevice inside of you, feel every vein on his shaft. it was amazing.
once you start to relax against him, you tap your fingers along his spine, and he knows. he pulls out until youâre only left with the tip teasing you, before plunging back in. you dig your nails into his back at the feeling.
he continues his slow, deep strokes, your combined moans and heavy breathing filling the air. âfaster, andy,â you breathe into his ear, and thatâs all he needs to hear. he immediately starts pounding into you with a new found energy, the sound of his balls slapping against your ass bouncing off the walls. you cling to his torso, instinctively wrapping your legs around him.
the shift allows him to go deeper, dropping his head to the crook of your neck with a choked sound escaping his mouth. it mightâve been intended as a groan but his voice cracking makes it come out as more of a whimper.
you know heâs close when his rhythm starts getting sloppy. âgonna fill you,â he grunts. âgonna pump you sooo full. want it dripping out of you so i can push it back in. howâs that sound, sweetheart? you want that?â you whine as your legs get tighter around his hips, desperately grinding against his pelvis for some kind of friction against your clit. âyeah, i know,â andrew coos. âi know, love, but you gotta use your words. tell me what you want. tell me and iâll give it to you.â
âplease, andyâfuck! please, i need to cum!â
âgo ahead, cum for me. wanna feel you cum on my cock.â
your orgasm hits you like a train, hard and fast, you walls clenching around him. the feeling pushed him over the edge as well, thrusting into you one last time as you feel something warm coat your insides. you could feel his length pulsing inside you, matching his heartbeat pressed against your chest.
you were both breathing hard, coming down from your highs and feeling all the sweat on your bodies. âi love you,â andrew says, his lips close to your ear. âonly you. always you. forever.â
âi love you too,â you utter, hands still lingering on his spine. âcan you carry me to the shower?â
âof course, princess.â
authors note: writing the smut for this had me utterly stumped but fuck it we ball (can you tell iâve never experienced this with another human? rhetorical question pls donât answer that.)
© 2026 angelofthepitt [all rights reserved]