a thanksgiving to remember WS2
summary: this was the first year that will had brought someone home for thanksgiving. and his family? they loved Y/N as soon as she stepped into the house. and they LOVED her banana bread.
requests: open
masterlist
Will Smith had always said hockey prepared him for anythingâpacked arenas, roaring fans, sudden breakaways, even late-night bus rides after tough losses. But as he stood in Y/Nâs kitchen holding a bowl of mashed bananas and trying not to sneeze from the flour in the air, he realized there were still a few things the sport hadnât trained him for.
Such as baking banana bread the morning of his familyâs Thanksgiving party.
Y/N leaned over the counter, measuring sugar with the precision of someone who had watched the recipe video three times. âYou know,â she said, glancing at Will with a teasing smile, âfor someone who claims he âtotally bakes all the time,â youâre doing a lot of staring and not a lot of helping.â
âI am helping,â Will protested, gently nudging her shoulder with his. âMoral support is a very underrated form of assistance.â
âMhm. Sure it is.â
But she was smiling, and he felt it inside his chest like warmth from an oven.
He slid closer behind her and rested a light hand on her waist to peek at the recipe again. âWaitâdo we put the chocolate chips in now? Or later?â
âNow,â she said, reaching for the bag. But Will snatched it first, holding it up triumphantly.
âIâve got this part,â he declared.
She gave him a suspicious look. âDo you?â
âAbsolutely.â
He opened the bag and poured the entire thing into the mixing bowl.
âWill!â Y/N burst into laughter. âIt said one cup, not the whole bag!â
âChocolate chip overachiever,â he said proudly.
She shook her head but didnât take the bowl away. âWell⊠I mean⊠your cousins will probably love it.â
âMy cousins will love anything with chocolate. Youâve just made me the Thanksgiving hero.â
âYou made yourself the Thanksgiving chaos agent,â she corrected playfully.
He grinned and leaned down to kiss her cheekâquick and warmâbefore mixing the batter. She pretended not to melt, but he saw the tiny smile she tried to hide.
And he loved it.
â
The Smith family home was already buzzing long before they arrived. Cars lined the driveway, music drifted through the open windows, and warm light spilled out onto the porch. Will parked the car, reached over, and squeezed Y/Nâs hand gently.
âYou ready?â he asked.
She nodded, though her fingers trembled a little around the container of banana bread. âI think so. Are they⊠nice?â
âOh, theyâre very nice,â Will said. Then paused. âBut also loud. And competitive. And my Aunt might ask you seventeen questions before you even take your shoes off.â
Y/N laughed nervously. âGreat⊠totally calming.â
âYouâll be fine,â he promised, sliding an arm around her waist as they walked toward the door. âIâll be right next to you the whole time.â
And he meant it.
When they stepped inside, they were immediately greeted by a wave of warmthâcinnamon, stuffing, and the unmistakable smell of someone burning sweet potatoes.
âWILL!â someone shouted from the living room.
His younger cousins launched themselves at him like a welcoming committee of chaos. Will barely had time to let go of Y/N before he was pulled into a hug pile, laughing as he tried to keep his balance.
Y/N stood by the doorway clutching the banana bread like a shield until Will managed to untangle himself and return to her side, sliding his arm back around her like it belonged there.
âThis is Y/N,â he announced proudly.
A chorus of greetings filled the room.
âHi, sweetheart!â
âSo nice to meet you!â
âYou made banana bread? Oh, bless you.â
âYou put chocolate chips? Even better!â
Will shot her a tiny, smug look.
She elbowed him.
His aunt swooped in next, just as Will predicted. âSo how long have you two been together? Do you like hockey? Are you going to the winter family trip? Do you have siblings? Are you hungry? Did you drive safe? Do you want something to drink?â
Will squeezed Y/Nâs hand behind his back as she answered with as much patience as she could muster. He leaned down and whispered, âI warned you,â which made her laugh, easing the tension.
His family was wild, but in the warm, welcoming way that felt like home.
â
At some point, Y/N found herself ushered into the kitchen by Willâs mom, Coleen, who was stirring gravy with the confidence of a seasoned Thanksgiving general.
âSo,â she said lightly, âhowâs Will doing with all his traveling? I imagine itâs a lot.â
Y/N smiled. âIt is, but he makes time. He always checks in, even on road trips.â
âThat sounds like him.â she chuckled. âWhen he was little, he used to call me from sleepovers if he missed home. He likes having his people close.â
Y/N felt her cheeks warm at thatâespecially because Will had practically attached himself to her the moment they entered the house.
Almost as if summoned by her thoughts, Will returned to the kitchen and slid an arm around her waist from behind.
âThere you are,â he said softly. âI was looking for you.â
âTold you,â his mom teased, making Will raise a brow.
âMom, come on,â he muttered.
Y/N laughed as he guided her toward the living room again, keeping close like it was second nature.
â
Family games at the Smith house were legendary. Will had warned Y/N, but she still wasnât prepared for the level of intensity his relatives brought to Thanksgiving trivia.
Y/N sat beside Will on the floor, her shoulder pressed against his, his arm loosely draped around her. Every once in a while heâd give her a little squeeze of encouragement, especially when she answered a question right.
When she got one question faster than his cousin tyler, the room eruptedâbut tyler pointed dramatically at Will.
âWill!â he barked. âYou brought a ringer!â
Will lifted his chin proudly. âObviously.â
Y/N playfully nudged him. âIâm not a ringer. I just knew that one.â
âUh-huh. Totally innocent,â Will murmured, leaning closer and brushing a soft kiss against her temple. His family erupted in teasing âoooohs,â but he just grinned against her hair.
Y/N hid her face in her hands, laughing, but Willâs fingers brushed gently over her shoulder in a way that said youâre okay.
And she felt it.
â
When dinner was finally ready, the dining room transformed into the heart of the evening. The table was packedâturkey, stuffing, mashed potatoes, rolls, cranberry sauce, and Willâs and Y/Nâs banana bread sitting proudly near the center.
Everyone squeezed together, elbows bumping, chairs scraping, kids arguing over who got the biggest roll. Y/N found herself between Will and his youngest cousin, Lily, who immediately started asking if Y/N could braid hair better than Will could.
âDefinitely,â Y/N whispered, which made Lily giggle.
Before the meal started, Will rested his hand on the small of Y/Nâs back, leaning close.
âThis is really nice,â she murmured.
He smiled. âBetter now that youâre here.â
She gave him a soft lookâwarm, grateful, just for himâand he brushed a tiny kiss to her forehead. His dad cleared his throat loudly in mock warning.
Will pulled back, cheeks pink, but still grinning.
During the meal, conversation flowed effortlessly around them. Hockey came upâof courseâand Y/N listened as Willâs uncles argued over which of his goals had been the best so far this season.
When she chimed in with her own opinion, the table went silent for a secondâthen everyone nodded in agreement.
âYou picked the right one,â Will whispered, nudging her knee with his under the table.
âYou trained me well,â she whispered back.
The banana bread was a massive hitâso much so that Willâs dad tried to steal the remaining slices to hide for later.
âNot a chance,â Will said, shielding the container dramatically. âThis is coming home with us.â
Y/N shook her head in amusement as she leaned into his shoulder.
â
Dessert and games followed dinner, and somehow Y/N ended up in a group helping clean the kitchen while Willâs cousins begged him to go outside and shoot a mini hockey puck with them.
Will kept glancing at her as he backed toward the door, clearly torn between joining the game and not wanting to leave her alone.
âGo,â she told him, smiling. âIâm fine.â
âYou sure?â
âI promise.â
He hesitated a second longer before jogging outsideâonly to run back inside ten seconds later just to steal a quick kiss from her lips.
His family howled from the yard.
âWILL, GET BACK OUT HERE!â
He grinned at her sheepishly. âOkay, now Iâll go.â
She laughed. âGo!â
But as he left, she felt her heart swell. Even surrounded by the people he loved most, he still looked for her.
â
As the night wound down, the house grew softerâlights dimmer, voices lower, kids drowsy on the sofas. Y/N and Will found a quiet corner of the living room beside the fireplace, sitting close on the carpet as the family talked around them.
Will slid his fingers into hers, absent-mindedly tracing circles on the back of her hand with his thumb.
âYou did amazing,â he murmured.
âI survived,â she said jokingly.
âYou didnât just survive. They love you. I can tell.â
Y/N looked aroundâat his smiling cousins, his mom laughing with an aunt, his dad trying to convince someone that his gravy was superior to Willâs grandmotherâs recipe.
âTheyâre⊠really great,â she admitted softly. âLoud. But great.â
Will laughed quietly. âTheyâre a lot. But theyâre my lot.â
He leaned his shoulder against hers. âAnd Iâm glad you were here with me.â
She rested her head lightly against him. âMe too.â
A few minutes passed in peaceful silence until his mom walked by and whispered, âCuties,â which made both of them blush.
â
The drive home was calmâstreetlights glowing, soft music playing, Y/N leaning comfortably against her seat with Will holding her hand on the center console.
âThat was a good day,â she said gently.
âOne of my favorites,â Will replied, glancing at her with a soft smile. âThanks for coming. And for making banana bread. And for surviving Aunt Patty.â
âI should get a medal for that.â
âYou absolutely should.â
He lifted her hand and pressed a gentle kiss to her knuckles before placing it back on his thigh, fingers intertwined.
Y/N felt warm. Safe. Happy.
âThink your family liked me?â she asked quietly.
Will looked over at her like the answer was the easiest thing in the world.
âThey adored you.â
âAnd you?â
His voice softened. âI adore you too.â
She smiled, leaning her head back as the streetlights passed by slowly.
And Will kept holding her hand all the way home.
© allaboutmacklin 2025















