My thoughts on Code Lyoko Evolution
Okay I know this post is about 3-4 years late, but now that I’m getting back into Code Lyoko again, I decided to give my full thoughts on the noncanon season 5 titled “Evolution”
(Yes, I refuse to acknowledge it as canon. In my eyes, Code Lyoko ended at season 4. Evolution is a shitty fanfiction)
Now the biggest thing that really put me off was the fact that it was live-action. That’s always been the most critiqued thing regarding a show transitioning from animation to live action, and I will acknowledge that they gave us some good shots, but overall, I wish they stuck to animation because it looks like they were limited on what they could do (I mainly saw this with XANA’s attacks but I’ll get to that later) compared to what they could do if it was animated: character expressions, movement, lighting, a whole bunch of stuff could make a huge difference. It’s like Moonscoop said “Oh we can’t do this, so we’ll do this” without really thinking of what they could do.
Okay it’s obvious that the best scenes are when the gang is on Lyoko, which honestly kinda proves my point further. The characters are more expressive, more lively, and the action scenes are actually rather nice to watch.
The more I watched Evolution, the more I realized that the switch from animation to live action was the least of my worries.
A whole lot of stuff regarding the story didn’t seem to make sense to me. Scratch that: everything regarding XANA didn’t make sense to me. The way he was brought back was basically Moonscoop saying that they can’t really move on from XANA to another villain to keep the show interesting. I kinda get it: the show started with XANA, and by that note, it should continue with XANA. But, if you killed off your main antagonist at the end of the series, but later you want to continue the series, give it a new antagonist.
Literally XANA’s return is summed up as “XANA didn’t really die. He escaped into another supercomputer so now the Lyoko Warriors have to go into that supercomputer to defeat him.”
I’m sorry, but did that mean Franz Hopper died for nothing?
I’m sorry, that’s just really lazy.
Speaking of XANA, what happened to him? He used to be the biggest threat in the show: controlling a satellite, creating killer robots and killer music, ripping the school in half, killing Yumi on multiple occasions, taking control of William for an entire season, destroying Lyoko, rearranging the route of two trains carrying nuclear bullshit so they’ll crash into each other, controlling a bus with Ulrich inside it to crash into a nuclear power plant, sending his monsters to the real world, REVERSING GRAVITY TO SEND EVERYONE INTO SPACE.
Instead, he’s sending spectre after spectre after spectre. Yeah, they can do something, but in Evolution, they just walk around menacingly and that’s it. They don’t shoot lightning out of their hands, they don’t try to stop the warriors from escaping, they don’t try to throw anything at the warriors to immobilize them. They literally follow them until they’re cornered before deciding to attack, and that takes the ENTIRE SECOND ACT OF AN EPISODE. It might be because of XANA being weak, but even in a weakened state, XANA could cause some major havoc.
Now that we’re talking about villains, let’s talk about the secondary villain in Evolution named Lowell Tyron (I literally had to look up his first name). Compared to XANA, he’s a weak villain. He doesn’t affect the plot in any sort of way (save for the bullshit with Aelita’s mom) until the very last episode where he destroys the Cortex and tries to recruit Laura (I’ll get to her soon enough), and he mainly just sits back and lets the Ninjas (the basic equivalent to XANA’s monsters) do everything for him. I kept forgetting he was in the show until someone mentioned him. If you have a villain who doesn’t affect the plot in any way, shape, or form, then you have a bad villain no matter how good the personality is.
(He also has the typical personality of “evil scientist guy” and it’s just weak. Same with his motives. This was in 2012. You cannot have a live-action villain so cartoony unless it was intended).
I’ll admit, the Cortex is really cool, and the MegaPod is a cool vehicle.
Most of the stuff is just never explained in the show. For example, the Lyoko Warriors (Except for Jeremie and William), are embedded with codes that helped XANA come back. Where did the codes come from? I don’t know. How did they get these codes? Good question. Are they important? HELL NO! Take out the code bullshit, and literally nothing changes. “The codes are used to strengthen XANA when he gets a hold of them.” The Return to the Past strengthens XANA too. I don’t see the point in why this exists.
You have a new villain, you have a new character, you have a new area to explore, you have plot points that the original left unfinished. Why do you need this?
They also explain that the Ice and Forest sectors practically deleted themselves because of the Supercomputer being shut down for a year. I’m sorry, the Supercomputer had been shut down for A DECADE before Jeremie found it, and all of the sectors were in one piece. Plus, those were the prettiest sectors. How dare you?
The characters have gotten a huge downgrade as well. I’d have to say my favorite out of the bunch was William, and that’s saying a lot since I never liked William in the original show, although I think it’s cause I mainly feel bad for him for all of the shit he had to go through. Odd was always my favorite Lyoko Warrior, but I had to ask “Moonscoop, what did you do to my son?”
Ulrich and Yumi had it the worst of all. It’s like they took 2 steps forward and 100 steps back regarding their characters and their relationship. Most of the time, Yumi just spends her time just glaring at Ulrich, and their main interaction was the two of them fighting that’s the central plot of an episode. This is exactly why I never shipped these two. They always got into fights over nothing, and instead of talking about a misunderstanding, they just spite each other more.
Now we’re getting to the newest bitch on the block, the bitch that everyone hates more than Sissi (her character just made me appreciate Sissi): Laura Gauthier. I never liked Laura. I’ll say that right now. When Odd first called her “Mrs. Einstein,” I believe I can say for the entire fandom that we said “Odd Della Robbia, you better take that shit back.”
Swear to God, Laura pissed me off more than Sissi and William combined. I could not stand her whenever she was onscreen, and she gave off the vibes of being a Mary Sue. How the fuck could she fix the Supercomputer, a device she has NEVER SEEN BEFORE, and create a program that makes her immune to the Return to the Past WITH JEREMIE LOOKING OVER HER SHOULDER!? She practically forced herself into the group, and was a huge red flag, and that’s not even involving her just being a fucking bitch, especially to Aelita. That comment about Anthea just made me want to slap her. I just wanted her written off of the show. I didn’t care how, just get rid of her.
Laura also gets a pass for doing shit the other warriors got kicked out of the group for doing. Her father wanted to take her out of Kadic (Good riddance), and she automatically shows him the Supercomputer in an attempt to let her stay. I don’t give a shit what her reasoning is; that is the biggest fucking rule of being a Lyoko Warrior. AND SHE GETS A PASS FOR IT! ASIDE FROM AELITA, EVERYONE INCLUDING JEREMIE VOTED TO KEEP HER IN THE GROUP! YEAH, SHE WAS IMMUNE TO THE RETURN TO THE PAST, BUT AS SHOWN IN “MUTINY” THEY REVERSED THAT SO WHAT’S THE PROBLEM!? SCREW TYRON BEING THE SECONDARY VILLAIN! THAT TITLE BELONGS TO LAURA!
I’m not even involving shipping bullshit. Take that into account with my criticism.
The show didn’t even end well. It ends on a shitty cliffhanger. Jeremie creates another virus to put in Tyron’s computer so it could destroy XANA, but Tyron shuts down the computer before the virus could finished downloading. The show ends with Jeremie basically saying that the virus will take effect when Tyron turns on his supercomputer again.
JEREMIE BELPOIS WHAT THE FUCK DOES THAT SOLVE!?
They’re basically playing a waiting game, and I’m just wondering why they would think Tyron would turn his Supercomputer back on with the knowledge that they go inside it? If I was him, I’d keep it closed for good. Besides, XANA can’t do shit because the Supercomputer is off. Even without the virus, you guys still won so what’s the issue here?
Code Lyoko Evolution is a fucking fanfiction and I refuse to acknowledge it as canon. The original series ended perfectly, and the plot points it left hanging could be interpreted among fans. Some people like it, and I’ll admit they took some creative liberties with it and experimented with live action, but the story just falls flat, the characters have gotten worse than their original counterparts, the new characters are bad, and the only good thing I can say about the show is the CGI has immensely improved. Hell that’s the only good thing people can say about Evolution.
Honestly, just watch Evolution for the CGI scenes, but aside from that, you can ignore it completely. It’s not worth your time. I’d prefer Evolution not exist, but if it has to, I’ll make a post about how I would rewrite it. Take this post with a grain of salt if you actually like Evolution. Just know that I don’t, and I wish it didn’t exist.