...so obviously from prior posts on the topic, I don’t truck with KNM-style rosatrice theory myself. oh, I’m curious about it, but I can’t watch the whole video series, and the written transcripts are missing some really important parts, and from what I’ve seen the necessary logic is much more twisted than the idiosyncratic-but-characteristic take on identity which has traditionally been the main stumbling block to taking Clair at her word.
but I’ve come to conclude, recently, that the existence of such a theory is really valuable and important in Umineko metaphysics, even to Confessional partisans like me. or, to say it another way, it’s valuable and important to a Confessional partisan like me precisely because our perspective will see it as a wrong answer.
this was easy for me to miss until recently. but what changed my mind was revisiting ep5′s inhuman teaparty, and the gambit Battler pulled there after getting gold privileges. because whether you believe in an orthodox 'trice model or a heterodox one, Battler’s countertheory against Erika deliberately avoids actually using that formulation; he instead constructs “the man from 19 years ago” as a separate entity (himself).
why?
simple: because his whole goal, at that point, is reviving Beatrice while preventing Bern and Erika - those vindictive, rando gawkers with no connection to her - from reaching Beato’s heart and treating it cruelly.
so he recreates the superposition - the uncertainty over the truth - without giving anyone who’s just watching a hint for what’s really going on.
isn’t that why he’s so concerned about ep6 - about whether the resurrected Beato’s solution to the logic error is okay to use openly? ep7 follows immediately after ep6 precisely because, if you subscribe to mainline theory, ep6′s final red truth exposed to the goats the ambiguous hiding-place in which Beatrice III ‘exists’ (as post-release fan discourse sadly bore out), and so what could ep7 be but her funeral?
so now we have plenty of people with love for ‘that’ Beatrice, whose devotion has probably kept the Umineko fandom alive ten years on... but also plenty of people with no love for her who can deny her magic regardless based on something they just Googled. this problem has been exacerbated by r07′s... insufficient resolve to keep the catbox firmly locked as time has gone on; although he’s managed to avoid giving an explicit “answer” to anything, he’s still given the Confessions more broad availability (via inclusion in the manga and Umineko Saku), and recent adaptations have spilled certain other beans as well (like the manga making Will’s “last rites” more explicit than they were in the VN).
so what does that mean? if we take anti-magic toxin metaphysics literally, have we re-killed Beatrice by opening the coffin and revealing her true form to the world?
well, not quite. and the reason it’s “not quite” is precisely because, like Battler at the climactic final showdown of ep5, KnownNoMore somehow stepped up and offered a conflicting explanation.
and it doesn’t matter how twisted the logic is. it doesn’t matter how much of a stretch is necessary to accept it. what matters is that it contradicts the Confessional explanation without contradicting the red. what matters is that it once again makes it impossible to declare, with certainty, that the cat in the box is dead. and, as Battler’s ep5 success and takeover of ep6 proved, that’s the uncertainty in which a witch like Beatrice can survive.
what’s more, by being a theory that centers around a denial of ep6′s core revelation - by denying the very moment where many readers finally saw ‘that’ Beatrice and couldn’t accept her - it acts as a magnet for those readers. it prevents them from acknowledging the Confessional Beatrice, and therefore denies them access to her heart... which was always meant, ever since those bottle fragments were written, to be saved for those able to understand and accept her, and remain, to everyone else, the mysterious, unknowable, incomprehensible heart of "exactly a witch”.
was that KnownNoMore’s true aim? not a true argument in favor of Rosa as Beatrice the Golden, but rather an attempt to throw a cloak around a certain person’s form after Umineko’s denouement left her too exposed? with a username like that, it’s certainly possible. and yet, it’s equally possible to read it as the taunt many assumed it to be: a supercilious suggestion that Umineko’s readerbase had stopped thinking, and may be about to find themselves, far from the peak of Mount Purgatory, "waking up, stupefied, in a dark and unfamiliar place”.
...well, there may be no way to know for sure, one way or the other. perhaps that’s the most appropriate answer, anyway. here in the realm of witches, at least, it seems there’s value to not being quite so sure about things.
I’m curious about your thoughts for ch39, especially since there’s a potential reunion between doumeki and yashiro coming in the horizon, and that prospect flustered doumeki so much. I’m particularly stung by doumeki referring to yashiro as “that person”, because it doesn’t seem like he’s doing that out of disdain and more like out of heartbreak (and perhaps quiet acceptance of his situation?) I also wonder who at yashiro’s side is still in contact with doumeki.
Sorry, I got several anons asking about my opinion on chapter 39, but I’m really not good at writing down my general thoughts on a chapter. I find it way easier to discuss specific questions, or details that stand out, so I’ll focus on those parts of your ask.
In general, referring to someone as “this person” or “that person” is not that unusual in Japanese, and in most cases it can be simply translated as “he”, “her” or “they”. So Doumeki’s “that person” probably stands out a bit more in English than "ano hito” does in Japanese. It’s also not the first time that Doumeki refers to Yashiro that way. He did so in volume 3, for example, where he thought, “I want to protect that person.” But in Japanese, too, the normal and polite way would be to use the person’s name or title, of course. The thing is, Doumeki can’t refer to Yashiro as Kashira/Boss anymore, because Doumeki’s boss is someone else now. And if he ever calls him Yashiro-san that would be such a big event in his case, there’s no way it would happen in a minor situation like here. On the day Doumeki’s mouth forms the magic words “Yashiro-san” for the first time, the screams of the Japanese Saezuru fandom will probably be heard all around the globe. XD
Anyway, in Japanese (as in English) saying “that person” could suggest that you don’t like or trust the person you’re talking about, because it does sound distant, but you could also use “ano hito” if you fondly remember someone, so it really depends on the situation. In Doumeki’s case both examples would make sense. He could be angry at Yashiro, or he could remember him as someone who meant a lot to him in the past. But honestly, I don’t think he’s angry after all these years, and I also don’t believe for a second that he has emotionally closed the door on Yashiro and is now quietly accepting his fate. So I simply took Doumeki’s choice of words as a) Sensei teasing us (She likes to keep things a little vague instead of stating the obvious and she knows we know who Doumeki is talking about.) and b) Doumeki being secretive because Kamiya is in the car right behind him and could be eavesdropping. After all, Doumeki has been very careful to not reveal anything about his past since he started working for Tsunakawa.
Regarding your question about who at Yashiro’s side could still be in contact with Doumeki, I would say Nanahara and/or Amou are the most likely candidates. But it’s clear that Doumeki isn’t talking to either of them in the phone scene. Judging from the informal way he speaks it must be either Chestnut, or (hopefully not) Inami.
Finally filled out the OC meme from a while back!!! ☺️☺️💕💕 I answered each question for both nic and lenny: https://docs.google.com/document/d/1mqdKsvBgVj7lDg0GYO-u04IVv0OiXFxIyFxI2KiLSFU/edit?usp=sharing
What’s their favorite beverage - alcoholic and/or non-alcoholic? Nic: herbal/floral teas, soy milk, red wine Lenny: sparkling water, sodas,
He's extremely kind. Not just any sort of kind, but he's generous and extremely understanding. He puts you first, and he's extremely selfless. I kind of like the fact that he's able to treat you like a princess while allowing you to develop in your own way, gently guiding you through responsibility, and seeing you off as you take flight into the future, I guess. He might not have been there every step of the time, but he makes sure you're clear about every single thing and then watches you take off. And I'm really glad he's there when he was.
Thinking of yourself as a separate entity can reduce anxiety, while also kicking up some major benefits for your confidence and determination.
Hecked up that 33 years after the Rokkenjima Massacre, Dave decided to name this technique after Bruce Wayne, and not after its true and proper inventor (RIP) who took it to levels this article can’t even comprehend