what do you think of metal beak from legend of the guardians: the owls of ga'hoole not doing anything until the climax?
DID SOMEONE SAY GUARDIANS OF GA’HOOLE
I’ve been summoned ( I say this like this ain’t in my askbox 😭 )
I sincerely apologise for the essay you’re about to receive .
If the buildup and reveal was done better , this could have worked . He had potential to be a great “narrative opposite” to Ezylryb same way Kludd is to Soren but that’s not done well enough .
——— Beware . An Essay 😨 ———
I think they did this to maintain the mystery and suspense around Metalbeak , but I don’t think it was done to its full potential . It’s quite hard to make animals intimidating , especially owls since most of the population sees them as weird cute little creatures .
Despite not doing anything until the climax , too much of his design was revealed too early .
[ What purpose does and should he serve in the story other than being the High Tyto ? ]
For a character that was meant to be “unreachable” and almost god-like for most of the Pure Ones , his reveal wasn’t as intimidating as it could have been .
Lyze / Ezylryb can pose as an interesting mirror to Metalbeak . Afterall , they’re the sworn enemies ever since their battle damaged half of Surtr’s face . The big confrontation is between Lyze and Surtr , before Soren interfers to save his teacher .
Surtr’s defeat at Soren’s talons could have meant a lot more if that parallel was stronger . A passing of the torch to the next protector and “true righteousness” . Which subsequently makes the implication of Kludd’s picking up of the “Metalbeak” title much more interesting .
[ So what does he do in the movies ]
Longer ? He really does nothing . He barely even commands his forces , Nyra calls the bats , she flies formation with the soldiers . He ???? He sits and he fits ig ?
I fear he’s the definition of sit still look pretty without the pretty .
[ How to improve his reveal ? ]
Keep his reveal slow . I’m thinking “The Ritual” ( horror movie ) kind of suspense and slow .
Don’t show his face so early . We are first introduced to his concept with Eglantine wearing a little leaf beak to playfight with Soren . That’s all we need for a while .
No face just actions when he’s speaking to the spy Allomere . Talons prodding at coal ( parallel to Ezylryb’s first proper introduction in his hollow to who he really is ) Sharpening a battle claw and moving his mask .
When Nyra introduces the recruits to him , he doesn’t approach Kludd . No full face . Only a shadow and eyes + mask lit by the torches and backlighting .
He could be unmoving , it’s unsettling to see a living being look dead . It can very easily imply something off and create unease . It should be alive but it doesn’t look it etc. Make use of owls being able to spin their heads 180 . He stalks enemies and allies just the same .
The owlets cower just the same , there is something very wrong about Surtr .
When he is fully revealed , it’s always related to the shadows , he comes out into the light etc. Launches a stealth attack . If they’re gonna make him a dark colored sooty owl , make the most of him and the darkness !!!!
Finally . Don’t be afraid of showing a scar . A healed scar unless extremely jarring doesn’t need to be hidden . We don’t ever get to see a “full reveal” of Metalbeak in the movies , his actual face under the mask is only shown in the artbooks .
[ How to increase his involvement without decreasing Nyra’s ? ]
The Pure Ones are a cult with a strong militia first and foremost . Make them strategise .
While Nyra is the General ( ordering and fighting alongside the troops makes sense ) , Surtr should not be absent when it comes to reports , planning etc. He is the “highest up” .
Show short quick cuts of Guardians being ambushed by Pure Ones after careful planning from Surtr and Nyra .
Show the Guardians struggle from losing their limited number of highly trained warriors . It doesn’t have to be in high detail or whole sequences , just quick shots / flashes of Guardians being taken out .
Surtr’s command in the final fight shouldn’t be a desperate / angry cry , he should be cold / composed .
Overall , I think this is the direction that they tried to take with Surtr / Metalbeak but didn’t achieve to it’s full effect . His lack of involvement in the story’s events doesn’t feel justified and his position as High Tyto doesn’t hold enough weight .
If u’ve read this far thank youu !! :} Feel free to yap back in the comments or to add on etc.