Hello! I know you liked "Bucky Barnes: The Winter Soldier", and I'd really like to know your take on it, cuz all I've seen were complaints about how awful it is. I haven't picked that title up because of all the bad opinions out there. Thank you!
Hi! Thanks so much for your question. (Apologies for taking so long to respond; I’ve been on a family vacation.) I really appreciate having an opportunity to talk about this series, which I absolutely loved, but which—as you say—was not at all popular. Here’re some of the things I loved about it:
1) I really liked the storytelling approach.Ales Kot, the writer of Bucky Barnes: The Winter Soldier, brings a very unique storytelling style to his comics. It's—as I’ve described elsewhere—psychedelic, holistic, and ofttimes stream-of-consciousness. His stories regularly involve multiple threads that don’t come together until the story’s denouement, and their meaning can be difficult to decipher even then. Sometimes a story that you think is about one thing turns out to be about something entirely different. Sometimes various stories that you think are different turn out to be secretly the same. It’s not everyone’s jam, and I get that, but I love it.
2) I really liked the approach to Bucky Barnes.Over and above everything else, BB:TWS is—for me—a totally new take on Bucky Barnes. (The first wholly new take on Bucky since Brubaker, imho.) But more than that, it’s a new take on the very concept of Bucky Barnes. It’s not just about Bucky, but about the idea of Bucky and about what that idea really represents. Without giving too much away about the plot, the series presents an intimate examination of the concept of the perpetual soldier, and through that examination a sociological deconstruction of the consequences of war (both personal and global). Bucky Barnes is the soldier who never stops, and for whom the war never ends, but in this story that role does not go unexamined. He is forced to confront the consequences of neverending war: not in the abstractly heroic fashion that anti-heroes and reformed villains typically address their past and future actions (by angsting about them), but in concrete terms of honest self reflection. In BB:TWS, Bucky has to think about what unending battle actually means for him. For his soul. For his future. And through him, we—citizens of a perpetually warmongering society—are offered the opportunity to think about what unending battle means for us.
On the one hand, Bucky Barnes: The Winter Soldier is about Bucky learning to take on the role of the Man on the Wall. On the other hand, however, it is about so much more, and I love it.
3) Marco Rudy’s art is stunning.One of the big complaints about this series—that I have seen—is that the art is uneven, and in some places it is (as is the case with many comic book series), but the majority of the art was done by Marco Rudy and that man is a genius. Even if the idea of brilliant sociopolitical commentary does nothing for you, I’d at least recommend giving the first volume a chance for the sheer joy of looking at Marco Rudy do his glorious thing
I hope you find this helpful. Thanks again for the question, and happy reading!













