This is gonna be probably a bit more difficult. So my idea is Error x Reader x Nox. I don’t have references this time but I can explain it as much as I can to help give you some context.
Basically Error is there because he wanted to destroy the AU but reader convinced him not to and he ends up being a roommate who eventually crushes on Reader. Nox likes to visit Reader and also crushes on them. The two are VERY well aware of the other’s feelings towards reader and become rivals (I imagine every visit is met with a glare). Reader loves both of them but is quite shy about it. They eventually find out try to woo them with their own unique ways.
It’s an idea I have for my fanfic that I want it to end in a poly relationship! Think you are up for the challenge?! Two tsunderes vs one simp reader!!! Good luck!!!
The Glitch and the Coffee Addict (Error X Reader X Nox)
Hehehehe, I'm going to have fun with this one. Hope you enjoy! I did alter it slightly, hope you don’t mind-
Note: Both skeletons are simping for the reader, not each other. I have to say this everyone time because people are weird.
When a destructive, glitching, seemingly aggressive skeleton appeared in your living room claiming to destroy this “accursed AU,” you weren’t too bothered by it, after all, you had a house full of skeletons and odd situations across the street. You just sighed and approached the monologuing skeleton, tapping his shoulder to get his attention. He quite literally jumped and turned to glare at you, opening his mouth to say something when you shushed him.
“Look, I dunno what your deal is but could you not destroy a bajillion lives cause you feel like it? Okay? Thanks,” You then just, walked away, Error had never had an encounter like this, one where you so confidently approached him and just asked not to be destroyed before going about your day. He was baffled, a little annoyed but intrigued. He decided to stick around, and see how things would play out.
And that is how you got a powerful skeleton as a roommate, a little moody at times but overall nice company. You wish you could say the same when Nox came over, those two would always get into some sort of competition and every time, you had to break it up before they destroyed your house again.
You loved them, you really did, you just wish they’d stop having glaring matches whenever you left the room because yes, you DID notice them. As you thought over this while playing a game, the two in question were fighting each other to the death within said game. You really wish you kept PVP off.
“Don’t you DARE steal my coffee beans you brute,” Error rolled his eyes, or at least what’s equivalent to them.
“Then YOU stop taking my crops, addict,” You sighed.
“Could you two please stop fighting, I’m trying to do something,” They both fall silent as you decided to go through with your plan, if you couldn’t express your feelings in the real world, then you’ll do it through the medium of game. You gathered all the resources you needed and glanced at the two of them before taking a deep breath.
“Hey, could you two meet up at my house?” They were immediately on their way as you had what you needed. As their characters stood in front of you, you take out the rings and marry both of them with the help of mods. Your face is red as you silently wondered what their reaction would be.
“. . . What?”
“. . . What?" They both wondered out loud in bewilderment, you take another deep breath to calm your nerves.
“I um… I like you both, a lot. And I was wondering if we could maybe… Start a relationship together?” They’re both silent for a bit before they both just poof in your room.
“Well, if it’s you I suppose I could tolerate the glitch,” Error huffed.
“Fine, I won’t t-t-take his soul, at least for a while,” You smile gently, happy to have finally confessed your feelings for the two skeletons.
