¡HELLO! ¡It feels like we've been here for 10 years, and Tumblr reminded me again! XP
And again, I don't have anything planned for today, but I'll think of something for later. Maybe a DTYIS, but we'll see.
If I miss it again next year, it'll become an annual thing...
In the meantime, like last year, I'll share some of the things I'm working on. Although we will see if two of the three end up being completed this year /(>u<)\
¿Should we bet? Just kidding. Hehehe.
For now, that's all, and a big thank you to everyone. Thank you to those who came, those who will come, and those who have always been here.
Thank you.
Thanks for following me and have a great weekend (ouo)/
I decided to be funny and ask ChatGBT theories of who they think is Doll's father cause I wanted a laugh after I finished chapter one of my story, and I decided to share it here!
Grab popcorn, pull up a chair, and lets play Maury!
First off:
ChatGBT's Reason(s):
🎪 THE CONTENDER: DOLL (aka Freckles)
Visual Clues:
Light blue eyes (almost identical to Ciel's)
Ash-blond/light brown hair
Pale skin
Hidden facial scar over left eye
Unique eye shape and long lashes — notable in both her circus and casual looks
Personality:
Innocent, devoted, emotionally sensitive
Shows strong loyalty to Joker and Kelvin (aka "Father"), but begins to question her reality
Desperately wants love and family
Background:
An orphan raised in Baron Kelvin’s twisted "circus family"
Trained to perform and serve as entertainment
Possibly abducted like the other children during the cult kidnappings
💣 THEORY: DOLL IS RELATED TO THE PHANTOMHIVE BLOODLINE
And not just in spirit. I’m talking biological half-sibling to the real Ciel Phantomhive. Yep. Here’s the case:
🧬 EVIDENCE 1: EYE COLOR & SHAPE
Doll has very specific eye features: pale blue irises, almost the exact tone and roundness as both real!Ciel and fake!Ciel (our main protagonist).
🧪 Genetics-wise: Pale blue eyes are extremely rare — the only other characters with that specific tone and softness in Kuroshitsuji are:
Ciel
Elizabeth Midford
(Maybe Soma, but his are warmer-toned)
This suggests Doll may share a maternal link, or a paternal Phantomhive connection.
🧬 EVIDENCE 2: SIMILARITIES TO REAL!CIEL
Let’s pull out the manga receipts: Real!Ciel (the twin) and Doll:
Are both emotionally intense yet quiet
Both mask their vulnerabilities (Real!Ciel behind charm and arrogance, Doll behind makeup and costumes)
Both show manipulative potential, though Doll does it out of desperation
Both have a strong emotional attachment to "family" (Doll to Joker, Real!Ciel to Vincent and his brother)
Their facial structures are very similar, especially in anime: narrow jaw, delicate nose, large irises, slight under-eye puffiness.
Also—Doll’s left eye is scarred, and Real!Ciel had trauma centered around the cult involving eyes and sacrifice. Possible parallel?
🧬 EVIDENCE 3: AGE MATCHES UP
Doll appears to be around 13-14 years old, the same age as the twins. She could be:
A third, illegitimate sibling
A half-sibling via Vincent Phantomhive’s side-fling (c’mon, that man was too pretty to not have made mistakes)
Or a cousin if born from Frances Midford’s extended family
It’s VERY possible Vincent had a child with someone outside of marriage — maybe a servant, prostitute, or cult member who survived. Doll being "dumped" at the circus fits this tragic Phantomhive pattern.
🧬 EVIDENCE 4: DOLL’S MYSTERIOUS ORIGINS
Unlike most other circus members, we never get concrete info on Doll’s backstory. She just... appeared one day and was "adopted" by Joker and Father.
Compare that to:
Beast: has a hinted childhood backstory
Dagger: grew up with Joker
Jumbo: same
Doll? Blank slate. It’s suspicious. Especially when you realize Yana Toboso doesn’t do things by accident. That open-endedness = invitation for future plot bombs.
🧬 EVIDENCE 5: AESTHETIC SYMBOLISM
Yana Toboso uses mirroring all the time:
Ciel vs. Real!Ciel
Sebastian vs. Ash
Joker vs. Vincent (both charismatic manipulators with a twisted "family")
Doll often appears as a "softer mirror" of Ciel:
They both wear masks (literal and emotional)
Both want love but hide behind roles (Earl/Circus Doll)
Both are used by adults for darker agendas
If Ciel represents repressed trauma and revenge, Doll represents suppressed innocence and yearning.
⚰️ THE MURDER BOARD CONCLUSION
🧬 IN THE CASE OF "WHO IS DOLL’S REAL FAMILY?"
🧑⚖️ The Maury Test Results Are In…
“Vincent Phantomhive… you ARE the father!”
Or at least the uncle, depending on how wild Yana wants to get with the Midford/Phantomhive entanglements.
BONUS CRACK THEORIES (but lowkey possible):
Doll is a twin who was separated at birth (triplet situation??)
Doll is Frances Midford’s illegitimate daughter, making her Lizzy’s secret half-sister
Doll is an experimental clone or child of the cult, meant to mimic Ciel (because eye color and ritual magic go hand-in-hand here)
🎭 Final Word:
Doll’s mystery, design, and symbolism are way too intentional for her to be a throwaway side character. She mirrors the Phantomhive twins too well, and her “nameless” backstory SCREAMS hidden nobility or bloodline relevance.
I’d bet the devil’s contract: Doll is a hidden Phantomhive.
Now we just wait for Yana to drop that DNA test arc. 🍿
Pretty fucking funny, makes me feel like I'm reliving Vampire Knight after the reveal Yuki and Kaname are siblings after we were forced to ship them.
But my question would be what the fuck happened for Doll to be taken away? Also does that mean Rachel or Vincent or Vincent's side piece burned Doll and abandoned her??
Okay Next!
ChatGBT's Reason(s):
🪦 THEORY: Doll is a Bizarre Doll/Hybrid Created by the Undertaker
🧬 VERSION A: Biological Daughter of Undertaker
Undertaker, like Vincent, once loved or used a human woman.
This woman could've died tragically, perhaps related to the cult or Phantomhives.
Undertaker, who is obsessed with resurrecting the dead with a “soul that smiles”, may have revived Doll using early methods before his tech was refined.
🔍 Supporting Clues:
Undertaker has a record of fathering children (Vincent).
He shows a softness toward children, especially those suffering.
Doll, unlike other circus members, seems more emotionally unstable—possibly a side effect of being an imperfect revival.
Her name is literally “Doll.”
She doesn’t talk much about her past — could be due to memory tampering or lack of real memories.
🧟 VERSION B: Bizarre Doll Based on a Real Child
Doll is not “naturally born” but was instead created using the body of a dead girl (perhaps even someone Vincent cared for).
She is a test run for Undertaker’s future projects (like the Four Siblings from Weston and the German military dolls).
May have had her memories implanted or fabricated.
Sent to the circus as a way to hide or test her behavior among other broken people.
🔍 Supporting Clues:
Her emotional expressions are sometimes exaggerated and performative.
Her sudden violence, then immediate remorse (e.g., when attacking Beast), could indicate instability or broken programming.
She survives things other humans might not—falls, fights, trauma—just like other Bizarre Dolls.
If she was an experiment, the circus would be the perfect place to monitor her, especially under Baron Kelvin’s influence (who was in contact with Undertaker).
🧛 VERSION C: She's a Hybrid (Biological + Artificial)
Doll might be Undertaker’s biological child who died young—possibly in the same tragedy as the cult ritual—and was brought back.
He may have combined soul fragments, cinematic records, or body parts to restore her.
This would explain her strong emotions, but also her lack of history and near-mechanical focus on loyalty (“Father said this... Joker said that...”).
🧠 THEMATIC CLUES
Symbol/Clue Meaning
Her name: “Doll” Meta hint she is not entirely human
Circus arc A "stage" for observing her among other broken people
Her strange eyes Match Ciel’s, hinting either Phantomhive or Bizarre Doll lineage
No family mention A narrative void — classic setup for hidden origins
Vincent’s smile obsession = Undertaker’s smile obsession Possibly learned behavior or programmed as a trigger
🗓️ TIMELINE THOUGHTS
If she’s around Ciel’s age (13–14), she would’ve been born shortly before or during the time Vincent was active as Watchdog.
Vincent dies when Ciel is 10.
The cult fire happens at the same time—this could also be when Doll died or was harvested.
If Undertaker was already collecting cinematic records, he may have used that event as a source.
She ends up in the circus soon after, where Baron Kelvin’s twisted obsession intersects with Undertaker’s experiments.
👥 CHARACTER MIRRORS
DollUndertakerHidden identity (not just a circus girl)Hidden motives and identityEmotionally erraticFascinated by emotions in the deadHyper-loyal to found familyLoyal to Phantomhives, especially VincentFeels out of placeEternal outsider to both life and death
🤯 WILD CONNECTIONS (Crack But Fun)
If Doll was made to resemble Vincent, she could’ve been an attempt at creating a daughter in his image—a creepy homage.
If Doll’s soul is made from someone else’s cinematic records, she could be a patchwork of memories.
🔚 CONCLUSION
The Undertaker theory turns Doll from a minor tragic figure into a major narrative symbol:
She could be the prototype for the Bizarre Doll army.
She could represent Undertaker’s obsession with family and grief.
She could tie the circus, the cult, and the Phantomhives together as the ultimate consequence of everyone's sins.
So. . . It is correct in some way with Undertaker remaking Doll, but all I'm thinking is that means Undertaker WATCHED DOLL DIE!
. . . Unless that explains why we haven't yet seen any scars showing how Doll died like with other Bizarre Dolls--
Next dude!
Love this GIF btw it looks like he wasn't aware the camera was recording on this show and he just turned XD
ChatGBT's Reason(s):
👨⚖️ “You ARE the Father!” — Viscount Druitt: Doll’s Biological Daddy Scandal
Doll: “All my life, I thought I was just some orphan in a circus…”
Ciel: “But that white-blond hair, the obsession with drama, and flair for theatrics? You were doomed from the start.”
🧬 THE CASE FILE: VISCOUNT DRUITT
Known Traits:
Extremely vain.
Notoriously promiscuous.
Frequently involved in shady, elite sex trafficking and underground parties.
High social standing — keeps things hush-hush.
Fancies delicate, unique beauty and oddities.
Doll:
Pale complexion, platinum-blonde hair (almost white).
Emotionally expressive, performative.
Feels like she doesn’t belong anywhere — not with nobles, not with commoners.
Dresses up, plays characters, loves performing.
Has a hidden side (scar, trauma, rage under softness).
Strong sense of “pretending” or “being on stage.”
💃 THE THEORY: One Night at a Masquerade Ball…
Picture this:
A lower-class young woman, possibly a beautiful maid, opera singer, or acrobat, is invited to a secret masked ball hosted by the Viscount.
She’s dazzled. Maybe she thinks she’s found a way out of poverty.
He flirts, seduces her — she's disposable in his eyes.
She ends up pregnant. He pays her off or disappears.
She dies giving birth (or is taken out for knowing too much).
Baby ends up in the hands of the Kelvin Orphanage.
Years later? That baby’s wearing a wig and walking a tightrope.
“You are the product of powdered silk sheets and powdered lies.”
🧾 Evidence Breakdown — The Scandalous Paternity Breakdown
Trait Doll Druitt Notes
Platinum blond hair ✅ ✅ White hair? That’s Viscount DNA working overtime.
Theatrical tendencies ✅ ✅ Doll’s circus flair mirrors Druitt’s flair for the dramatic.
Delicate face, long lashes ✅ ✅ Definitely suspicious.
Manipulated by nobles ✅ ✅ Like father, like pawn.
Hidden trauma / secrets ✅ ✅ Doll hides her scar; Druitt hides his crimes.
Strong sense of “performance” ✅ ✅ Life is a stage for both of them.
🎭 Why It Weirdly Works
Doll being noble by blood but raised in the gutter mirrors Ciel’s own paradox.
Would give her personal motive for vengeance against the aristocracy beyond the circus deaths.
The irony of a monster who objectifies women creating someone who now seeks to rip the mask off the system is poetic justice.
The tragedy? Doll’s father is a monster in a powdered wig.
. . .Huh-
I both hate and love this
So obviously ChatGBT knows of Doll but struggle writing her in any way.
There were other parts of the prompt with honorable mentions like Kevil (ew-) and "a maid in the Phantomhive family" and kept trying to somehow still tie the Phantomhives with her so I stopped it's rambles.
