I love your ideas for the silver keys, I think AC-Fairy Tail decided that Hisui and other wizards would be the user of majority of silver keys while Natsu and Yukino hold the Zodaic. Natsu has Aquarius, Libra, Virgo, Taurus, Loke, Taurus, Aries and Ophiuchus. While Yukino has Capricorn, Sagittarius, Pisces, Gemini and Scorpio.
I just can’t bear to separate Ophiuchus from Yukino, man. Her summoning that snake at the GMG was too iconic for me to get her out of Yukino’s contract. Natsu definitely gets Taurus, Loke, and Aries, although I’m not sure if Libra or Virgo is his style, AU or not.
If I were the one writing this, I’d go on a much slower route with collecting or even introducing the gold keys at all. They are supposed to be the only ones of their kind in the entire damn world (and in canon, all 13 of them just happen to be floating around Fiore, one country???). I’d leave Natsu with silver keys and slowly collecting more as he traveled, getting gold ones so rarely that you can’t imagine him having all 12 at any point. That is, after all, what’d make it worthy of being a life goal, as opposed to them just falling into canon Lucy’s lap.
Also no offense to Zeref but [ axes Zeref ]. Axe-ing the dragon parents plot too, because as tired of dragons as I am, I’m taking any chance I can to avoid having to deal with them any more. You know what, fuck Acnologia too. The only long-term goal I’d keep from the original is the drama behind Natsu being a demon without knowing it.
Gray and Lucy, Natsu’s best friends, both use holy magic. Imagine if, after finding out the secret, they have a crisis because they’ve been friends with a demon the whole time, and they test it out while he’s asleep and their holy magic burns him the way demons do? Natsu ends up with a small scar he doesn’t remember getting the next morning. Is their friendship with Natsu wrong, or is their desire to kill demons wrong?
In canon, the way Lucy and Taurus met seems to have been in some field. No big “finding the key” thing, Lucy just walked up on a horny bull man as far as I can tell. So I’m capitalizing on Celestial Spirits manifesting in the human world by themselves, which allows for spirits like Aquarius, Pisces, and Cetus to be actual hostile entities. And while we’re at it, that’s probably how Natsu and Taurus met--Natsu beating Taurus in a fight and becoming partners with him.
Imagine Pisces, two enormous flying fish, circling the sky over an area they’re about to destroy with a flood? Make ‘em almost as terrifying as Ophiuchus, doesn’t it?













