It’ll Always Be You And Him
Pairings: Avani x Charli, Charli x Madi
Warnings: Jealousy, Angst, One Sided
Summary: Charli has feelings for a familiar tiktok friend, but her eyes are only set on her brown haired boyfriend.
———
Charli had love for many different things, each being a different kind.
There was her love for her parents. She felt as she could be herself around them, and not have to put on a mask. It was strong.
There was her love for her sister. She was truly her best friend, and had been all of her life. She trusted her with everything, and wouldn't trade her for anything. It was unbreakable.
There was her love for her supporters and fans. They helped build back up her confidence, as many people were shooting it down. It was compassionate.
There was her love for Madi and Gemma. They were just as much family as her blood relatives were, and sometimes felt more so than them. If anyone ever hurt her or even looked as they were going to, they did everything in their power to make sure she was okay. It was heartwarming.
There was her old love for Chase. She felt safe in his arms when he held her. He made her feel content at any situation. And even though he hurt her in the worst possible way, she would always have a piece of it left over for him. It was untouchable.
Then there was her love for Avani.
Ever since they met and exploded the media, they became quite close.
The public caught on and soon started making their friendship known, them now being one of the most popular friendships on the app.
But it was different than that.
She felt a different tingle run through her spine, then when Madi touched her. She felt safer in her arms, then when Gemma held her at late nights. She felt content. She didn't know what to call it.
So now here she was sitting on her couch beside Dixie, with Avani basically on top of Anthony on the other.
Anthony was quite a kind person, and Charli liked him actually. He treated Avani well by what she told her. He was the type of guy to run in a road with zooming cars passing by, and help someone to get out.
Avani deserved him.
As likable as he was to everyone, including the brunette, she couldn't help feel the unfamiliar feeling stream through her veins.
She hated being tagged in at least fifty videos a day with Avani and Anthony visibly drooling for each other. She hated dragging her eyes over every trace his finger left on the exposed parts of skin, being shown on her body.
She hated the urge to be the one holding Avani in her arms.
Knocking herself out of her thoughts, the door opened revealing the last guests Madi and Addison.
Dixie stood up to stand beside Addison, kissing her on the forehead as she greeted her.
Madi took Dixie's spot beside Charli, slinging her arm around her shoulder. "Missed ya babes." Madi placed a kiss on Charli's cheek.
"You too lovely."
After a while everyone decided to play a quiet game on spin the bottle, just kissing instead of doing the whole closet thing, as they all wanted to be in each other's presence.
The first two rounds went by slow.
Dixie and Addison.
Addison and Madi.
Charli saw the jealousy flicker in Dixie's eyes, just as much as she saw the satisfaction once it broke apart.
Madi spinned the bottle, quite hard but not where the bottle moved from its position.
The bottle passed everyone in the circle at least twice before it started slowing down. Charli's breath hitched as she saw the bottle stop and land on her figure.
She watched the blonde two people away just shrug and scoot over in front of her. Before Charli could protest, Madi pulled Charli's shirt, slamming their lips together.
Madi tasted of bubblegum, which was quite sweet if Charli was being honest.
Madi's tongue was much different than Chase's. His tongue was almost scaly and felt rough but Madi's felt more familiar to a pillow.
As they pulled away they noticed everyone's eyes on them, accompanied by gaping mouths.
"Damn got the wrong sister."
Charli spun the bottle hoping for Addison or something, just because she knew her sister wouldn't mind.
But as it stopped Charli's mouth fell once again. Avani.
Avani looked over at him for almost approval, before he just nodded with a smirk on his face. She turned back to face me and scooted forward since she was right in front of me.
"Hi." I smiled and was about to reply before they grabbed my neck and pulled my body into hers.
Very surprisingly, Avani showed no struggle of fighting for dominance. Her tongue danced nicely with Charli in a melodic rhythm.
But it soon came to an end, Charli's smile inside the kiss fading.
She looked up and saw Avani attacking Anthony's lips. "God I missed your lips already." Charli just hid her sadness, wiping away a stray tear and continued playing.
Everyone was now going to sleep at random spots in Charli's home that her parent's laid out.
But she decided to just stay in her room, as she wasn't in the mood to socialize.
But as she was going upstairs, she spotted a familiar blonde leaning against the counter, and decided to approach her.
"Hey Madi. What's up?" Madi looked up and smiled slightly. "Hey Char. Nothing much just sending Sebs last hoodie."
Madi clicked the last button she needed to before putting her phone away.
"Night Char." Madi walked in the direction of the living room, more than likely going to lay down on the spot on the couch she was assigned to.
But before she could go, Charli stopped her.
"Hey Madi? Why don't you stay upstairs tonight?
Madi smiled brightly back.
Maybe she should focus on someone new.