Forsaken | Chance x Mafioso x BunnyCryptid!Reader
Figured I'd try a little mix after my last post and I wanna be more daring but I'm still worried about reactions tbh... ANYWAYS ENJOY-
The Reader's pronouns here will be She/They (⸝⸝๑﹏๑⸝⸝)
Slight warning for obsessive behaviour and maybe even yandere? Idk if I did it right though-
You felt a little humiliated.
You were a Cryptid, yeah, and intimidating to most...
But you also had the appearance of a huge bunny... Which made the intimidation factor rely on your size rather than your appearance.
It was humiliating but you dealt with it, opting to just stay away from Robloxians and hiding away in a park where you could hide.
Even in your Robloxian form though, you still had the ears and tail. You looked ridiculous but at least you could still eat whatever you liked, given you were technically a prey animal too.
Naturally, it was a shock when you fell asleep enjoying the warm sun and woke back up in a cold cabin, surrounded by strangers. Your black fur and red eyes made one of them call you a demon jokingly, which you rolled your eyes at.
But you still didn't want to trust any of them. Instead opting to hearing them out at least and giving them your name in a creepy tone. You were hoping they'd leave you alone for the most part after they figured out your abilities were mostly healing and speed based so they expected you to work with Elliot.
Lucky for him, he made sure to tell you you don't need to work with him if you didn't want to. It wasn't lucky because you would've been hostile but the moment you revealed your Robloxian form was when one of them fell for you. And he fell HARD. You were luckily too absorbed in your own thoughts to notice his staring though as you simply went out to explore.
Chance was quick to follow, trying to make small talk but flinching as you stomped the ground in indication not to be bothered right now. That didn't stop him from trying at least a couple more times but he eventually got the message and let you be. Although maybe he shouldn't have.
Because you immediately began exploring further out, ignoring earlier warnings as you figured you'd be fast enough even if something happened with your sensitive hearing being as good as it is.
What you couldn't have known was that there was a killer both silent in their step and would take a special interest in a bunny cryptid like yourself.
You were pretty far out already by the time you decided to try the different plants of this hellscape. You were curious if they tasted any different but they were surprisingly exactly like what you would have back at the park. Although, that made your leg stomp a bit in frustration as you actually kinda looked forward to experiencing new tastes.
And then, a twig behind you snapped.
You were already about to run but shortly pulled back by the scruff of your fur, which was just one of those furry scarfs that one would see celebrities sometimes wear while you were in your current form.
You instinctively curled up and held onto the scarf for dear life, not wanting to risk losing it only to accidentally get married by Selkie standards. You didn't exactly dare to scream since you were pretty sure no one would hear you as you closed your eyes and waited for a world of pain...
Except... It never came...?
You looked hesitantly at the man holding you and he just smirked at you. "Gotcha, little bunny." He chuckled, amused as you looked a little disturbed, unsure wether this was better or worse...
"Ya must be new, the name's Mafioso." Really? What kinda name is that? You honestly hoped he didn't choose it himself so you could at least try to feel pity for him.
You were hesitant to give your own name but sighed, figuring even though he's a killer, you might get out alive if you play nice. "[Reader]... Can you... Maybe let me go?" You asked cautiously, not wanting to risk his temper but feeling your hands getting sore from holding so tightly onto the scarf that was your fur.
"What's wrong with this?" He asked lightly, clearly amused by your struggle but you just told him you were of the Selkie variety and he seemed to understand, letting you to the ground but refusing to let you leave.
Welp, you found yourself in some deep shit now...
Or... Maybe not...
With a bang, you were suddenly dragged away, leaving Mafioso behind as you were brought back to the cabin by none other than Chance.
You were gonna ask how he knew where you were but he cut you off.
"You were suddenly gone and I wandered around to see where you went and saw you two just in time." His voice almost sounded jealous, but you decided to brush it off for now. Not because you didn't believe he was but rather that you thought he was more jealous because the killer was being friendly with you and not the others.
You decided to thank him, even bowing as you were accustomed to being formal. Old habits from when you were a palace bunny in the old times, being showered with anything you wanted and more all in exchange for your services as a companion. He was a little flustered but told you it was the least he could to to help another survivor.
Right... That was your role now.
Nonetheless, you decided to take the rest of the time to yourself until your first round. You weren't exactly tired but you did want to explore. Chance did say he wanted to go to sleep but you kept feeling eyes on you as you rummaged through the kitchen and eventually made yourself a salad. Why? Because you were in the mood for tomatoes but eating them as is gives you a weird feeling.
But you still couldn't shake of the feeling you were being watched, no matter how many times you checked...
And it persisted over time. Strangely enough, you never really worried when Mafioso was the killer. He seemed to completely ignore you most of the time but at some point Chance seemed to be shown mercy too. Or- at least LMS...
Yeah, Mafioso obviously didn't like losing, you got that. But you had better chances when you were always LMS. It was still painful as shit but it was better than what Elliot had to go through all the time because he was usually the designated healer. Poor guy...
What did surprise you that some rounds, Mafioso would even mutter an apology- HOLD ON WHAT-
Not only that but Chance started getting more clingy. At first you were annoyed but now it was just routine. Get the round done, watch as Chance ran right to you to call you his good luck charm and discuss with the others what the plan should be for the next round once you all knew who was being summoned.
And when you and Chance happen to get to be amongst the ones not chosen for a round? Well...
He'd insist on grooming your fur or even brushing your hair. It took weeks for you to give into his demands but the sensation always made you tired enough that you would sometimes just fall asleep right then and there.
But if you and Mafioso were out of a round while Chase was in?
You two would just have a nice little chat in the spot you met and return before the round ends with random stuff on you to make the other survivors less suspicious of your activities. Most of them just shrugged it off as a Cryptid thing of some kind but Chance knew.
It was just that by the time he figured it out, he and Mafioso had made a deal behind your back. A deal to keep you safe and share you between them.
The shock came when you caught them both chatting in the spot you would usually chat up Mafioso in. You didn't exactly mind it but their embarrassed expressions had you take a different meaning to the scene.
You actually teased them, thinking they were secretly dating.
Which... They were but they weren't embarrassed about that.
You had wanted to turn around and leave with a chuckle but they both decided to stop you and it surprised you enough that you stopped dead in your tracks to look at them again.
Chance had been the one to stop you and he immediately got nervous as he had to let your hand go. "There's more..." You just looked at them confused as they both began to hold your hands and hid their faced under their hats. Admittedly, it was adorable... WAIT NO-
You got a little tense as you heard Mafioso speak first. "Little bunny, we want you all to ourselves..." Hold on what-
"You're more than a lucky charm, your beauty is addictive and we've been hooked on it for so long..." HOLD ON-
"Please, let us be the only ones to make you happy... We know it's selfish but we can't share you with anyone else..." Why was your face flushed red now...?
You could've sworn you heard chance mutter something about the other survivors being 'unworthy' or something but you were too flustered to care. Your brain was raising all kinds of red flags but for once... You decided to follow your heart. As impulsive as it could be.
"Fine..." You barely uttered out your response before they both gave you a cheeky kiss on the knuckles. Though, you quickly pulled your hands away. "I'm not a damn damsel!" You exclaimed, still flustered as they stood up again and Chance was the first to steal a kiss from your lips. It came unexpected but you allowed yourself to melt into it, only to pull away and have Mafioso lift you up by your waist to steal one too.
Great, you got yourself into quite a mess but they weren't nearly done, feverishly taking turns holding you and kissing you like it was a competition. All the while your brain was turning to mush. Able to think about nothing but their kisses. Just as they wanted.
Sometimes they'd even sneak in a kiss against your ears or brushing their hands so gently over your skin that you'd get goosebumps.
They were actively trying to get you as addicted to them as they were to you...
You could've also sworn they were discussing something about the next round whenever they gave you a minute to make sure you didn't suffocate between them...
I might have issues- (╥﹏╥)
Anything you'd like to request/ask? Check out my pinned post first and I'll be happy to write up whatever you want!













