Ah, superheroes origins and average people inside them! Have they always been here?
50/50. On the one hand, standalone stories about random cops, Jim's personal adventures, etc took up space in the old comics. Their appearance varied from decade to decade, but you can easily find them on the Batman pages in the 60s and inside Detective Comics of the early 80s.
However, these were more random stories from individual authors. Year One was a true revolution in DC's superhero narrative, establishing the place of Gotham, the Department, and a little thieves as a key component of Batman's plots. In other words
It's not just the foundation of everything in Dark Knight after the Great Crisis. No. It's the foundation of the entire Batverse itself.
And you can see how the authors developed ideas about not so powerful, inexperienced, protector of the weak in Legends of the Dark Knight. How Gotham became a modern comic book hero thanks to Scott Snyder. How Catwoman blended elements of luxury, street life and unusual roots into one person.
Moreover, Year One is the start of the important Year Trilogy for understanding Bruce's psychology. Also it's basically modern approach - visual style is important, deep cinematic narration, feelings behind hero, plot twists, idea of fight with something much bigger than Gotham itself.
Now that we've dealt with the importance of the comic on the outside, let's talk about the inside. It's a start of Jim's long run. Trouble with his wife and new love in the form of his partner. Problems with being a father and a cop in a dirty system. An unbearability of living in the city where psychos trying to kill their own family have become the norm. All of these things will shape the image of the commissioner in the past, present or even...
...a future...
How does he do it? Well, details make things happen. On the first panels we see the man. Very tired but generally believing in a bright future. The reality of Gotham forces him to act differently. More brutal and severe. But at the same time, he remains an honest man. Frank Miller asks the reader to believe in Jim as much as Jim himself believes in the rule of law. So even when he plays dirty...
It's still about the letter of the Law. Miller makes visual storytelling the backbone of the show. The colors, the shifting beauty and dirt of the city, the variety of streets and the people on them captivate the imagination.
In the finale of the first issue, we get Bruce drowning in devastating thoughts. Trying to help isn't working. His life has been wasted. Or it is not? Of course, criminals are a cowardly and superstitious lot. He got his answer! He's supposed to become a Bat!
Bruce, Jim, even Selina...it's just a symptom. They become the answer to Gotham's call to free itself from the old order, where there are only mad kings and the oppressed poor soul.
We either fight to the death of the enemy or we die ourselves. To defeat monsters, we become monsters ourselves.
And now you're thinking: Hey, crazy fellow, we've all read the Batman classics! Why are you saying all of this clear conclusions?
Because we will never learn what are adaptations without the original. A comic book is a product of its time. When Batman was just beginning his modern journey. When his Darkness was everywhere. When Robin died, when the Batfamily was only a distant Dick and a rare visitor, Barbara. When Tim didn't know how to handle his life.
Batman: Year One is the answer to the question of who Batman is after his reboot, the reboot of all of DC. As universe, as publisher, as one (of two) biggest gamers at picture stories wildspace in its renaissance.
The End of Part One. High Volume YO cycle.














