Unpopular opinion: I actually think Dutch use to be a good man and really did love the gang, but due to poor decision making, outside stress, his own personal issues, and losing people he just went off the deep end and become unhinged. Like Dutch in the beginning of RDR2 vs RDR1 Dutch? Very different.
I honestly think the bonk Dutch gets during the SD trolley mission really affected him, like he probably suffered a head injury cause they reallllly emphasized that. And along with that and all the stuff you listed, it resulted in his downfall.
tbf I’ve never seen Dutch as a villain, even in the first game, so yah big agree with this!!


















